Reassessing planetary composition: Evidence of rock-dominated envelopes in Uranus and Neptune
Vanesa Ramirez, Yamila Miguel, Saburo Howard · 2026
Read Reassessing planetary composition: Evidence of rock-dominated envelopes in Uranus and Neptune by Vanesa Ramirez, Yamila Miguel, Saburo Howard (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-13020.txt.
Introduction
Ramirez, Miguel, and Howard model the interiors of Uranus and Neptune and find both planets less icy than their 'ice giant' label suggests. Their envelopes carry a median rock fraction near 60 percent of the heavy-element component, resembling Pluto and Kuiper belt objects. Deeper down the pair diverges: Neptune's mantle is rock-rich at about 55 percent, while Uranus stays ice-rich near 41 percent.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Vanesa Ramirez, Yamila Miguel, Saburo Howard |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57877 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13020
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reassessing planetary composition: Evidence of rock-dominated envelopes in Uranus and Neptune Vanesa Ramirez, Yamila Miguel, Saburo Howard Abstract Although Uranus and Neptune are commonly classified as ice giants, their exact compositions remain poorly constrained. Recent studies of outer Solar System bodies challenge the traditional view that these planets are primarily ice-dominated, suggesting that refractory material plays a more significant role. Determining the proportions of ice and rock within Uranus and Neptune is essential for understanding their formation and the evolutionary history of the Solar System. In this work we computed interior structure models for both planets and explored, within a Bayesian framework, the range of compositions that satisfy the available observational constraints. We quantified the resulting ice and rock fractions and analyzed their impact on the inferred internal structure. Our results suggest that the envelopes of both Uranus and Neptune are systematically enriched in refractory material, with median rock fractions of approximately 60% within the heavy-element component, similar to Pluto, Kuiper belt objects, and comets. In contrast, the deep interiors of the two planets exhibit distinct compositions: Neptune is best fit by relatively rock-rich mantles (median rock fraction of ∼ \sim 55%), whereas Uranus is inferred to have more ice-rich mantles (median rock fraction of ∼ \sim 41%), consistent with a more strongly stratified structure. These results point to compositional differences between Uranus and Neptune that may reflect divergent formation and evolutionary pathways. 1 Introduction Understanding the interior compositions of Uranus and Neptune is essential for advancing our knowledge of planetary formation and evolution, both within the Solar System and beyond. These two planets serve as key reference points for interpreting exoplanets of similar sizes, particularly those in the Neptune and sub-Neptune category, which account for nearly 40% of the confirmed exoplanet population 1 1 1 Based on data from the NASA Exoplanet Archive: https://exoplanetarchive.ipac.caltech.edu . Consequently, they provide a unique opportunity to refine planetary structure models and characterize analogous worlds outside the Solar System. Although Uranus and Neptune have historically been labeled as ice giants, the constraints on their internal structures are highly nonunique, and their actual compositions remain uncertain and depend heavily on the assumptions underlying their models, as well as the materials used to represent heavy elements (see 25 for an in-depth discussion). Measurements suggest relatively low deuterium-to-hydrogen (D/H) ratios in their atmospheres, which implies that, if the planets were once fully mixed, they now contain substantial amounts of rock in their interiors ( 10 ; 74 ) . Additional evidence from outer Solar System bodies supports this hypothesis: 45 find a rock fraction of about 70% for Pluto, while 5 report consistent rock mass fractions of 70% for 15 Kuiper belt objects. Moreover, studies of comets indicate that their refractory-to-ice mass ratios range from 3 to 6 ( 68 ; 16 ; 15 ; 17 ; 8 ) . These findings suggest that Uranus and Neptune also contain significant rock