Understanding mechanisms underlying solar cycle predictability with a general framework

Binghang Li, Jie Jiang, Yukun Luo · 2026

Read Understanding mechanisms underlying solar cycle predictability with a general framework by Binghang Li, Jie Jiang, Yukun Luo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13585.txt.

Introduction

Li, Jiang, and Luo ask when the Sun's surface magnetic field can actually forecast the next solar cycle. Applying Stokes' theorem to the induction equation, they link the surface field directly to the dynamo process below and derive a quantitative test for predictive power, applied to five dynamo models. The surface field forecasts well when flux-transport processes feed it back into the dynamo loop, or when it mirrors the interior poloidal field's radial part.

Catalog record

CREATORBinghang Li, Jie Jiang, Yukun Luo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54128
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13585

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Understanding mechanisms underlying solar cycle predictability with a general framework Binghang Li, Jie Jiang, Yukun Luo Abstract Context. The large-scale magnetic field observed at the solar surface is produced by the interior dynamo process. Whether this surface field also provides the dominant seed for the subsequent dynamo cycle, however, remains controversial, with important consequences for the predictive skill of solar dynamo models. Aims. We investigate the physical conditions under which this predictive skill of the surface field arises in dynamo models within a general framework. Methods. By applying Stokes’ theorem to the magnetic induction equation, we establish a direct physical link between the surface magnetic field and the subsequent dynamo process. The dominance of the surface induction integral in the net toroidal flux generation rate provides a quantitative criterion for assessing dynamo predictability, which we apply to five representative dynamo models. Results. This general framework shows that the surface magnetic field acquires predictive power when the surface poloidal field is efficiently coupled back into the dynamo loop through flux-transport processes (e.g., meridional circulation), a condition that can be satisfied in both Babcock–Leighton (BL)–type and α − Ω \alpha-\Omega mean-field dynamo models. The framework further identifies a new condition under which the surface magnetic field acquires predictive power: namely, that it represents the radial component of the interior poloidal field, as in the original BL-type dynamo scenario. In addition, the non-zero net toroidal flux across different dynamo models supports its use as a proxy linking the interior toroidal field to surface flux emergence. 1 Introduction The amplitude of the approximately 11-year solar cycle varies over a wide range, from extended periods of very low activity, such as the Maunder minimum, to episodes of unusually high activity, such as the modern grand maximum in the 1960s ( 41 ; 49 ) . This variability significantly affects the space environment near Earth and numerous aspects of human activity ( 13 ) , motivating efforts to predict solar cycle amplitudes. Since the solar cycle arises from a dynamo process operating within the Sun, prediction schemes based on solar dynamo models with data assimilation are particularly appealing. The first such attempts were made at the end of cycle 23, when two groups predicted cycle 24 using flux-transport dynamo models ( 18 ; 19 ; 12 ; 26 ) . These efforts subsequently prompted debate regarding the feasibility and robustness of solar cycle prediction based on dynamo model outputs ( 48 ; 4 ) . Nevertheless, research along this line has continued. In addition to flux-transport dynamo models ( 25 ; 45 ; 37 ) , \alpha-\Omega mean-field dynamo models have also been applied to solar cycle prediction ( 29 ; 28 ; 30 ) . This body of work raises a key physical question: what are the necessary physical conditions for data assimilation of the surface magnetic field to result in predictive dynamo simulations? The polar magnetic field constitutes a major component of the solar surface field, particularly during cycle minimum, and exhibits a strong correlation with the amplitude of the subsequent solar cycle. 46 first attempted to interpret the polar-field precursor within the framework of a Babcock–Leighton (BL) dynamo ( 1 ; 34 ) . In this class of models, the toroidal magnetic field is generated from a pre-existing poloidal field through shearing by differential rotation (the \Omega -effect). The resulting toroidal flux subsequently emerges to form sunspots and is therefore expected to be correlated with the poloidal field present at the preceding cycle minimum, which is predominantly concentrated in the polar regions. Based on this dynamo interpretation, a number of subsequent studies have attributed the polar-field precursor relationship to the BL mechanism, regarding it as observational support for the operation of the solar dynamo in a BL regime ( 46 ; 39 ) . However, 9 (hereafter CB11) suggested that such an interpretation of the polar-field precursor is not necessarily conclusive. They investigated three distinct stochastic forcing dynamo models and found that the polar field exhibits predictive skill in both a mean-field \alpha-\Omega model with meridional circulation and a BL dynamo model, with nearly identical correlation coefficients in each case. Notably, the predictive skill of the surface polar field disappeared in the \alpha-\Omega model when meridional circulation was omitted. Thus, they concluded that the surface poloidal field only shows predictive skill if it is coupled back into the dynamo loop. At least part of the polar field should be submerged and carried into the tachocline to contribute to the induction of the toroidal magnetic component that will give rise to sunspots of the subsequent cycle. The condition can be satisfied in both BL and mean-field dynamo models. Moreover, interpretations outlined above are based on dynamo models in which the dynamo operates primarily in the tachocline. In such dynamo models, both mean-field and BL types, the surface magnetic field is transported by meridional circulation into the tachocline. There, it feeds back into the dynamo loop by acting as the source to be amplified through the radial shear to generate the toroidal magnetic field ( 43 ; 10 ) . However, in recently developed distributed-shear BL dynamo models ( 55 ; 54 ; 27 ) , toroidal flux is generated in the bulk of the convection zone by latitudinal shear on the internal latitudinal poloidal field. Owing to the imposed condition of vanishing radial diffusion of the surface magnetic field ( 55 ; 35 ) , the polar field cannot be submerged by the meridional flow, and the surface radial magnetic field does not directly participate in the internal dynamo process. Consequently, based on this dynamo model, a natural question arises: whether the assimilation of the surface magnetic field into the BL dynamo can retain predictive skill, and if so, what physical mechanism underlies it. Beyond the unresolved questions, the methodologies commonly employed to assess predictability in dynamo models also warrant reevaluation. The conventional approach typically involves two steps ( 52 ; 9 ; 32 , e.g.,) : first, introducing stochastic forcing into a dynamo model and performing long-term simulations; second, statistically analyzing correlations between the polar field strength at cycle minimum and the amplitude of the subsequent cycle inferred from the model output. This approach has several limitations when applied to the study of dynamo predictability. First, it primarily quantifies the correlation between the polar field at cycle minimum and the following cycle amplitude, rather than directly addressing whether the observed surface magnetic field actively provides the source information for the subsequent dynamo process. Second, the method requires long-term simulations for each dynamo model, which are computationally demanding and model dependent. Third, the inferred predictive skill depends sensitively on the level of stochasticity and nonlinearity prescribed in the model ( 9 ; 32 ) . In addition, because there is no unified parameter that directly quantifies solar cycle strength in dynamo models, different proxies are adopted across studies ( 52 ; 9 ; 23 ; 22 ) , making consistent comparisons between models operating in different regions of the convection zone difficult. These limitations highlight the need for a more general framework that can be applied uniformly across dynamo models while directly probing the capability of predictive skill. The lack of a unified parameter

Read the complete text