On the effective restoration of U ​ ( 1 ) A U(1)_{A} symmetry at finite temperature

Gert Aarts, Chris Allton, Ryan Bignell, Benjamin Jäger, Seyong Kim, Jon-Ivar Skullerud, Antonio Smecca · 2026

Read On the effective restoration of U ​ ( 1 ) A U(1)_{A} symmetry at finite temperature by Gert Aarts, Chris Allton, Ryan Bignell, Benjamin Jäger, Seyong Kim, Jon-Ivar Skullerud, Antonio Smecca (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-11916.txt.

Introduction

Aarts and six colleagues probe whether the axial U(1) symmetry of massless QCD, broken by the axial anomaly, is restored at high temperature. Using lattice ensembles with Wilson-clover fermions, they track when pseudoscalar and scalar susceptibilities become degenerate across a wide temperature range. Fine timing lets them pin restoration at 319 plus or minus 22 megaelectronvolts, well above the chiral crossover.

Catalog record

CREATORGert Aarts, Chris Allton, Ryan Bignell, Benjamin Jäger, Seyong Kim, Jon-Ivar Skullerud, Antonio Smecca
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35521
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11916

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the effective restoration of U ​ ( 1 ) A U(1)_{A} symmetry at finite temperature Gert Aarts, Chris Allton, Ryan Bignell, Benjamin Jäger, Seyong Kim, Jon-Ivar Skullerud, Antonio Smecca Abstract The U ​ ( 1 ) A U(1)_{A} symmetry of the massless QCD Lagrangian is explicitly broken by the axial anomaly, but it may be effectively restored at finite temperature. Determining the temperature at which this occurs is important for understanding the chiral transition and the structure of the QCD phase diagram. A commonly used probe of effective U ​ ( 1 ) A U(1)_{A} restoration is the degeneracy of flavour non-singlet pseudoscalar and scalar susceptibilities. Using anisotropic lattice QCD ensembles with Wilson-clover fermions generated by the Fastsum collaboration, we study this degeneracy through hadronic correlation functions over a wide range of temperatures. The fine temporal resolution of our Generation 3 ensembles allows us to determine the temperature at which the pseudoscalar and scalar channels become degenerate. We find evidence for the effective restoration of U ​ ( 1 ) A U(1)_{A} symmetry at T U ​ ( 1 ) A = 319 ​ ( 22 ) T_{U(1)_{A}}=319(22) MeV, well above the chiral crossover temperature. Introduction – During the last fifty years, it has been established that quantum chromodynamics (QCD) is the correct theory of the strong interaction 65 . Despite this, the behaviour of QCD under the extreme conditions of high temperature and density remains only partially understood 12 . Of particular interest is the study of thermal phase transitions, which in certain limits are associated with the restoration of symmetries of the QCD Lagrangian 12 ; 29 . The massless QCD Lagrangian is invariant under the symmetry U(1)_{V}\times U(1)_{A}\times SU(n_{f})_{L}\times SU(n_{f})_{R} , where n_{f} denotes the number of quark flavours. In vacuum, SU(n_{f})_{L}\times SU(n_{f})_{R} is spontaneously broken, giving rise to massless Goldstone modes. Below we refer to this as chiral symmetry breaking. On the other hand, the U(1)_{A} symmetry is explicitly broken in the quantised theory 22 ; 13 and is responsible for the higher mass of the \eta^{\prime} meson through the Witten-Veneziano formula 101 ; 98 . In nature, light quarks have small but non-zero masses, making the above symmetries approximate. It is now understood that at high temperature chiral symmetry is restored 17 ; 50 ; 45 . For physical quark masses the transition is a crossover occurring at T_{c}\approx 154 \mathrm{MeV} 21 ; 28 ; 55 . Restoration of chiral symmetry implies the degeneracy of hadronic channels related through a chiral rotation. Well-known examples of such chiral partners are the vector ( \rho ) and axial-vector ( a_{1} ) mesons, the flavour singlet scalar ( \sigma , also known as f_{0} ) and the flavour non-singlet pseudoscalar ( \pi ) mesons, and, in the nucleon sector, the N(939) and N^{*}(1535) states. For light and strange baryons, the emergence of parity doubling, which indicates chiral symmetry restoration, has