Simulation-Based Optimisation of Batting Order and Bowling Plans in T20 Cricket
Tinniam V Ganesh · 2026
Read Simulation-Based Optimisation of Batting Order and Bowling Plans in T20 Cricket by Tinniam V Ganesh (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13861.txt.
Introduction
Ganesh optimizes T20 batting orders and bowling plans with a Markov Decision Process framework, scoring by win and defend chances rather than expected runs. A three-phase profile engine for Powerplay, Middle, and Death uses James-Stein shrinkage, blending sparse phase statistics toward league averages. Profiles come from 1,161 IPL records from 2008 to 2025, with probabilities from Monte Carlo simulation over 50,000 innings. In two 2026 IPL matches, the Mumbai Indians order lifts win probability by 4.1 percentage points, and the Gujarat Titans plan lifts defend probability by 5.2 points.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tinniam V Ganesh |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43762 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13861
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Simulation-Based Optimisation of Batting Order and Bowling Plans in T20 Cricket Thanks: Submitted to the Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports (JQAS), April 2026. Tinniam V Ganesh Abstract Abstract This paper develops a unified Markov Decision Process (MDP) framework for optimising two recurring in-match decisions in T20 cricket, namely batting order selection and bowling plan assignment, directly in terms of win and defend probability rather than expected runs. A three-phase player profile engine (Powerplay, Middle, Death) with James–Stein shrinkage (a technique that blends a player’s individual statistics toward the league average when their phase-specific data is sparse) is estimated from 1,161 IPL ball-by-ball records (2008–2025). Win/defend probabilities are evaluated using vectorised Monte Carlo simulation over N=50{,}000 innings trajectories. Batting orders are evaluated by comparing all feasible arrangements of the remaining players and selecting the one that maximises win probability. Bowling plans are optimised through a guided search over possible over assignments, progressively improving the allocation while respecting constraints such as the prohibition on consecutive overs by the same bowler. Applied to two 2026 IPL matches, the optimal batting order improves Mumbai Indians’ win probability by 4.1 percentage points (52.4% to 56.5%), and the optimal Gujarat Titans bowling plan improves defend probability by 5.2 percentage points (39.1% to 44.3%). In both cases, the observed sub-optimality is consistent with phase-agnostic deployment: decisions that appear reasonable under aggregate metrics are shown to be costly when phase-specific profiles are applied. Keywords: T20 cricket; batting order optimisation; bowling plan optimisation; Markov Decision Process; Monte Carlo simulation; simulated annealing; James–Stein shrinkage; sports analytics; Indian Premier League 1. Introduction The Twenty20 (T20) format has compressed professional cricket into 120 deliveries per side, yet within that frame a single over can determine the outcome. In the Indian Premier League (IPL), where franchise valuations exceed one billion USD and playoff positions hinge on net run rate, the quality of two recurring tactical decisions is decisive: which batsman to promote at each wicket fall, and which bowler to assign to each remaining over. Both decisions are sequential and state-dependent. The batting captain must balance aggression against preservation given the current match state (runs remaining, balls remaining, wickets in hand) and the batsmen still available. The bowling captain must assign bowlers subject to the T20 quota (maximum four overs per bowler) and the consecutive-over rule, while accounting for phase-specific economy and wicket-taking ability. Both decisions are therefore naturally modelled as Markov Decision Processes (Bellman, 1957; Puterman, 1994), with the objective of maximising a probability — that runs scored cross a target, or that runs conceded stay below it — rather than an expectation. Prior linear programming approaches (Ganesh, 2017) optimise expected runs, but maximising expected runs does not maximise win probability — especially when the match is close and a team needs a specific number of runs rather than simply as many as possible. This paper makes the following contributions: 1. A unified MDP framework that models batting order and bowling plan optimisation on a common state space with symmetric Bellman equations, making explicit the duality between the batting win probability and the bowling defend probability. 