Is Productivity Advantage of Cities Really Down To Mean and Variance?

Vladislav Morozov, Andrea Sy · 2026

Read Is Productivity Advantage of Cities Really Down To Mean and Variance? by Vladislav Morozov, Andrea Sy (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13188.txt.

Introduction

Morozov and Sy test whether city productivity edge reduces to shift, dilation, and truncation of firm productivity distributions, following Combes and colleagues' 2012 split. Using Spanish firm-level data and methods robust to noisy estimates, they find curves in denser and less dense areas are indeed identical up to those terms. Shifts and dilations alone suffice, at least in Spain, suggesting policy makers should focus on agglomeration policies.

Catalog record

CREATORVladislav Morozov, Andrea Sy
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22422
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13188

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Is Productivity Advantage of Cities Really Down To Mean and Variance? Vladislav Morozov, Andrea Sy Abstract Firms in denser areas are more productive, a pattern attributed to agglomeration economies and firm selection. To disentangle these two channels, the popular approach of Combes et al. 2012 critically assumes that total factor productivity (TFP) distributions between denser and less dense areas are the same up to mean, variance, and left-tail truncation. We empirically validate this assumption using Spanish administrative firm-level data and recent econometric methods adapted to noisy TFP estimates. Our results find that TFP distributions are indeed statistically identical up to these parameters, validating the use of such productivity decompositions. Furthermore, using only the mean and variance is sufficient to capture differences for all sectors. Accordingly, the productivity advantage of cities may be entirely due to agglomeration rather than stronger selection, suggesting that policymakers should focus on policies targeting agglomeration. Finally, our approach extends to related contexts like differences in worker skill distributions. 1 Introduction Firms in denser areas are systematically more productive ( Melo et al. 2009 ; Combes and Gobillon 2015 ; Duranton and Puga 2020 ) . This productivity advantage may reflect agglomeration economies or firm selection — the concentration of firms in dense environments making them more productive, or stronger competition in denser areas culling weaker firms at higher rates, respectively. Understanding which of these mechanisms drives the productivity advantage of cities is important for evaluating place-based interventions like tax incentives, infrastructure investments, or regional development programs ( Neumark and Simpson 2015 ) . Combes et al. 2012 disentangle these channels by assuming that the distributions of total factor productivity (TFP) across denser and less dense areas are the same except for shifts in mean and variance that reflect agglomeration and for tail truncation due to firm selection. Under this assumption, they decompose productivity differences along the two channels. If, however, the TFP distributions across areas differed in other ways (e.g. tail behavior or shape), this decomposition may be invalid and instead reflect those differences, complicating interpretations of sorting patterns ( Gaubert 2018 ) and evaluations of place‑based interventions. Despite its central role, this assumption has not been directly tested. Empirical validation is challenging because productivity is not directly observed, but instead estimated with noise. Thus, naive comparisons of TFP distributions based on noisy TFP estimates may conflate (policy-irrelevant) noise with true heterogeneity ( Jochmans and Weidner 2024 ) . This paper empirically tests this assumption of distribution equality. Using Spanish administrative firm-level data, we nonparametrically test for differences in TFP distributions across denser and less dense areas, using methods that account for estimation noise in TFP. Across all sectors, we find that TFP distributions share the same shape, with differences fully explained by the parameters posited by Combes et al. 2012 . Our results suggest that urban productivity advantages may be fully explained by agglomeration rather than stronger selection. Of the three Combes et al. 2012 parameters, only the mean and variance are needed to align the TFP distributions across areas, while the tail truncation parameter is not needed. This suggests that policies enhancing agglomeration, such as improving infrastructure or fostering knowledge spillovers, may be more effective than competition‑enhancing policies, such as reducing entry barriers or promoting firm turnover. This paper makes three contributions. First, we empirically validate the distribution equality assumption in Combes et al. 2012 , complementing the partial results of Morozov 2026 , who finds no evidence of left-tail truncation. Second, our methodology for testing distribution equality with noisy data is also applicable to other contexts, such as geographical differences in worker skills ( de la Roca and Puga 2017 ) . Last, we contribute to the literature on working with noisy estimates of unobserved heterogeneity ( Okui and Yanagi 2019 ; Jochmans and Weidner 2024 ; Morozov 2026 ) by proposing a goodness-of-fit test based on noisy observations. 