indeed been observed using lattice QCD 6 ; 4 ; 5 . Although U(1)_{A} symmetry is broken explicitly by the anomaly, it is expected to be effectively restored at high temperature, which can also be studied at the level of correlation functions 90 ; 41 ; 42 . In this case, the restoration would imply a degeneracy between the flavour non-singlet pseudoscalar ( \pi ) and scalar ( \delta , also known as a_{0} ) channels. Note that by effective restoration we mean that differences between related channels due to U(1)_{A} symmetry breaking become negligible. The realisation of the effective restoration is still an open question with important consequences for the order of the chiral transition in the chiral limit and the structure of the QCD phase diagram 84 ; 30 ; 48 . U(1)_{A} restoration is an intricate part of QCD, as it relates the Dirac operator spectral density 16 ; 48 and the contribution of near-zero modes above T_{c} with the topology of the gauge fields 27 . Due to the nonperturbative nature of QCD, effective U(1)_{A} symmetry restoration at nonzero temperature has been studied using lattice simulations, comparing either susceptibilities in the flavour non-singlet pseudoscalar and scalar channels, or by analysing near-zero modes of the Dirac operator; for recent reviews, see Refs. 72 ; 51 . Given the importance of chiral symmetries, most investigations have used a lattice fermion formulation with unbroken chiral symmetry at non-zero lattice spacing 80 ; 81 ; 31 . The present picture remains ambiguous 65 ; 51 , despite the longstanding effort of several groups. Some results suggest that U(1)_{A} is effectively restored near T_{c} 43 ; 95 ; 44 , while others do not find this 32 ; 48 ; 14 ; 70 ; 19 ; 69 ; 55 ; 24 ; 49 . This matter is extensively discussed in Refs. 57 ; 58 ; 56 , clarifying assumptions made in earlier work. Another element to consider is the role of the strange quark 40 ; 63 ; 29 . Wilson lattice fermions break chiral symmetry explicitly. Hence their use to investigate the restoration of U(1)_{A} symmetry has been limited. An exception is Ref. 30 , in which screening masses in the relevant channels were studied. Without explicit chiral symmetry, two aspects should be considered 34 . First, at finite lattice spacing the effect of the Wilson term is prominent at small distances. Second, the renormalisation of operators is not protected by chiral symmetry. In this work, we present a study using Wilson-clover fermions 100 ; 88 , on ensembles with an unprecedented fine lattice spacing in the temporal direction. We address these two aspects in detail. By analysing temporal correlation functions in the flavour non-singlet pseudoscalar and scalar channels, our main finding is that U(1)_{A} symmetry is effectively restored at T\gtrsim 300\, MeV. Table 1: Details of the Fastsum Generation 2, 2L and 3 ensembles with n_{f}=2+1 flavours on N_{s}^{3}\times N_{\tau} lattices: the number of lattice points N_{s} in the spatial direction ( ∗ in Generation 3, N_{s}=24 for N_{\tau}=256 ); the lattice spacings a_{s},a_{\tau} ; the renormalised anisotropy \xi=a_{s}/a_{\tau} ; the pion mass m_{\pi} ; the chiral transition temperature T_{c} determined using the renormalised chiral condensate. The strange quark mass is approximately at its physical value. Generation 2 Generation 2L Generation 3 N_{s} 24 32 32 ( ∗ 24) a_{s} (fm) 0.1205(8) 0.1121(3) 0.1080(6) a_{\tau}^{-1} (GeV) 5.63(4) 6.079(13) 12.82(9) \xi=a_{s}/a_{\tau} 3.444(6) 3.453(6) 7.02(3) m_{\pi} (MeV) 384(4) 239(1) 380(1) T_{c} (MeV) 181(1) 167(3) 182(1) Refs. 2 ; 7 1 ; 8 91 ; 53 Table 2: Temporal extent N_{\tau} of the lattices in the three generations, with the corresponding temperature T expressed in MeV and in units of T_{c} . Generation 2 Generation 2L Generation 3 N_{\tau} T (MeV) T/T_{c} N_{\tau} T (MeV) T/T_{c} N_{\tau} T (MeV) T/T_{c} 128 44 0.24 128 47 0.42 256 50 0.28 64 95 0.59 128 100 0.55 56 109 0.67 112 114 0.64 48 117 0.63 48 127 0.78 96 133 0.73 40 141 0.76 40 152 0.94 80 160 0.88 76 169 0.93 36 156 0.84 36 169 1.04 72 178 0.98 68 188 1.04 32 176 0.95 32 190 1.17 64 200 1.10 28 201 1.09 28 217 1.34 56 229 1.26 24 235 1.27 24 253 1.56 48

Read the complete text