AI-assisted modeling and Bayesian inference of unpolarized quark transverse momentum distributions from Drell–Yan data

Zhong-Bo Kang, Luke Sellers, Congyue Zhang, and Curtis Zhou · 2026

Read AI-assisted modeling and Bayesian inference of unpolarized quark transverse momentum distributions from Drell–Yan data by Zhong-Bo Kang, Luke Sellers, Congyue Zhang, and Curtis Zhou (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-14133.txt.

Introduction

Kang and three colleagues extract unpolarized quark transverse-momentum distributions from Drell-Yan data using Bayesian inference with machine learning woven through the analysis. An AI-guided search ranks candidate shapes for the nonperturbative parts and the evolution kernel, while a trained emulator stands in for costly cross-section calculations during sampling. The global fit spans fixed-target, RHIC, and LHC data, and its uncertainty bands differ visibly from those of the replica method.

Catalog record

CREATORZhong-Bo Kang, Luke Sellers, Congyue Zhang, and Curtis Zhou
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE97734
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.14133

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI-assisted modeling and Bayesian inference of unpolarized quark transverse momentum distributions from Drell–Yan data Zhong-Bo Kang, Luke Sellers, Congyue Zhang, and Curtis Zhou Abstract We present an extraction of unpolarized quark transverse-momentum-dependent parton distribution functions (TMD PDFs) from Drell–Yan data within a Bayesian inference framework, incorporating artificial intelligence at multiple stages of the analysis. Our analysis is performed at N 3 ​ LO {\rm N^{3}LO} in perturbative QCD combined with N 4 ​ LL {\rm N^{4}LL} resummation accuracy. We first employ an AI-driven iterative procedure to explore and rank candidate functional forms for the nonperturbative contributions to TMD PDFs at the initial scale, as well as for the Collins-Soper evolution kernel, using χ 2 \chi^{2} fits and physics constraints. To enable efficient Bayesian inference, we construct a surrogate model for TMD cross sections by training a machine-learning emulator over the parameter space, replacing computationally expensive repeated evaluations and allowing scalable sampling with an affine-invariant Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) ensemble. Using this framework, we perform a global analysis of Drell-Yan data from fixed-target, RHIC, and LHC experiments and extract TMD PDFs with quantified uncertainties. We compare the results with those obtained using the replica method and highlight differences in the resulting uncertainty estimates. 1 Introduction Transverse-momentum dependent parton distribution functions (TMD PDFs) provide a three-dimensional picture of the proton in momentum space, encoding both the longitudinal and transverse motion of partons Accardi:2012qut . They play a central role in processes characterized by multiple scales, in particular when a hard scale Q is accompanied by a much smaller transverse momentum q_{T}\ll Q . In this regime, TMD factorization Collins:2011zzd ; Boussarie:2023izj enables a systematic resummation of large logarithms of q_{T}/Q and provides a framework for precision QCD phenomenology. With the increasing precision of Drell–Yan measurements from fixed-target, RHIC, Tevatron, and LHC experiments, together with the future Electron-Ion Collider program AbdulKhalek:2021gbh ; Alexandrou:2026cnj , reliable extractions of TMD PDFs and their uncertainties have become increasingly important. In recent years, TMD phenomenology has undergone substantial progress driven by both theoretical and methodological developments. On the theory side, perturbative ingredients entering TMD factorization are now known to very high accuracy, enabling phenomenological analyses at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order (N 3 LO) combined with next-to-next-to-next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic (N 4 LL) resummation Moos:2025sal . On the phenomenology side, global analyses combining multiple processes, such as Drell–Yan and semi-inclusive deep-inelastic scattering (SIDIS), have enabled increasingly comprehensive determinations of TMD PDFs and fragmentation functions, including studies of flavor dependence and correlations with collinear PDFs Bacchetta:2024qre . More recently, simultaneous fits of TMD and collinear distributions have been performed Barry:2025glq , highlighting the deep connection between these frameworks and improving constraints on proton structure. In parallel, neural-network parametrizations have been introduced Bacchetta:2025ara to provide flexible, data-driven descriptions of the nonperturbative components, offering improved descriptions of experimental data compared to traditional functional forms. Furthermore, the combination of experimental data with lattice QCD inputs has recently been explored Avkhadiev:2025wps , particularly for the determination of the Collins–Soper kernel, offering new avenues to reduce theoretical uncertainties. Despite this progress, a central challenge remains