Towards New Hidden Zero and 2 2 -Split of Loop-Level Feynman Integrands in Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) Model

Kang Zhou · 2026

Read Towards New Hidden Zero and 2 2 -Split of Loop-Level Feynman Integrands in Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) Model by Kang Zhou (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13810.txt.

Introduction

Zhou extends hidden zeros and 2-splits from tree-level Tr(phi-cubed) amplitudes to loop-level Feynman integrands, setting aside scaleless integrals. The key is a factorization mechanism in Feynman diagrams under shuffle sums. Loop-level zeros and splits differ from the literature's, yet their kinematic conditions are simple. The zero-to-split link is as tight as at tree level, via the same procedure. The loop-level 2-split formula generalizes the tree one: an L-loop integrand becomes a sum over L-plus-one terms, each with 2-split structure.

Catalog record

CREATORKang Zhou
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77617
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13810

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Towards New Hidden Zero and 2 2 -Split of Loop-Level Feynman Integrands in Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) Model Kang Zhou Abstract We extend the hidden zeros and 2 2 -split of tree-level Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) amplitudes to loop-level Feynman integrands, apart from some physically irrelevant scaleless integrals. Our method is based on a certain factorization mechanism that occurs in Feynman diagrams when summing over shuffle permutations. The loop-level hidden zeros and 2 2 -split identified in this work differ from those in the literature. In our result, the kinematic conditions for loop-level hidden zeros and 2 2 -split are remarkably simple. Their connection is as tight as at tree-level, with the same procedure for obtaining the 2 2 -split condition from the zero condition. The resulting 2 2 -split formula at loop-level represents a generalization of that at tree-level: the L L -loop integrand is expressed as a sum over L + 1 L+1 terms, each of which exhibits a 2 2 -split structure. 1 Introduction In the past few years, the discovery of two novel properties at tree level—hidden zeros and 2 -split—has emerged as a remarkable advancement in the study of scattering amplitudes. Hidden zeros refer to the phenomenon that on special loci in kinematic space, the entire amplitude vanishes identically. First identified in the {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) , non-linear sigma model (NLSM) and Yang-Mills (YM) theories Arkani-Hamed:2023swr , hidden zeros have since been shown to hold across a wider range of models, including the special Galileon, Dirac-Born-Infeld theory, gravity (GR), as well as modified YM and GR with specific higher-derivative corrections Rodina:2024yfc ; Bartsch:2024amu ; Li:2024qfp ; Zhang:2024efe ; Huang:2025blb ; Zhou:2025tvq . By slightly altering these zero loci, another striking property emerges: the 2 -split behavior, where the amplitude factorizes exactly into a product of two lower-point off-shell currents, without the need for taking residue at a pole Cao:2024gln ; Cao:2024qpp ; Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd . These two new properties were initially discovered using modern frameworks such as the associahedron, surfaceology and Cachazo-He-Yuan (CHY) formalism Arkani-Hamed:2023swr ; Cao:2024gln ; Cao:2024qpp ; Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd . In subsequent work, efforts have also been made to understand them from various different perspectives, such as universal expansions of amplitudes, BCFW recursion relation, and traditional Feynman diagrams Zhou:2024ddy ; Feng:2025ofq ; Feng:2025dci . For further research on hidden zeros and 2 -split of tree amplitudes, see Guevara:2024nxd ; Cao:2025hio ; Zhang:2025zjx ; Zhang:2026dcm ; Saha:2026ftv ; Azevedo:2025vxo ; CarrilloGonzalez:2026lnu . The importance of these novel structures extends far beyond mere computational curiosities. They reveal that tree-level amplitudes obey constraints stronger than those dictated by locality and unitarity alone, pointing toward an unexplored geometric foundation of the S-matrix. Moreover, the universality of hidden zeros and 2 -split across scalars, gauge bosons, and gravitons suggests a common kinematic origin, providing fresh insights into the unification of different models. From a practical standpoint, the 2 -split property offers a new computational tool: it reduces higher-point amplitudes to products of lower-point currents, thereby simplifying calculations and enabling new bootstrap