Bilinear products and the orthogonality of quasinormal modes on hyperboloidal foliations
Marica Minucci, Rodrigo Panosso Macedo, Christiana Pantelidou, Laura Sberna · 2026
Read Bilinear products and the orthogonality of quasinormal modes on hyperboloidal foliations by Marica Minucci, Rodrigo Panosso Macedo, Christiana Pantelidou, Laura Sberna (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13182.txt.
Introduction
Minucci, Panosso Macedo, Pantelidou, and Sberna explore bilinear products for black hole quasinormal modes on hyperboloidal foliations. Although the modes are smooth and finite on future hyperboloids, the integrand defining their orthogonality still blows up. The mirror flip in the product definition changes what happens at the edge. They present several taming methods yielding a finite well-defined bilinear form, plus another version adding flux terms, and define driving factors and numbers for scalar ripples of Schwarzschild geometry.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marica Minucci, Rodrigo Panosso Macedo, Christiana Pantelidou, Laura Sberna |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 141353 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13182
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bilinear products and the orthogonality of quasinormal modes on hyperboloidal foliations Marica Minucci, Rodrigo Panosso Macedo, Christiana Pantelidou, Laura Sberna Abstract We explore the properties of bilinear products for black-hole quasinormal modes (QNMs) formulated on hyperboloidal foliations. We find that, although QNM solutions are smooth and finite on future-directed hyperboloids, the integrand of the bilinear form with respect to which the modes are orthogonal is still divergent. This is a result of the reflection (equivalently, CPT) transformation required in the definition of the products, which modifies the behaviour of the integrand at the boundaries. We present several regularisation procedures that yield a finite and well-defined bilinear form. In addition, we examine an alternative definition of the bilinear products that incorporates flux contributions, discussing its advantages and limitations. Finally, we define the QNM excitation factors and coefficients within the hyperboloidal framework in terms of the bilinear products, and compute them explicitly for a choice of mode numbers and constant initial data. For concreteness, we work with the QNMs associated to scalar perturbations of the Schwarzschild family of spacetimes. I Introduction When two black holes merge, the remnant is expected to be a spinning, distorted black hole, with the corresponding spacetime emitting gravitational waves in a characteristic “ringdown.” The timescales associated with this exponentially damped and oscillatory signal are encoded in the so-called quasinormal modes (QNMs). These modes form a set of complex frequencies \omega_{\ell mn} , labelled by discrete indices (\ell,m,n) , where (\ell,m) capture the angular distribution pattern of the radiation, while n accounts for the tower of allowed vibration and decay timescales (overtones). Quasinormal modes are fingerprints of the final black hole spacetime, carrying information not only on astrophysical observables but also on the fundamental nature of gravity. Measuring these frequencies is the main goal of the black hole spectroscopy program, as this information enables precision tests of general relativity, particularly when multiple modes are resolved—see Abedi et al. 2025 and references therein for a recent and comprehensive review. With current observations already investigating the presence of overtones Abac and et al 2025 ; Abac et al. 2026 , next-generation detectors promise the sensitivity required for precision black hole spectroscopy Berti et al. 2016 ; Maggiore et al. 2020 ; Cabero et al. 2020 ; Toubiana et al. 2024 . In addition to the challenges of detecting QNMs in gravitational-wave signals, fundamental conceptual issues within the underlying theory remain unresolved. Formally, the QNM problem arises in black hole perturbation theory once the underlying wave equations are solved with the physically relevant boundary conditions at the horizon and at future null infinity. However, within this linear response, the QNM frequencies dominate the signal only during an intermediate phase. The early-time dynamics are characterised by a prompt response that describes freely propagating radiation, while the late-time behaviour is dominated by power-law tails Leaver 1986 ; Price 1972 ; Gundlach et al. 1994 . Strategies to extract QNMs from data rely on the