Perspective on a challenge: predicting the photochemistry of cyclobutanone

Jiří Janoš, Nanna Holmgaard List, Andrew J. Orr-Ewing, Jiří Suchan, Mario Barbatti, Olivia Bennett, Marcus Brady, Javier Carmona-García, Rachel Crespo-Otero, Julien Eng, O. Jonathan Fajen, Marco Garavelli, Sandra Gómez, Alice E. Green, Federico J. Hernández, Daniel Hollas, Lewis Hutton, Lea M. Ibele, Adam Kirrander, Zhenggang Lan, Yorick Lassmann, Joseph E. Lawrence, Benjamin G. Levine, Dmitry V. Makhov, Jonathan R. Mannouch, Xincheng Miao, Roland Mitrić, Shane M. Parker, Thomas J. Penfold, Jiawei Peng, Jeremy O. Richardson, Dmitrii Shalashilin, Petr Slavíček, K. Eryn Spinlove, Patricia Vindel-Zandbergen, Federica Agostini, Sara Bonella, Todd J. Martínez, Graham A. Worth, Basile F. E. Curchod · 2026

Read Perspective on a challenge: predicting the photochemistry of cyclobutanone by Jiří Janoš, Nanna Holmgaard List, Andrew J. Orr-Ewing, Jiří Suchan, Mario Barbatti, Olivia Bennett, Marcus Brady, Javier Carmona-García, Rachel Crespo-Otero, Julien Eng, O. Jonathan Fajen, Marco Garavelli, Sandra Gómez, Alice E. Green, Federico J. Hernández, Daniel Hollas, Lewis Hutton, Lea M. Ibele, Adam Kirrander, Zhenggang Lan, Yorick Lassmann, Joseph E. Lawrence, Benjamin G. Levine, Dmitry V. Makhov, Jonathan R. Mannouch, Xincheng Miao, Roland Mitrić, Shane M. Parker, Thomas J. Penfold, Jiawei Peng, Jeremy O. Richardson, Dmitrii Shalashilin, Petr Slavíček, K. Eryn Spinlove, Patricia Vindel-Zandbergen, Federica Agostini, Sara Bonella, Todd J. Martínez, Graham A. Worth, Basile F. E. Curchod (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-12749.txt.

Introduction

Jiří Janoš and 39 colleagues review a 2023 challenge on cyclobutanone photochemistry. The challenge asked theorists to predict MeV-UED signals before the SLAC test. Fifteen predictions from over 70 people used varied methods. A second signal came from Shanghai Jiao Tong University. The Perspective compares approaches and notes strengths and weaknesses. Methods for excitation, structure, motion, and observables are assessed. The challenge showed qualitative power of nonadiabatic motion. It also showed electronic theory shapes outcomes and needs careful checks.

Catalog record

CREATORJiří Janoš, Nanna Holmgaard List, Andrew J. Orr-Ewing, Jiří Suchan, Mario Barbatti, Olivia Bennett, Marcus Brady, Javier Carmona-García, Rachel Crespo-Otero, Julien Eng, O. Jonathan Fajen, Marco Garavelli, Sandra Gómez, Alice E. Green, Federico J. Hernández, Daniel Hollas, Lewis Hutton, Lea M. Ibele, Adam Kirrander, Zhenggang Lan, Yorick Lassmann, Joseph E. Lawrence, Benjamin G. Levine, Dmitry V. Makhov, Jonathan R. Mannouch, Xincheng Miao, Roland Mitrić, Shane M. Parker, Thomas J. Penfold, Jiawei Peng, Jeremy O. Richardson, Dmitrii Shalashilin, Petr Slavíček, K. Eryn Spinlove, Patricia Vindel-Zandbergen, Federica Agostini, Sara Bonella, Todd J. Martínez, Graham A. Worth, Basile F. E. Curchod
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE92837
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.12749

