Unsupervised Anomaly Detection in Process-Complex Industrial Time Series: A Real-World Case Study

1 st Sergej Krasnikov * Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0009-0008-1034-7290 2 nd Lukas Meitz * Technische Hochschule Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 3 rd Samineh Bagheri Independent Researcher Karlsruhe, Germany email address or ORCID 4 th Michael Heider Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0000-0003-3140-1993 5 th Thorsten Schöler Technische Hochschule Augsburg Augsburg, Germany email address or ORCID 6 th Jörg Hähner Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0000-0003-0107-264X * These authors contributed equally to this work. · 2026

Read Unsupervised Anomaly Detection in Process-Complex Industrial Time Series: A Real-World Case Study by 1 st Sergej Krasnikov * Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0009-0008-1034-7290 2 nd Lukas Meitz * Technische Hochschule Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 3 rd Samineh Bagheri Independent Researcher Karlsruhe, Germany email address or ORCID 4 th Michael Heider Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0000-0003-3140-1993 5 th Thorsten Schöler Technische Hochschule Augsburg Augsburg, Germany email address or ORCID 6 th Jörg Hähner Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0000-0003-0107-264X * These authors contributed equally to this work. (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13928.txt.

Introduction

Krasnikov and colleagues test anomaly detection on real factory time series, where multi-stage processes make the data far messier than standard benchmarks. A classic Isolation Forest baseline misses the uneven, multi-scale patterns in the data. Autoencoders do consistently better across the board. Temporal convolutional autoencoders prove most robust. Recurrent and variational versions need more careful tuning to match them. In short, simple tools fail on real plant data.

Catalog record

CREATOR1 st Sergej Krasnikov * Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0009-0008-1034-7290 2 nd Lukas Meitz * Technische Hochschule Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 3 rd Samineh Bagheri Independent Researcher Karlsruhe, Germany email address or ORCID 4 th Michael Heider Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0000-0003-3140-1993 5 th Thorsten Schöler Technische Hochschule Augsburg Augsburg, Germany email address or ORCID 6 th Jörg Hähner Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0000-0003-0107-264X * These authors contributed equally to this work.
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27100
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13928