the reliable quantification of uncertainties in TMD extractions. Most existing analyses rely on the Monte Carlo replica method, in which pseudodata are generated according to the experimental covariance matrix and refitted to produce an ensemble of parameter sets. This approach is intuitive, widely used, and well established in hadronic phenomenology, and has proven successful in a broad range of TMD extractions Moos:2025sal ; Bacchetta:2024qre ; Bacchetta:2024yzl ; Barry:2025glq ; Bacchetta:2025ara ; Avkhadiev:2025wps ; Echevarria:2020hpy ; Alrashed:2021csd . Bayesian inference offers a complementary framework for uncertainty quantification, in which the full posterior probability distribution of the model parameters is constructed given the data and a specified prior. This approach has been successfully applied in several neighboring areas, including collinear PDF fitting Candido:2024bayesGP ; Capel:2024qkm , small- x dipole amplitude determination Casuga:2025etc ; Mantysaari:2025ltq , heavy-ion phenomenology PhysRevC.94.024907 ; JETSCAPE:2026chun , neutron-star inference PhysRevD.99.084049 ; PhysRevD.111.034005 , and joint analyses across multiple sectors Huth:2022 . Bayesian methods provide a direct probabilistic interpretation of uncertainties, make prior assumptions explicit, and naturally incorporate marginalization over nuisance parameters. Furthermore, the Bayesian framework readily accommodates the combination of heterogeneous information sources, such as experimental data and lattice QCD inputs, within a unified probabilistic description. At a general level, the relation between frequentist resampling methods (such as the replica approach) and Bayesian inference has been extensively studied in the statistical literature Efron:1994bootstrap ; Stuart_2010 ; Kass1990TheVO . However, their quantitative comparison in realistic TMD extractions remains limited. Given the widespread use of both approaches, it is therefore natural to compare them directly when estimating uncertainties. Such comparisons go beyond a simple cross-check: they can help identify which aspects of an inference problem are most sensitive to the choice of methodology and clarify the regimes in which one framework may provide a more reliable description. In this sense, replica and Bayesian methods are best viewed not as competing alternatives, but as complementary probes of the uncertainty structure of TMD fits. In this work, we present a global extraction of unpolarized quark TMD PDFs from Drell–Yan data within a Bayesian inference framework, incorporating artificial intelligence (AI) at multiple stages of the analysis. Our theoretical setup is based on TMD factorization at high perturbative accuracy, enabling a precise description of the perturbative components. To address the modeling of the nonperturbative sector, we employ an AI-driven workflow to systematically explore and rank candidate functional forms for the TMD PDFs and the Collins–Soper kernel, subject to theoretical constraints and phenomenological criteria. This procedure allows for a broader and less biased exploration of the ansatz space compared to traditional approaches. A key technical ingredient of our analysis is the use of a machine-learning emulator to accelerate the evaluation of TMD cross sections. Bayesian inference requires repeated likelihood evaluations across a high-dimensional parameter space, which would be computationally prohibitive using direct theory calculations. By training a neural-network surrogate model on a set of exact predictions, we enable efficient posterior sampling using Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods while maintaining high accuracy. Within the same theoretical and phenomenological framework, we also perform a replica-based analysis, allowing for a direct comparison between Bayesian and replica uncertainty estimates. This comparison provides insight into the robustness of the extracted uncertainties, the role of parameter correlations, and the extent to which different inference methodologies capture the underlying structure of the parameter space. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. 2 , we review the theoretical framework for TMD factorization in Drell–Yan production. Sec. 3 describes the experimental datasets used in the analysis. In Sec. 4 , we present the fit setup, including the AI-driven exploration of nonperturbative parameterizations and a brief review of the replica method as a non-Bayesian reference. The Bayesian inference framework and emulator construction are detailed in Sec. 5 . The results, including a comparison between Bayesian and replica uncertainties, are presented in Sec. 6 . We conclude in Sec. 7 , and provide technical details on the uncertainty analysis, along with the posterior distributions, in the appendix. 2 Theoretical formalism 2.1 Drell–Yan process and kinematics We consider unpolarized neutral-current Drell–Yan production, h_{1}(P_{1})+h_{2}(P_{2})\to\gamma^{*}/Z(q)\to\ell^{+}(l)+\ell^{-}(l^{\prime})+X, (1) where h_{1} and h_{2} are the incoming hadrons with momenta P_{1}^{\mu} and P_{2}^{\mu} ,

Read the complete text