Exploring Urban Land Use Patterns by Pattern Mining and Unsupervised Learning
Zdena Dobesova \affilnum 1 and Tai Dinh \affilnum 2 and Pavel Novak \affilnum 1 · 2026
Read Exploring Urban Land Use Patterns by Pattern Mining and Unsupervised Learning by Zdena Dobesova \affilnum 1 and Tai Dinh \affilnum 2 and Pavel Novak \affilnum 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13050.txt.
Introduction
Dobesova, Dinh, and Novak compare land-use patterns across 100 European urban areas using Urban Atlas 2018 data. They turn the data into 290,396 neighborhood transactions and 1,543 frequent-itemset support features, then cluster cities into seven groups, checked through repeated subsampling. City similarity stays stable across support thresholds, though membership shifts with representation choices, and the method keeps scale and boundary limits explicit.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zdena Dobesova \affilnum 1 and Tai Dinh \affilnum 2 and Pavel Novak \affilnum 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61790 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13050
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Exploring Urban Land Use Patterns by Pattern Mining and Unsupervised Learning Zdena Dobesova \affilnum 1 and Tai Dinh \affilnum 2 and Pavel Novak \affilnum 1 Abstract Comparative planning needs reproducible methods for identifying recurring land-use configurations across cities. Using Urban Atlas 2018 data for 100 European urban areas, we construct 290,396 focal-neighborhood transactions and 1,543 frequent-itemset support features at 10% minimum support. Ward clustering is applied in the original normalized feature space, with UMAP used only for visualization. A seven-cluster descriptive solution is retained through multi-criterion evaluation and 500 paired feature-subsampling repetitions. Sensitivity analyses show stable city-similarity geometry across 5–15% thresholds but greater membership sensitivity to representation choices and non-artificial land-use content. The framework supports peer-city comparison while making scale and boundary limitations explicit. keywords Urban Atlas, land use, frequent itemsets, hierarchical clustering, comparative planning, urban morphology, sensitivity analysis † † affiliation: \affilnum 1Department of Geoinformatics, Palacký University, Olomouc, Czech Republic \affilnum 2The Kyoto College of Graduate Studies for Informatics, Japan † † corresponding: Zdena Dobesova and Tai Dinh 1 Introduction Urban areas are complex systems influenced by socioeconomic, environmental, and infrastructural factors, with land use patterns being key to urban morphology. Understanding these patterns is crucial for urban planning and policy. The Copernicus program’s Urban Atlas ( European Environment Agency, 2025 ) provides detailed data on land cover, land use, and spatial development across European cities, offering valuable insights into urban landscapes. Traditional geographic approaches, including spatial analysis, remote sensing, and geographic information systems (GIS), provide powerful tools for examining urban land-use patterns, temporal change, and environmental impacts. However, standardized comparison across large numbers of cities and the identification of recurring multi-category land-use associations can remain analytically challenging. Data-mining approaches can complement these established methods by systematically extracting recurring structures from large and heterogeneous spatial datasets. In recent years, geography has increasingly adopted data mining and machine learning to analyze large datasets and uncover patterns. These data-driven approaches provide complementary tools for identifying recurring structures and associations in large and complex datasets. Among the diverse array of data-mining techniques, frequent itemset mining (FIM) and clustering are particularly relevant to the systematic comparison of recurring land-use combinations across cities. Existing comparative studies have characterized cities using street-network structure, spatial metrics, land-use mix, urban morphology, and aggregate city typologies ( Louf and Barthelemy, 2014 ; Ye and Nes, 2014 ; Prastacos et al., 2017 ; Gregor et al., 2018 ) . These approaches provide valuable descriptions of urban composition and form, but they do not directly characterize how multi-category land-use combinations recur across local neighborhoods and how the prevalence of these combinations differs systematically between cities. This leaves a planning-relevant gap in standardized cross-city comparison: recurring local land-use co-presence can provide information that complements aggregate measures of composition, density, and land-use mix, but its comparative structure and sensitivity to analytical choices remain insufficiently examined. Such neighborhood-level comparisons can support the identification of comparable urban contexts, unusual land-use interfaces, and candidate peer cities for more detailed planning investigation. This study addresses this gap by representing each city through the relative support of recurring local combinations of Urban Atlas land-use classes. In this study, a pattern refers to an unordered set of land-use categories that are co-present within the specified local neighborhood, rather than to their exact geometric arrangement. Similarity refers to proximity between cities based on their profiles of relative support for these recurring patterns. The resulting clusters are therefore interpreted as descriptive empirical groupings conditional on the data representation and analytical choices, rather than as fixed or normative urban typologies. Accordingly, the study addresses the following research questions: 1. What recurring local land-use co-presence configurations characterize the selected European urban areas? 