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unsupervised Anomaly Detection in Process-Complex Industrial Time Series: A Real-World Case Study 1 st Sergej Krasnikov * Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0009-0008-1034-7290 2 nd Lukas Meitz * Technische Hochschule Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 3 rd Samineh Bagheri Independent Researcher Karlsruhe, Germany email address or ORCID 4 th Michael Heider Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0000-0003-3140-1993 5 th Thorsten Schöler Technische Hochschule Augsburg Augsburg, Germany email address or ORCID 6 th Jörg Hähner Universität Augsburg Augsburg, Germany [email protected] 0000-0003-0107-264X * These authors contributed equally to this work. Abstract Industrial time-series data from real production environments exhibits substantially higher complexity than commonly used benchmark datasets, primarily due to heterogeneous, multi-stage operational processes. As a result, anomaly detection methods validated under simplified conditions often fail to generalize to industrial settings. This work presents an empirical study on a unique dataset collected from fully operational industrial machinery, explicitly capturing pronounced process-induced variability. We evaluate which model classes are capable of capturing this complexity, starting with a classical Isolation Forest baseline and extending to multiple autoencoder architectures. Experimental results show that Isolation Forest is insufficient for modeling the non-periodic, multi-scale dynamics present in the data, whereas autoencoders consistently perform better. Among them, temporal convolutional autoencoders achieve the most robust performance, while recurrent and variational variants require more careful tuning. I Introduction Industrial environments generate large volumes of multivariate time-series data from heterogeneous sensors monitoring machinery and its executed processes. These streams are often high-dimensional, non-periodic, and exhibit multi-scale temporal dynamics, reflecting complex operational sequences and noise-prone conditions. Detecting deviations from normal behavior in such settings is a key prerequisite for reliable Machine Health monitoring and Predictive Maintenance. Classical anomaly detection methods such as Isolation Forest (IF) are attractive in industrial practice due to their simplicity, low computational cost, and label-free training. However, they typically rely on learning static feature distributions and struggle when normal behavior is defined by non-stationary, multi-stage processes with variable temporal structure. This raises the question of whether classical methods remain viable under pronounced process-induced complexity, or whether representation-learning models are required. Our study is built upon a proprietary dataset, that has been collected from more than 100 connected devices of the same type. This real-world dataset contains all of the complexity that naturally comes with operation and usage in production scenarios, which makes it a valuable resource for studying the effect of complexity on different model architectures. To address this subject effectively, we evaluate the capability of a simpler model, the Isolation Forest (IF) , to serve as a basis of comparison and implement six Autoencoder (AE) configurations: three standard and three variational—implemented with Temporal Convolutional Network (TCN) , Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) , and Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU) architectures. The models are trained and tested on our proprietary industrial dataset characterized by non-periodic, multi-scale process dynamics and sensor-rich recordings, reflecting typical challenges in machine monitoring environments. In summary, this work makes the following contributions: 1. We systematically evaluate anomaly detection methods of varying complexity on industrial time-series. 2. We present a controlled empirical study comparing autoencoder architectures—convolutional versus recurrent, deterministic versus variational—in their ability to model process-complex (see II-B ) industrial sequences, addressing a gap in the literature where such systematic comparisons remain rare. 3. We show that architectural alignment with temporal structure is more critical than model complexity: convolutional networks outperform recurrent alternatives through better capture of multi-scale process dynamics in real-world industrial data. Our findings highlight architectural and representational trade-offs, with convolutional standard AEs demonstrating superior performance on complex industrial data. While the results are derived from a single industrial application, the observed performance differences are driven by structural properties—non-periodicity, variable phase ordering, and process-induced non-stationarity—that are common across many real-world industrial processes. Fig. 1 : Plot of a process sample from the dataset, showing readings from four selected sensors captured during a single run executed on one machine. Each sensor records different physical quantities over time, exhibiting distinct behaviors including stable operational phases, gradual drifts, and abrupt changes indicative of process transitions or anomalies. The view of the data has been deliberately perturbed to protect sensitive operational information, while preserving the underlying structure and complexity. II Background Anomaly detection in time-series data has been extensively studied across domains such as healthcare, manufacturing, and infrastructure monitoring. In industrial settings, both classical and deep learning–based approaches are commonly employed, often under limited labeling and strict deployment constraints. However, a systematic understanding of how different model classes and architectures behave under realistic, process-induced complexity remains limited. II-A Classical and Autoencoder-Based Anomaly Detection Classical anomaly detection methods, including IFs and related feature-based techniques, have long been used in industrial monitoring due to their simplicity, scalability, and low data requirements. These methods typically operate on static feature representations and implicitly assume stationarity, which limits their ability to model non-periodic, multi-stage process dynamics commonly observed in real production environments. In recent years, deep learning approaches—particularly autoencoder-based models—have demonstrated their potential for unsupervised time-series anomaly detection. Autoencoders learn compact latent representations from unlabeled data and identify anomalies via reconstruction error [ 9 ] . Their effectiveness has been shown across a wide range of applications, including industrial systems and predictive maintenance. Recent surveys provide comprehensive overviews of deep anomaly detection methods and highlight the large design space of autoencoder architectures [ 15 ] . A variety of autoencoder variants have been proposed to model temporal dependencies in time-series data. Recurrent architectures based on LSTM and GRU units are widely used for sequential modeling and have been applied to feature extraction and anomaly detection in industrial and energy systems [ 14 ] . Extensions incorporating memory mechanisms [ 3 ] or attention-based designs, such as OmniAnomaly [ 10 ] , aim to improve robustness in multivariate settings. In parallel, TCNs leverage dilated convolutions to capture long-range dependencies with stable training behavior and have shown strong performance in healthcare, manufacturing, and general anomaly detection tasks [ 11 , 1 , 8 , 5 ] . Variational Autoencoders (VAEs) extend standard autoencoders by learning probabilistic latent representations and have been explored for dimensionality reduction [ 12 ] , weakly supervised anomaly detection [ 13 ] , and data augmentation [ 2 ] . Despite their theoretical appeal, empirical evidence for consistent advantages of variational formulations over standard AEs in industrial anomaly detection remains mixed. Recent industrial-focused surveys further emphasize that many deep anomaly detection methods are still predominantly evaluated on simplified or benchmark-style datasets, limiting conclusions about their robustness under realistic operational variability [ 7 ] . II-B Need for Complexity-Aware Evaluation Although a wide range of anomaly detection architectures has been proposed, few studies systematically compare classical and AE -based models across convolutional, recurrent, and variational designs under realistic industrial conditions. Prior work has noted that general-purpose models often underperform when confronted with heterogeneous, non-stationary processes [ 11 ] . Recent research has argued that such evaluation gaps are closely tied to unmodeled sources of machine- and process-induced complexity, motivating the use of explicit complexity taxonomies to reason about dataset characteristics and model assumptions [ 6 ] . Following this taxonomy, we call our dataset process-complex, as it includes complexity predominantly induced by the process that is being monitored. Addressing this gap is essential for

Read the complete text