components ( 74 ) , and that models that do not take into consideration the presence of rocks in their envelopes may oversimplify their internal structure. Constraining the ice-to-rock fractions in Uranus and Neptune is critical for understanding their formation and evolution, as their formation location directly influences their accretion processes and resulting compositions ( 30 ) . Furthermore, insights into the distribution of ice and rock within these planets could also help refine models of analogous exoplanets, in which rocks are often considered to reside only in the core. We addressed these questions by analyzing the internal structures of Uranus and Neptune and determining their ice and rock fractions. The structure of the paper is as follows. Section 2 describes the interior structure models, the Bayesian inference framework, and the observational constraints adopted. In Sect. 3 we present our inferred heavy-element distributions, including ice and rock fractions, and their impact on the planetary structure. Section 4 discusses the implications of these results for the formation and evolution of Uranus and Neptune. In Sect. 5 we conclude with a summary of our main findings. 2 Methods Table 1 : Observational constraints for Uranus and Neptune used in this work. Uranus Neptune Planet mass (kg \times 10^{25} ) 8.68 a 10.241 a Measured equatorial radius at 1 bar (km) 25559 b 24766 c Temperature at 1 bar (K) 76 \pm 2 b 72 \pm 2 c Revised solid-body rotation period (s) 59664 d 62849 d Quadrupole gravitational harmonic J_{2}\times 10^{-2} 0.35107(7) e 0.35294(45) f Octopole gravitational harmonic J_{4}\times 10^{-4} -0.342(13) e -0.358(29) f • a via JPL Horizons • b 37 • c 38 • d 22 • e 32 • f 31 2.1 Calculation of the Uranus and Neptune interior models We constructed models assuming a three-layer structure: envelope, mantle, and a fully rocky core (see Fig. 1 , left panel). This approach has been employed in previous studies ( 1 ; 70 ; 60 ) , all of which assume that rocks are confined solely to the core 2 2 2 1 also explore an alternative two-layer model, where there is no separate rocky core; instead, rocks are fully mixed with ices in the mantle, while the outer envelope remains rock-free. . In contrast to these works, we allowed both ices and rocks to be present in the planetary envelope and mantle to determine the ice-to-rock fractions that fit the data. Following 6 , we restricted the presence of rocks to regions where the temperature exceeds a threshold consistent with silicate condensation. We adopted a condensation threshold of 1500 K as a proxy for the silicate cloud base, since silicates are the dominant rocky component (70% SiO 2 ) and form the basis of the metal equation of state (EOS) considered here ( 39 ) . Furthermore, this choice avoids numerical instabilities when the condensation boundary coincides with the envelope–mantle transition. Because condensation curves depend strongly on composition and mixing, this value should be regarded as a conservative lower limit for the onset of rock condensation in the interiors of these planets. To fit the measured gravity data for both planets, a sharp transition in composition from the hydrogen-rich outer envelope to the deeper regions containing heavier elements appears necessary. The physical cause of this discontinuity is not yet fully understood, but hydrogen-water immiscibility is a possible explanation, and this transition must occur at shallow depths ( \sim 0.7\penalty\ R_{\rm planet} ; 1 ; 4 ; 6 ; 20 ). Although hydrogen-water immiscibility has been demonstrated at conditions relevant to the Earth’s mantle ( 2 ; 82 ) , there remains a lack of experimental data for the extreme pressures and temperatures inside the ice giants. Given these uncertainties, we treated the depth of the compositional transition as a model parameter and explored a wide range of possibilities. Table 2 : Priors for model parameters used in both the Uranus and Neptune simulations. Parameter Distribution Lower bound Upper bound \mu \sigma M_{\rm core} (M p ) Uniform 0 0.2 (0.1) – – Z_{\rm env,\;ice} Uniform 0 0.7 – – Z_{\rm env,\;rock} Uniform 0 0.7 – – Z_{\rm mantle,\;ice} Uniform 0 0.99 – – Z_{\rm mantle,\;rock} Uniform 0 0.99 – – P_{1-2} (Mbar) Uniform 0.01 0.4 – – T_{\rm 1bar} (K) Normal 50 100 72 (76)