2. How do cities differ in the prevalence of these configurations, and which urban-form and urban–rural interface characteristics distinguish the resulting descriptive city groupings? 3. How can these recurring configurations support comparative planning and urban benchmarking, and how sensitive are the resulting comparisons to the support threshold, analytical representation, clustering choices, and non-artificial land-use content? The study makes four contributions. First, it develops a reproducible procedure for transforming polygon-based Urban Atlas data into transaction data representing recurring local co-presence of land-use classes. Second, it uses frequent itemset mining to construct comparable city-level profiles of the prevalence of these recurring land-use combinations across 100 selected European urban areas. Third, it compares cities by clustering their normalized frequent-itemset support profiles directly in the original feature space and evaluates the resulting structure through cluster-number assessment and extensive sensitivity analyses. Fourth, it examines how support thresholds, alternative representations and clustering geometries, UMAP visualization settings, repeated transaction patterns, and non-artificial land-use content affect the comparison, thereby defining both the robustness and the limitations of the resulting descriptive groupings for comparative planning. The analytical framework comprises four main stages: (1) preprocessing Urban Atlas spatial data and converting local land-use neighborhoods into transactions; (2) extracting frequent itemsets using the negFIN algorithm ( Aryabarzan et al., 2018 ) ; (3) constructing a city-by-itemset matrix in which each city is represented by the relative support of its frequent itemsets; and (4) comparing cities using hierarchical agglomerative clustering and sensitivity analysis. Ward hierarchical clustering is performed on the normalized original city-by-itemset feature matrix. UMAP ( McInnes et al., 2018 ) is used only for two-dimensional visualization and diagnostic assessment and does not determine the primary cluster assignments. Heatmaps, dendrograms, and UMAP projections are subsequently used to interpret and visualize the resulting city groupings. The datasets, source code, analysis notebook, and computational workflow used in this study are publicly available through the ULUMiner GitHub repository ( https://github.com/taiduydinh/ULUMiner ) to support reproducibility and reuse. The repository contains the materials required to reproduce the results reported in this study, together with information on data provenance and the analytical workflow. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. The Related Work section reviews the relevant literature and establishes the planning and methodological context of the study. The Preliminaries, Data and Proposed Method section describes the data and analytical framework. The Experimental Results section presents the empirical findings and sensitivity analyses. The Discussion interprets the findings in relation to comparative planning and considers the methodological limitations of the approach. The Conclusion summarizes the main findings and directions for future research. 2 Related Work 2.1 Comparative urban form, land-use mix, and city typologies The comparative study of urban structure has a long history. Classical work described recurring configurations of urban areas and their evolution ( Harris and Ullman, 1945 ; Harris, 1997 ) , while more recent studies have used increasingly detailed spatial data to quantify differences in urban form. For example, commuting patterns have been used to examine monocentric and polycentric urban structures ( Burger et al., 2011 ) , while street-network characteristics have supported cross-city comparison based on block form, orientation, configuration, and entropy ( Louf and Barthelemy, 2014 ; Boeing, 2018 ; Boeing, 2019 ; Boeing, 2020 ) . These approaches demonstrate that cities can be compared systematically through measurable characteristics of their spatial structure. Among recent approaches to the quantitative characterization of urban form, Fleischmann et al. (2026) introduced the Hierarchical Morphotope Classification (HiMoC), a theory-driven and computationally scalable framework for classifying built form. HiMoC operationalizes the concept of the morphotope—the