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Perspective on a challenge: predicting the photochemistry of cyclobutanone Jiří Janoš, Nanna Holmgaard List, Andrew J. Orr-Ewing, Jiří Suchan, Mario Barbatti, Olivia Bennett, Marcus Brady, Javier Carmona-García, Rachel Crespo-Otero, Julien Eng, O. Jonathan Fajen, Marco Garavelli, Sandra Gómez, Alice E. Green, Federico J. Hernández, Daniel Hollas, Lewis Hutton, Lea M. Ibele, Adam Kirrander, Zhenggang Lan, Yorick Lassmann, Joseph E. Lawrence, Benjamin G. Levine, Dmitry V. Makhov, Jonathan R. Mannouch, Xincheng Miao, Roland Mitrić, Shane M. Parker, Thomas J. Penfold, Jiawei Peng, Jeremy O. Richardson, Dmitrii Shalashilin, Petr Slavíček, K. Eryn Spinlove, Patricia Vindel-Zandbergen, Federica Agostini, Sara Bonella, Todd J. Martínez, Graham A. Worth, Basile F. E. Curchod Abstract This Perspective is part of a Special Topic that explored the maturity of nonadiabatic molecular dynamics for predicting photochemical processes. In 2023, a prediction challenge was issued to the community of computational photochemists to simulate the photochemistry of cyclobutanone, photoexcited at 200 nm, and the resulting time-resolved MeV-UED signal. The challenge attracted 15 theoretical predictions from more than 70 researchers, employing a wide range of strategies for electronic structure and nonadiabatic molecular dynamics to predict the time-resolved MeV-UED signal before the experiment had been conducted at SLAC (Stanford, USA). The MeV-UED instrument at Shanghai Jiao Tong University was also used to provide a second independent time-resolved MeV-UED signal for the photochemistry of cyclobutanone. This Perspective discusses the various approaches and strategies used by the participants to predict the photochemistry of cyclobutanone. This work also summarizes the strengths and weaknesses of various methods used for photoexcitation, electronic structure, nonadiabatic dynamics, and calculation of observables, as agreed by the participants during a CECAM workshop dedicated to the results of the challenge and organized in Lausanne in April 2025. This Perspective also collects all the predicted time-resolved MeV-UED signals into a single figure, together with the experimental signal. This challenge (i) demonstrated the qualitative predictive power of nonadiabatic molecular dynamics and (ii) underscore the impact of electronic-structure theory on the outcome of the excited-state dynamics and the need for its careful benchmarking. This effort allowed the community to share practical strategies to perform nonadiabatic dynamics (discussed in the present Perspective) and constitutes a ’calibration’ exercise for computational photochemistry. 1 Introduction Developing methods to simulate the dynamics of electronically excited molecules beyond the Born–Oppenheimer approximation, coined nonadiabatic molecular dynamics , has been a very active field of research over the past decades with numerous applications, e.g., in spectroscopy, Liu et al. 2025 photochemistry, Levine and Martínez 2007 ; Schuurman and Stolow 2018 or atmospheric chemistry. Curchod and Orr-Ewing 2024 Nonadiabatic molecular dynamics relies not only on strategies that can capture the subtle coupling between electronic and nuclear motion in regions of strong nonadiabaticity, but also on the possibility to approximate some of the nuclear quantum effects unraveled by the photoexcitation process. Recent applications of nonadiabatic molecular dynamics to realistic simulations of molecules also highlighted the key importance of the underlying electronic-structure methods, Janoš and Slavíček 2023 ; Papineau, Jacquemin, and Vacher 2024 ; Jíra, Janoš, and Slavíček 2024 which provide electronic energies, nuclear forces, nonadiabatic coupling matrix elements, and other electronic quantities required for the nuclear propagation. Photophysical processes, where the nuclear configuration space visited by the photoexcited molecule does not include bond breakage or formation, can often be well described by simple, single-reference quantum-chemical methods. Conversely, photochemical processes, which span a much larger region of the nuclear configuration space, typically require electronic-structure methods including both static and dynamic correlation. The methods picked for the nonadiabatic dynamics and electronic structure are, however, not