On the Meaning of the Web as an Object of Study

Claudio Gutierrez, Daniel Hernández · 2026

Read On the Meaning of the Web as an Object of Study by Claudio Gutierrez, Daniel Hernández (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-12756.txt.

Introduction

Claudio Gutierrez and Daniel Hernández argue the Web's meaning as a research object has diluted. The Web grew from a focused tech object into a universal digital world. That very success split its academic community and blurred its core identity. Crises at the Web Conference and Semantic Web Conference illustrate the trend. Pressures include the academic tragedy of the commons and disruptive AI. The authors chart the path from a clear object to a split backdrop. A community discussion is needed on what studying the Web means now.

Catalog record

CREATORClaudio Gutierrez, Daniel Hernández
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23307
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.12756

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Meaning of the Web as an Object of Study Claudio Gutierrez, Daniel Hernández Abstract . This text advances the hypothesis that the meaning of the Web as an object of study has diluted as a clear research domain. One example of this phenomenon is the identity crisis of the Web Conference and the International Semantic Web Conference. At its root is the Web’s evolution from a focused technological object into a universal digital environment, a transition whose very success has fragmented its academic community and obscured its core identity. We chart this trajectory from a well-defined object of study to a fragmented backdrop, identifying key pressures such as the “academic tragedy of the commons” and the disruptive force of AI. We conclude that a fundamental community discussion is needed to define what it means to study the Web now that it has become the universal infrastructure for global digital activity. Preprint. The published version appears in the poster track of the 18th ACM Web Science Conference Companion (WebSci Companion ’26). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3795513.3807425 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License . Introduction The World Wide Web, conceived as a universal space of interconnected information ( 1 ) , has long surpassed its status as a technological novelty (in its origins in the 1990s) to become an omnipresent and nearly transparent environment for contemporary users. This universality and invisibility make it difficult to define what “the Web” is today, beyond a ubiquitous infrastructure upon which the critical functions, services, and devices of the digital world operate. Moreover, the Web, like many digital disciplines, has been overshadowed in research by other technologies that now capture the attention of the computing community, such as machine learning-based artificial intelligence, large-scale data science, and platform-dominated recommendation systems ( 7 ) . To these tensions, we must add the contemporary crisis in academic publishing, exacerbated by the arrival of large language models (LLMs) and a hyperproliferation of submissions to conferences and journals. The explosive increase in contributions—many outside the intended scope, hastily produced, or redirected from other venues after negative reviews—has overloaded reviewers and program committees, eroding the quality filters of traditional scientific practice ( 10 ) . The emergence of automated tools for writing, reviewing, and plagiarism detection has introduced new dynamics not yet normatively absorbed, further complicating rigorous evaluation and thematic coherence. Clearly the area is facing a problem that most researchers are aware of, but whose causal explanation is far from being evident. In this poster paper, we present a hypothesis and make an argument for it. 1 1 1 Qualitative in nature and based on open data sources and the authors’ experience in program committees of Web-related venues. We claim that the Web, as an object of study, has seen its centrality diluted as a clear research domain, primarily due to its integration into the innumerable subsystems of the digital ecosystem. This fragmentation manifests in the thematic dispersion of submitted work and a loss of coherent disciplinary identity within academic venues that historically placed the Web at their core. The consequence is a mismatch that leads to the acceptance of papers that have no genuine connection to Web-centric research, a phenomenon particularly evident at The Web Conference (formerly WWW) and the International Semantic Web Conference (ISWC). Thus the aim of this paper is to contribute arguments and perspectives to the necessary open discussion about the Web’s place within the current digital landscape. Our distinctive contribution is the application of Simon’s “artificial systems” theory to re-categorize the Web as an environment rather than an instrument. While prior research has viewed the Web as a data source or a platform, our environmental approach helps explain why the discipline is experiencing a “tragedy of the commons”: the prestige attracts researchers from competitive adjacent fields; this overloads committees and erodes identity; and diminishes the weight of proper Web research. As illustration, we present the case of the evolution of submissions and topics at The Web Conference, which serves as both a symptom and a symbol of this paradigmatic crisis. For researchers of the Web, this crisis is deepened by the advent of AI, a technology that seems to be reconfiguring most traditional digital techniques. The very notions of “navigation,” “interaction,” or “information access” are being reshaped by conversational models and autonomous agents. This prompts a fundamental question: does the Web remain the privileged medium for human–machine interaction, or is it on its way to becoming a background infrastructure, overshadowed by intelligent interfaces that operate atop it without user awareness? In sum, this article argues that we are witnessing a dual transition: a loss of the Web’s academic centrality and a reconfiguration of the scientific system, both driven by the pressures of mass participation, data availability, and ML/LLM platforms. These trends converge in the need to reassess what it means to study “the Web” in 2026, what its corresponding disciplinary object is, and what role historical venues such as The Web Conference should play in this new landscape. This paper is organized into four sections. First, a brief theoretical framework outlining the historical evolution of the Web as a technological object (the “material” basis of the crisis). Second, a short analysis of the evolution of Web research topics. Third, an examination of the current situation of the Web Conference. Finally, some reflections and conclusions. 1. The Technological Landscape: Tools, Machines, and Environments To understand the historical and conceptual trajectory of the Web, it is useful to distinguish among different types of technological artifacts. This approach draws inspiration from Herbert Simon’s theory of artificial systems ( 14 ) , which emphasizes that artifacts must be understood in relation to their designed purposes and the forms of interaction they support. This foundation allows us to understand technology not merely as tools, machines, and methods, but also as environments, an idea also explored in contemporary theories of technology ( 5 ) . Let us briefly review these categories. Tools act as extensions of human agency, expanding existing capabilities without substituting for user action. Their purpose is specific and narrow: a hammer drives nails; a text editor facilitates writing; Photoshop enables image editing. Control is immediate and total, with human intentionality fully governing the operation. These artifacts (together with machines) form the traditional focus of technological studies, which emphasize functionality, efficiency, and usability. Context is not a central concern. A contribution in this area is evaluated by its performance, a “property” of the tool itself. Machines , by contrast, introduce partial autonomy and delegation. They automate functions previously requiring human effort or inaugurate capabilities that did not exist before. Following Mumford’s classical definition, machines are “organic systems composed of coordinated parts that perform work through external energy” ( 11 ) . This redistribution of agency—part remaining with the user, part delegated to the artifact—complicates human–machine relations, a dynamic especially pertinent to contemporary AI systems. Automobiles, washing machines, and neural-network systems are paradigmatic examples. Their study increasingly intersects with other disciplines, and the context of use becomes relevant precisely because agency is partially delegated. That context becomes a relevant part of their evaluation. Environments constitute a qualitatively distinct category. They are not instruments one wields nor

Read the complete text