Melodic contour does not cluster: Reconsidering contour typology
Bas Cornelissen, Willem Zuidema · 2026
Read Melodic contour does not cluster: Reconsidering contour typology by Bas Cornelissen, Willem Zuidema (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13119.txt.
Introduction
Cornelissen, Zuidema, Burgoyne, and Honing challenge melodic contour typologies, the small sets of shape types scholars use to describe melodic phrases. Testing German and Chinese folksongs plus Gregorian chant, they find no evidence that phrase contours cluster into discrete types. Their clustering test, a dip test of multimodality after UMAP reduction, spots clustering in synthetic data but not in real contours, suggesting contour is continuous, not typed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bas Cornelissen, Willem Zuidema |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39302 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13119
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Melodic contour does not cluster: Reconsidering contour typology Bas Cornelissen, Willem Zuidema Abstract How to describe the shape of a melodic phrase? Scholars have often relied on typologies with a small set of contour types. We question their adequacy: we find no evidence that phrase contours cluster into discrete types, neither in German or Chinese folksongs, nor in Gregorian chant. The test for clustering we propose applies the dist-dip test of multimodality after a umap dimensionality reduction. The test correctly identifies clustering in a synthetic dataset, but not in actual phrase contours. These results raise problems for discrete typologies. In particular, type frequencies may be unreliable, as we see with Huron’s typology. We also show how a recent finding of four contour shapes may be an artefact of the analysis. Our findings suggest that melodic contour is best seen as a continuous phenomenon. 1 Introduction Recent years have seen a renewed interest in the search for musical universals: properties common to most or even all musics across the world [ 5 , 31 , 27 ] . Musical universals can help to identify the constraints within which most music is made, which may, in turn, point to biological predispositions for music ( musicality ) and inform theories about its evolution [ 20 ] . The frequent use of isochronous beats is, for example, consistent with a biological, cognitive capacity for beat perception [ 37 ] . But music might also be shaped by physiological constraints. A frequently cited universal is the prevalence of arch-shaped or descending melodic phrase contours, known as the melodic arch hypothesis [ 21 , 31 , 5 , 33 ] . It has been suggested that the physiology of our vocal system explains their prevalence, making pitch contours that fall towards the end of a phrase easier to produce [ 36 ] . Questions of universality go hand in hand with classification: they usually require typologies that break down music into a set of characters or features with several possible values or types [ 5 ] . Examples of features are the type of scale used or the type of rhythmic subdivision. Both of these are discrete characters, but there are also continuous characters, like tempo when measured in beats per minute. Even though it can vary almost continuously, melodic contour is often treated as a discrete character and described as ascending , descending , arch-shaped , and so on. By mapping the frequency of contour types, one can assess cross-cultural generalizations like the melodic arch hypothesis. The validity of all such comparative questions depends on the validity of the typology used. Consider a character modality taking the values major , minor , and irregular based on the presence of the major third. While this seems sensible for common practice melodies, it is an awkward description of Gregorian chant or the songs of the Lakota [ 10 ] . 1 1 1 Frances Densmore tabulated the modality of the songs she collected in precisely this way, but was well aware that this notion of modality was alien to the music she was studying. In this paper, we question the validity of discrete melodic contour typologies. Reviewing the literature on contour typologies, the common assumption seems to have been “that melodic contour types do exist and can be empirically defined” ( [ 1 ] , but also e.g., [ 30 ] ). More recently, [ 18 ] present evidence for four broad common contour shapes. We challenge this view. Contour types do not exist, unless contours cluster accordingly. We however fail to find any evidence for clustering in phrases from three repertoires, both within each repertoire and when aggregating them. As a result, discrete typologies partition the contour space somewhat arbitrarily. If the partition is not fair, it may skew the type frequencies and misrepresent the variability in the data. All this argues for treating melodic contour as a continuous character. Figure 1: Three contour typologies. (A) [ 10 ] divided Lakota songs into five contour classes, each identified by one representative song. (B) [ 1 ] considers all possible orderings of the four boundary pitches: the type 3412 means that the initial note (i.e., 3) is above the final (2). In between, the melody first reaches a higher (4) and then a lower (1) pitch. (C) [ 21 ] considers the ordering of the average pitch on the first, middle, and final parts of a melody. 2 Melodic contour typology Contour is a key aspect of melody. When still in the womb, humans already appear to be sensitive to the pitch contour of the mother tongue [ 25 ] , and once born, contours remain a central cue for our first steps in language learning. With such importance in early life, it is not surprising that [ 13 ] argued that contour and scale underpin our melodic memory. Composers who want to write catchy melodies must also attend to their contours. Indeed, many composition treatises discuss how to shape melodies. [ 29 ] for example opens his Counterpoint with a chapter on the “melodic curve” , while [ 28 ] reassures us that “there are only five basic melodic shapes or contours” (p. 179): ascending , descending , arch , inverse arch , and stationary . Such accounts are primarily meant prescriptively, not as a cross-cultural description of contour shapes—even though we will see some overlap. [ 1 ] identifies a plethora of melodic contour descriptions in the academic literature. Some narrate how the melody progresses, others settle for word lists, yet others for graphs. Some authors propose ten types, others six, yet others four. Descriptions are often ambiguous—how to distinguish a bow from an arch ?—and sometimes even inconsistent. Alan Lomax’ cantometrics project, for example, coded melodic shape as arched , undulating , descending , or terraced . But where the first three apply to the most characteristic phrase in a song, the latter applied to the entire song. Its successor, CantoCore [ 32 ] , only includes phrase-level contour types, but six of them ( horizontal , ascending , descending , U-shaped , arched and undulating ) and the annotator is given considerable freedom to resolve ambiguities. 2 2 2 The instructions allow coding of “clear ‘hyper-phrase’ contours” as a single contour and advice the annotators to ignore “temporary interval changes that do not greatly affect the dominant melodic contour.” An early, systematic contour analysis is Frances Densmore’s [ 10 ] study of the music of the Lakota people (also known as the Teton Sioux). She visualized the contours of complete songs by plotting the accented notes (the downbeats in her transcriptions) while ignoring accidentals ( Figure 1 A). This allowed her to cluster songs into five classes with similar contours and apparently sometimes similar social functions. It is not entirely clear how Densmore classified the songs. Sometimes the global shape seems to be the crux, sometimes characteristic local features are critical, and suggest that classes were based on more than contour alone. 3 3 3 More precisely, class A is defined by its global shape, and usually has only descending intervals. Class C has a characteristic local feature (repetition of the lowest note),