strategies. Furthermore, these two newly discovered properties provide novel avenues for addressing the boundary term problem in BCFW recursion relation and for deriving soft theorems of tree amplitudes Li:2025suo ; Zhou:2025xly ; Zhou:2026isc . Given these remarkable tree-level features, a natural and pressing question is whether these two properties persist at loop-level. In Backus:2025hpn , hidden zeros of 1 -loop {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) and NLSM Feynman integrands were studied by means of the kinematic mesh at 1 -loop-level. On the other hand, in Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd , the 2 -split of the loop-level Feynman integrands for {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) was investigated using surfaceology, and its generalizations to NLSM and YM theories were discussed. In this paper, using the Feynman-diagram-based method developed in our previous work Zhou:2024ddy , we find new hidden zeros and 2 -split of loop-level {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) Feynman integrands that differ from those given in the literature Backus:2025hpn ; Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd . Our approach is based on a factorization mechanism exhibited by Feynman diagrams, which we refer to as shuffle factorization along a specific line (SFASL). More concretely, under the kinematic constraints of the hidden zeros or the 2 -split, when various building blocks of Feynman diagrams are attached to a specific line, the result of summing over shuffle permutations factorizes into two independent parts 1 1 1 A similar shuffle factorization also appears in recent studies of cosmological wavefunctions Li:2026gns . . A more detailed explanation of this mechanism will be given in the following sections. In Zhou:2024ddy , this mechanism was used to interpret hidden zeros and 2 -split of tree {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) amplitudes. This mechanism is completely local, concerning only the interaction vertices on a specific line and independent of the structures of other parts of the Feynman diagrams. This feature allows it to apply equally well at loop-level. Therefore, in this paper, we utilize this mechanism to generalize hidden zeros and 2 -split to loop-level. Compared with the hidden zeros and 2 -split of loop-level integrands found in the literature, the kinematic conditions under which the hidden zeros and 2 -split are realized in our new results are simpler and weaker. Moreover, the connection between the kinematic condition for hidden zeros and that for 2 -split remains as tight as at tree-level. In particular, the procedure for obtaining the kinematic condition for 2 -split by relaxing the condition for zeros is exactly the same as that at tree-level. The loop-level 2 -split we obtain is a generalization of its tree-level counterpart. More specifically, after imposing the kinematic condition for 2 -split given in this work, the entire L -loop Feynman integrand reduces to a sum of L+1 terms, each of which exhibits the 2 -split structure. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In section 2 , we review the interpretation of hidden zeros and 2 -split developed in our previous work Zhou:2024ddy , from the Feynman diagram perspective. In particular, we provide a detailed introduction to the mechanism exhibited by Feynman diagrams, which we refer to as SFASL. Based on the diagrammatic method introduced in section 2 , we extend the hidden zeros and 2 -split to the 1 -loop Feynman integrand of {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) model in section 3 . Next, in section 4 , we establish the hidden zeros and 2 -split at higher loops using the same approach. Finally, we present a brief conclusion and discussion in section 5 . 2 Review for hidden zero and 2 -split of tree-level amplitudes in {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) model In this section, we review the interpretation for hidden zeros and 2 -split of tree {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) amplitudes from the Feynman diagram perspective. This material does not arise from the work presented in this paper, but rather from our previous work Zhou:2024ddy . Nevertheless, since this Feynman-diagram-based approach serves as the foundation for studying hidden zeros and 2 -split of loop-level Feynman integrands in subsequent sections, it is necessary to introduce it in detail. The organization and emphasis of this section is significantly different from that of Zhou:2024ddy : we will highlight a mechanism exhibited by Feynman diagrams in the summation over shuffle permutations, which we refer to as SFASL.

Read the complete text