separation of these different regimes, and therefore there has recently been a surge in analytical methods to better model them De Amicis et al. 2024 ; Arnaudo et al. 2025a ; Arnaudo and Withers 2025 ; De Amicis et al. 2026 ; Su et al. 2026 ; Ma 2026 . Another theoretical issue arises when analysing the system in the frequency domain. Upon performing a Fourier transform of the original field equation, the QNM frequencies are identified as eigenvalues \omega_{\ell mn} —with associated eigenfunctions—of the corresponding evolution operator. In conservative (e.g. Hermitian) systems, such eigenfunctions form a complete basis in an appropriate functional space. Thus, the system is naturally endowed with a scalar product, allowing the projection of an arbitrary function onto that basis. However, this property is absent from the QNM problem, due to the leakage of energy through the spacetime boundaries. It has long been known that QNM eigenfunctions blow up at the event horizon and in the infinitely far region, a feature that has historically prevented the definition of an appropriate functional space with L^{2} -type inner products. As a consequence, projecting solutions onto QNMs, an essential step for analysing nonlinear mode interactions and defining excitation amplitudes, remains ambiguous. Despite these difficulties, it is possible to define a product under which QNMs with different frequencies are orthogonal, in analogy to other non-Hermitian physical systems. The product is understood as a complex-valued bilinear form, rather than as an inner product. Based on earlier developments for perturbations of the Schwarzschild family of spacetimes Ching et al. 1995 ; Ching et al. 1996 , Ref. Green et al. 2023 provided a general recipe to construct such a product for perturbations of the Kerr family of spacetimes. The product is built from the symplectic form of the Teukolsky master equation, and exploits the time and azimuthal angular reflection symmetries of the Kerr family via an operator \mathcal{J} . At the same time, separate products for the angular and radial solutions of the Teukolsky equation have also been introduced London 2023 ; London 2026 . Such QNM products have practical applications for the computation of QNM excitation coefficients Green et al. 2023 and perturbative frequency shifts Leung et al. 1997 ; Zimmerman et al. 2015 ; Mark et al. 2015 ; Hussain and Zimmerman 2022 ; Li et al. 2024 ; Cannizzaro et al. 2024 , as well as in waveform modelling Hamilton et al. 2021 ; Thompson et al. 2024 . Beyond the applications in gravitational wave physics, QNM products have also been introduced in asymptotically anti-de Sitter spacetimes motivated by gauge-gravity duality Arnaudo et al. 2025b . All these products, however, inherit the blow-up behaviour of the QNM eigenfunctions toward the boundaries of the spatial domain, and this issue must be addressed at both foundational and computational levels. On the analytical side, the arguments leading to the definition of these products are initially formulated for functions with compact support. A careful treatment of the full spatial domain, together with a consistent implementation of the boundary conditions, is typically deferred. These issues are then addressed at the computational level through regularisation schemes, such as deforming the integration domain into the complex plane. From a complementary perspective, it has been understood over the past decades that the ill behaviour of the QNM eigenfunctions reflects a poor choice of coordinate system, not adapted to the radiative nature of wave propagation Zenginoglu 2011 ; Panosso Macedo and Zenginoglu 2024 . Traditionally, the QNM eigenvalue problem arises from a Fourier analysis with respect to Boyer–Lindquist-type coordinates. In this setting, the limits towards the horizon and infinitely far region correspond to the bifurcation sphere \mathcal{B} and spatial infinity i^{0} , respectively, where hypersurfaces of constant time accumulate, leading to the blow-up of the corresponding spatial functions. Upon focusing on the geometrical aspects of the problem, the hyperboloidal framework Zenginoglu 2011 ; Panosso Macedo 2024 ; Panosso Macedo and Zenginoglu 2024 provides a natural resolution to this issue. It prescribes a formulation in which the time foliation intersects the physically relevant regions of spacetime for black-hole and gravitational-wave physics, namely the black-hole horizon {\cal H}^{+} and future null infinity \mathscr{I}^{+} . Within this geometrical setting, the corresponding QNM eigenfunctions remain finite, and the QNM eigenfrequencies are