Next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order QCD corrections to photon-pair production
Michał Czakon, Felix Eschment, Terry Generet, Rene Poncelet · 2026
Read Next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order QCD corrections to photon-pair production by Michał Czakon, Felix Eschment, Terry Generet, Rene Poncelet (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-12613.txt.
Introduction
Michal Czakon and three colleagues compute photon-pair production at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order in QCD. Two isolated photons at the Large Hadron Collider matter for Higgs studies and new-physics searches. Percent-level theory would sharpen those measurements. This first N3LO calculation tests whether perturbation theory converges. It also shrinks theory error threefold, down to 3 percent. The result paves the way to improved analyses.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michał Czakon, Felix Eschment, Terry Generet, Rene Poncelet |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25074 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.12613
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order QCD corrections to photon-pair production Michał Czakon, Felix Eschment, Terry Generet, Rene Poncelet Abstract The production of two isolated photons in high-energy hadron collisions poses a challenge to perturbative QCD because of large corrections through next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO). We present novel next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order ( N 3 \text{N}^{3} LO) predictions and finally demonstrate perturbative convergence for this process. We discuss the considerable computational challenges and phenomenological results for the Large Hadron Collider. I Introduction Perturbative Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) is essential to the physics program of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). In recent years, NNLO calculations have matured with a number of proposed subtraction schemes 82 ; 100 ; 61 ; 37 ; 94 . In particular, Refs. 82 ; 61 have enabled precise predictions for 2\to 3 processes 45 ; 46 ; 63 ; 50 ; 84 ; 4 ; 12 ; 25 ; 10 . This required efficient software implementations, like the package STRIPPER , a C++ implementation of the sector-improved residue subtraction scheme 61 ; 60 ; 64 . Other implementations— NNLOJET 87 of the antenna subtraction method 82 ; 65 ; 59 , NNLOCAL 69 of the CoLoRFulNNLO method 100 ; 70 , and history 92 of the nested soft-collinear subtraction scheme 37 ; 38 —have recently been made publicly available. Predictions at \text{N}^{3} LO are necessary to reduce theory uncertainties to match the experimental progress expected at the High Luminosity LHC. Furthermore, they offer valuable tests of the convergence of the perturbation series in QCD. While a \text{N}^{3} LO calculation using a subtraction scheme for a cross section at electron-position colliders has recently been presented 55 , a scheme applicable to hadron colliders remains elusive. Instead, first \text{N}^{3} LO predictions for the 2\to 1 processes of Higgs and Drell-Yan production at the LHC have been obtained using alternative methods. The method of reverse unitarity 7 ; 8 yields inclusive cross sections (Higgs 6 ; 5 ; 96 ; 75 , Drell-Yan 74 ; 73 ) which have been implemented in the software package n3loxs 13 . However, it is difficult to extend it to higher-multiplicity processes. Whenever inclusive cross sections are available, fully differential cross sections can be obtained with the projection-to-Born method 32 , which has been applied to Higgs production at \text{N}^{3} LO 49 . Other semi-differential \text{N}^{3} LO predictions have been obtained for Higgs and Higgs-pair production in vector-boson fusion using the structure function approximation 71 ; 72 . A different method that produces fiducial or differential predictions is q_{T} slicing 42 , which has been successfully applied at \text{N}^{3} LO for the same processes (Higgs 57 ; 21 , Drell-Yan 33 ; 53 ; 34 ; 51 ; 54 ; 97 ; 36 ). At \text{N}^{3} LO, q_{T} slicing is currently limited to colorless final states. Approaches to overcome its conceptual limitations to processes without resolved jets have not exceeded NNLO so far 29 ; 30 ; 80 ; 28 . Furthermore, the ingredients necessary to apply it to processes with massive colored particles are unknown at \text{N}^{3} LO. A different slicing approach that allows the incorporation of N resolved jets is N -jettiness slicing 22 ; 81 . This method requires beam 76 ; 16 , jet 24 ; 15 and soft functions. Only the zero-jettiness soft function is currently known at \text{N}^{3} LO 18 ; 17 . The natural next step in \text{N}^{3} LO calculations for the LHC is to increase the multiplicity beyond 2\to 1 processes using a slicing method. Photons have a rich phenomenology at the LHC and provide an ideal laboratory for calculations with slicing at \text{N}^{3} LO due to their colorlessness. Diphoton