the only important ingredients for a successful simulation of excited-state processes: the description of the photoexcitation process and the calculation of experimental observables of interest are key components for a direct comparison with experiments. Hence, performing nonadiabatic molecular dynamics requires control over a vast set of parameters for different highly entangled components: photoexcitation, electronic structure, nonadiabatic dynamics, and calculation of observables. Cigrang et al. 2025 ; Prlj et al. 2026 The challenge of combining the various ingredients necessary for nonadiabatic molecular dynamics has often constrained excited-state simulations to act as an interpretative tool for (time-resolved) spectroscopy and photochemistry. This Special Topic asked the question: Is the field of nonadiabatic molecular dynamics mature enough to be predictive? This question emerged during a discussion session of the CECAM workshop entitled ’Triggering out-of-equilibrium dynamics in molecular systems’, which took place in Lausanne (Switzerland) between the 28th and the 31st of March 2023. Motivated to find an answer to this question, a subgroup of participants in this workshop developed the idea of this prediction challenge. Discussion with scientists at the SLAC Megaelectronvolt Ultrafast Electron Diffraction facility (Stanford, USA) led to the identification of an experiment scheduled for the end of January 2024: a time-resolved mega-electronvolt ultrafast electron diffraction (MeV-UED) study of the photochemistry of cyclobutanone, photoexcited at 200 nm. Such an experiment was considered a good fit for a challenge: (i) the knowledge about the photochemistry of cyclobutanone excited at 200 nm in the gas phase is limited (Fig. 1 ), yet it is expected that photoproducts (resulting from photodissociation pathways) are formed, (ii) intersystem crossing may play a role in the excited-state dynamics, (iii) time-resolved MeV-UED offers both spatial and temporal resolution at the atomic scale, i.e., molecular movies – a great way to monitor the formation of photoproducts. The Journal of Chemical Physics (JCP) agreed to host the articles resulting from this challenge as part of this Special Topic and sent invitation emails to members of the community at the end of July 2023. The challenge consisted of predicting (i) the photochemistry of gas-phase cyclobutanone, photoexcited by a 200 nm laser pulse, and (ii) the time-resolved mega-electronvolt ultrafast electron diffraction (MeV-UED) signal that would be recorded at SLAC. Point (ii) was a central requirement of this call, ensuring a one-to-one comparison between theory and experiment. All participants were informed of the earlier experimental and theoretical literature on this molecule. Kao et al. 2020 ; Diau, Kötting, and Zewail 2001 ; Xia et al. 2015 ; Liu and Fang 2016 The deadline was set to the 15th of January 2024, subsequently extended to the 15th of February 2024. 15 articles resulted from this call, gathering more than 70 researchers to address this challenge. The range of strategies employed for the electronic structure and the nonadiabatic dynamics was broad and will be dissected in Sec. 2 . Figure 1 : Schematic representation of the potential photochemistry of cyclobutanone triggered by photoexcitation at 200 nm (adapted from Ref. 14 ). Red symbols indicate the pathways discussed and questions addressed as part of the Prediction Challenge. The C {}_{\text{2}} and C {}_{\text{3}} photoproducts are highlighted. We note that ethenone (C {}_{\text{2}} product) can possibly undergo further reaction to produce CO and \text{CH}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\vphantom{\text{2}}\smash[t]{\text{2}}}^{\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\hphantom{\text{2}}\text{}} . The time-resolved MeV-UED experimental article published in this Special Topic proposed a detailed analysis of the recorded signals without using the results of the nonadiabatic dynamics simulations part of the challenge. This experiment (Exp1 in the following), was conducted at the SLAC Megaelectronvolt Ultrafast Electron Diffraction facility and sampled the photodynamics of cyclobutanone up to 2 ps following photoexcitation (200 nm, 130 fs FWHM). Green et al. 2025 Exp1 interpreted their observations as showing that cyclobutanone

Read the complete text