2. A three-phase player profile engine using Laplace smoothing and James–Stein shrinkage that estimates per-ball outcome distributions for batsmen and bowlers in Powerplay (overs 1–6), Middle (overs 7–15), and Death (overs 16–20) phases separately, from 1,161 historical IPL matches. 3. Simulation-based search : for batting, all feasible orderings of the remaining players are evaluated and the one maximising win probability is selected; for bowling, a guided search progressively improves the over assignment while respecting constraints such as the prohibition on consecutive overs by the same bowler. Both directly optimise win/defend probability over the stochastic innings model, validated at N=50{,}000 simulations per configuration (Monte Carlo SE \approx 0.22\% ). 4. Two detailed case studies from the 2026 IPL season, providing quantitative audits of actual in-match decisions: the batting and bowling decisions in KKR vs. MI (29 March 2026) and the bowling decisions in GT vs. PBKS (31 March 2026). The two cases span different match contexts: one where the bowling gap is large (+18.1 pp) and one where it is modest (+5.2 pp), enabling a comparative analysis of the conditions under which sub-optimal decisions have the greatest impact. The paper is structured as follows. Section 2 reviews related work. Section 3 presents the MDP framework. Section 4 describes the player profile engine. Section 5 presents the Monte Carlo simulation. Section 6 covers the search algorithms. Sections 7 and 8 present the two case studies and their results. Section 9 provides a comparative analysis and discussion of limitations. Section 10 concludes. 2. Related Work The Duckworth–Lewis method (Duckworth and Lewis, 1998) implicitly defines a resource table over (runs needed, balls remaining, wickets in hand), the same state space used in this paper, for resetting targets in interrupted matches. It remains the de facto standard in international cricket and establishes that match state can be meaningfully quantified. The author’s earlier work (Ganesh, 2017) formulated batting lineup and bowling selection as linear programming problems, assigning ball-level encounters o_{ij} between player i and bowler j to maximise aggregate strike rate (batting) or minimise aggregate economy rate (bowling). That formulation correctly identifies that the allocation of playing time across player matchups matters, but it optimises expected runs rather than win probability and cannot encode the sequential, constraint-rich structure of T20 over assignment. The present paper replaces the LP objective with a stochastic MDP framework whose objective directly matches the match outcome: a win probability threshold rather than an expectation. The MDP framework and Bellman equations are due to Bellman (1957) and Puterman (1994). The James–Stein shrinkage estimator applied to sparse player profiles follows James and Stein (1961). The simulated annealing search for bowling plans draws on Kirkpatrick, Gelatt, and Vecchi (1983). 3. The MDP Framework 3.1 State Space and Match Dynamics Let the match state at any ball be the triple: \mathcal{S}=(r,\,b,\,w) where r\in\{1,\ldots,R_{\max}\} is the runs remaining for the batting side to win (or, equivalently, for the bowling side to defend), b\in\{0,1,\ldots,B\} is the number of legal balls remaining in the innings ( B=120 in T20), and w\in\{0,1,\ldots,10\} is the number of wickets in hand (batting perspective) or wickets taken (bowling perspective). The Markov property holds: the probability distribution over future match trajectories is fully determined by \mathcal{S} , independent of the history of play. On each legal delivery, one of seven outcomes o\in\Omega=\{W,0,1,2,3,4,6\} is realised, where W denotes the dismissal of the on-strike batsman. The runs-scored function \rho:\Omega\to\{0,1,2,3,4,6\} is defined by \rho(W)=0 and \rho(o)=o for o\neq W ; both a wicket and a dot ball therefore contribute zero runs to the batting total. The outcome o=5 runs (an all-run five) is omitted from \Omega : it occurs in fewer than 0.1% of deliveries in the historical data and its inclusion has negligible effect on computed probabilities. Wides and no-balls are handled at the data-preprocessing stage and are not included in the legal delivery count. 3.2 Batting MDP For the batting side chasing a target, define the win probability value function : V^{B}(r,b,w)=\mathbb{P}\!\left(\text{batting side wins}\;\middle|\;\text{state }(r,b,w),\;\text{order }\sigma\right) Terminal conditions: The batting side wins if and only if the target is reached: V^{B}(r,b,w)=\begin{cases}1&\text{if }r\leq 0\\[4.0pt] 0&\text{if }b=0\text{ or }w=0,\text{ and }r>0\end{cases}