production is a background process for H\to\gamma\gamma , which was the most important decay channel for the discovery of the Higgs boson 1 ; 43 . Furthermore, it has been measured directly by ATLAS 2 and CMS 44 . In Ref. 2 , measurements were compared with NNLO predictions for pp\to\gamma\gamma obtained with NNLOJET . Before that, NNLO calculations had been performed with q_{T} slicing 41 ; 35 . The calculations showed that while the prediction starts to agree with the data at NNLO, no convergence is observed when increasing the order of the approximation. Instead, both next-to-leading order (NLO) and NNLO calculations yield cross-section values well outside the theory uncertainty predicted by the previous order. Furthermore, this theory uncertainty increases order-by-order and reaches about 8% at NNLO. In this letter, we present the fiducial cross section for diphoton production at \text{N}^{3} LO. We finally observe perturbative convergence together with a significant reduction of scale uncertainty. Due to the enormous numerical challenges, there remains a non-negligible Monte Carlo integration uncertainty of 2%—about the same size as the scale variation. To achieve the result, we have drastically improved the efficiency of the NNLO pp\to\gamma\gamma + jet calculation, and obtained analytic one-loop amplitudes for pp\to\gamma\gamma + 2 jets using modern techniques. II Calculation We perform the \text{N}^{3} LO cross-section calculation with the q_{T} -slicing method 42 . Accordingly, the diphoton production cross-section is decomposed as \sigma^{pp\to\gamma\gamma}_{\text{N}^{3}\text{LO}}=\int_{0}^{q_{T}^{\text{cut}}}\textrm{d}q_{T}\frac{\textrm{d}\sigma^{pp\to\gamma\gamma}_{\text{N}^{3}\text{LO}}}{\textrm{d}q_{T}}+\int_{q_{T}^{\text{cut}}}^{\infty}\textrm{d}q_{T}\frac{\textrm{d}\sigma^{pp\to\gamma\gamma j}_{\text{NNLO}}}{\textrm{d}q_{T}}, (1) where q_{T}\equiv|\bm{q}_{T}| is the transverse momentum of the photon pair. A finite q_{T}^{\text{cut}}>0 regulates infrared divergences due to the jet radiation in the second term. On the other hand, if q_{T}^{\text{cut}} is chosen sufficiently small, we can approximate the first term by means of the factorization theorem 58 ; 23 ; 20 ; 78 ; 56 \frac{\textrm{d}\sigma^{pp\to\gamma\gamma}}{\textrm{d}\bm{q}_{T}^{2}\,\textrm{d}m_{\gamma\gamma}\,\textrm{d}y}=\sum_{a,b}H_{ab}(m_{\gamma\gamma})\int\!\frac{\textrm{d}^{2}\bm{b}_{T}}{(2\pi)^{2}}e^{i\bm{q}_{T}\cdot\bm{b}_{T}}\\ \times\tilde{f}_{a}(x_{1},\bm{b}_{T})\tilde{f}_{b}(x_{2},\bm{b}_{T})+\mathcal{O}(q_{T}/m_{\gamma\gamma}), (2) where m_{\gamma\gamma} is the diphoton mass and y the rapidity, x_{1,2}=m_{\gamma\gamma}/\sqrt{s}\exp(\pm y) . H_{ab} contains the Born cross section and virtual corrections and \tilde{f}_{i} is the transverse-momentum-dependent parton distribution function. It combines beam and soft functions, \tilde{f}_{i}(x,\bm{b}_{T})\equiv B_{i}(x,\bm{b}_{T})\sqrt{S(\bm{b}_{T})} , and enters multiplicatively for the partons a and b when expressed through the impact parameter \bm{b}_{T} , the Fourier conjugate of \bm{q}_{T} . Furthermore, it is related to regular parton distribution functions (PDFs) f_{i} via convolution 58 \tilde{f}_{i}(x,\bm{b}_{T})=\sum_{j}\int_{x}^{1}\!\frac{\textrm{d}z}{z}\tilde{\mathcal{I}}_{ij}^{\text{TMD}}(z,\bm{b}_{T})f_{j}\Big(\frac{x}{z}\Big)+\mathcal{O}(\bm{b}_{T}\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}), (3) with the matching kernel \tilde{\mathcal{I}}_{ij}^{\text{TMD}} calculated through \text{N}^{3} LO in Refs. 77 ; 93 . Starting from the ancillary files of Ref. 93 , we perform the \bm{b}_{T} and \bm{q}_{T} integrals analytically and implement the result in STRIPPER , where the convolution with PDFs and remaining phase-space integration can be carried out numerically. The virtual amplitudes through three-loop order that contribute to H_{ab} were taken from Refs. 83 ; 39 . The second term of Eq. ( 1 ) requires an NNLO calculation that can be performed with existing subtraction schemes as already done in Refs. 46 ; 25 . Here, we use the STRIPPER implementation described in detail in Ref. 46 . However, the requirement of a very small q_{T}^{\text{cut}} parameter introduces major technical obstacles. We therefore implement several improvements compared to Ref. 46 . First, we employ hybrid floating-point precision, double or quadruple, using the qd library 86 . Phase-space regions with particularly large cancellations are calculated in quadruple precision by default. Second, to reduce cancellations between double-real contributions and improve the numerical stability in quadruple and simultaneous double-triple collinear limits, the selector function has been modified to avoid extreme angular hierarchies by replacing d_{ij,k} in Eq. (18) in Ref. 60 by d_{ij,k}=\frac{E_{i}}{\sqrt{s}}\frac{E_{j}}{\sqrt{s}}(1-\cos\theta_{\rm min})(1-\cos\theta_{\rm max}) where \theta_{\rm min/max}=\min/\max\{\theta_{ij},\theta_{ik},\theta_{jk}\} . Third, we use amplitudes of very high numerical stability.