2 Setting and Distribution Equality Hypotheses To evaluate the assumption of distribution equality for TFPs, we work in the setting of Combes et al. 2012 (CDGPR12 henceforth). Their approach proceeds in two steps: first estimating firm-specific TFPs, then comparing productivity distributions between high-density (above-median density, AMD) and low-density (below-median density, BMD) areas. Following CDGPR12, we define firm-level TFP \theta_{i} by assuming that firm i in year t , sector s , and area a\in\{\text{AMD}\mathchar 59\relax\text{BMD}\} produces value added V_{i\mathord{\mathchar 59\relax}t} according to a Cobb-Douglas production function: V_{it}=\exp(\theta_{i})K_{it}^{\beta_{1\mathchar 59\relax s\mathchar 59\relax a}}L_{i\,t}^{\beta_{2\mathchar 59\relax s\mathchar 59\relax a}}\exp(U_{it}+\beta_{0\mathchar 59\relax t\mathchar 59\relax s\mathchar 59\relax a}) (1) where \theta_{i} is firm (log) total factor productivity (TFP), K_{it} and L_{it} are capital and labor, and U_{it} captures measurement error in V_{it} . Here \beta_{1\mathchar 59\relax s\mathchar 59\relax a} and \beta_{2\mathchar 59\relax s\mathchar 59\relax a} are sector- and area-specific factor shares, while \beta_{0\mathchar 59\relax t\mathchar 59\relax s\mathchar 59\relax a} is a time-specific intercept, allowing for productivity trends. Firms in sector s draw \theta_{i} from F_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD} (AMD) and F_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD} (BMD). To separate agglomeration economies and selection, CDGPR12 assume that F_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD} and F_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD} differ only in location ( \mu ), scale ( \sigma ), and left tail truncation (\xi) : F_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD}(\theta)=\max\left\{0\mathchar 59\relax\dfrac{F_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD}\left(\frac{\theta-\mu}{\sigma}\right)-\xi}{1-\xi}\right\}. (2) Here (\mu\mathchar 59\relax\sigma) capture agglomeration economies, while \xi reflects stronger competition in denser areas. CDGPR12 view ( 2 ) as a continuum of moments and estimate (\mu\mathchar 59\relax\sigma\mathchar 59\relax\xi) with GMM. Our goal is to test assumption ( 2 ). If it fails, then the CDGPR12 estimators of (\mu\mathchar 59\relax\sigma\mathchar 59\relax\xi) may potentially be biased or produce quantities that are challenging to interpret. Formally, we test the following null of distribution equality up to mean and variance for every sector s : H_{0}:\quad F_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD}\left(\dfrac{\theta-\mu_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD}}{\sigma_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD}}\right)=F_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD}\left(\frac{\theta-\mu_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD}}{\sigma_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD}}\right)\text{ for all }\theta\in\R (3) where \mu_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD}\mathchar 59\relax\mu_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD}\mathchar 59\relax\sigma_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD}\mathchar 59\relax\sigma_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD} are AMD/BMD sector-specific location and scale parameters. This null is more restrictive than (and hence implies ) CDGPR12’s, as it excludes \xi . We omit \xi based on Morozov 2026 who nonparametrically finds no evidence of left tail truncation. Moreover, our results in section 5 show that location-scale shifts are sufficient for distribution equality for all s . Importantly, our analysis is fully agnostic about how F_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD} and F_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD} arise or how to interpret (\mu\mathchar 59\relax\sigma) . We also make no functional form assumptions on F_{s\mathchar 59\relax AMD} and F_{s\mathchar 59\relax BMD} . Testing the null in ( 3 ) is challenging for two reasons. First, the TFPs \theta_{i} are latent and must be estimated from data using some \hat{\theta}_{i} , as is standard in the literature. Second, \hat{\theta}_{i} are noisy measurements of \theta_{i} . As Jochmans and Weidner 2024 show, naively using \hat{\theta}_{i} may lead to invalid inference. We now address these challenges in turn. 3 Data and TFP Estimation We use administrative balance sheet and income statement data from the Banco de España’s CBI dataset ( Banco De España 2026 , remote access, 2024 vintage) from 2000 to 2019. CBI is representative, covering \sim 80% of incorporated non-financial Spanish firms and matching the aggregate dynamics of output, employment and wages ( Almunia et al. 2018 ) . All monetary

Read the complete text