Can AI Detect Life? Lessons from Artificial Life

Ankit Gupta, Christoph Adami · 2026

Read Can AI Detect Life? Lessons from Artificial Life by Ankit Gupta, Christoph Adami (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-11915.txt.

Introduction

Gupta and Adami warn that machine-learning life detectors, trained on Earth-like organic mixtures to separate biotic from abiotic samples, are easily fooled. Using artificial life systems, they show such methods report life with near 100 percent confidence for samples incapable of life. The flaw is sensitivity to out-of-distribution inputs: alien samples will almost surely fall outside the training range. Life detection by AI, they conclude, is likely to yield many false positives.

Catalog record

CREATORAnkit Gupta, Christoph Adami
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17519
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11915

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Can AI Detect Life? Lessons from Artificial Life Ankit Gupta, Christoph Adami Abstract Modern machine learning methods have been proposed to detect life in extraterrestrial samples, drawing on their ability to distinguish biotic from abiotic samples based on training models using natural and synthetic organic molecular mixtures. Here we show using Artificial Life that such methods are easily fooled into detecting life with near 100% confidence even if the analyzed sample is not capable of life. This is due to modern machine learning methods’ propensity to be easily fooled by out-of-distribution samples. Because extra-terrestrial samples are very likely out of the distribution provided by terrestrial biotic and abiotic samples, using AI methods for life detection is bound to yield significant false positives. Introduction Creating an agnostic life detector (a system that detects life even in the absence of information about the biochemistry of life-bearing molecules) has been one of the main goals of astrobiology for decades ( Walker et al., 2018 ) . Potential biosignatures can be classified into substances (e.g., isotopes, elements, and molecules), objects (e.g., fossils, stromatolites, etc.), and patterns (mineral, physical, or chemical) ( Chan et al., 2019 ) . Which substances, patterns, or objects are diagnostic of life is, however, a difficult question since we are privy only to one form of life on this planet. Machine learning methods have been deployed in the past to classify amino acids as biotic or abiotic ( Dorn et al., 2003 ) , and agnostic biomarkers have been developed and even tested with Artificial Life ( Dorn et al., 2011 ; Dorn and Adami, 2011 ) . However, the machine learning methods of today (dubbed “AI” in the following) are far more powerful than the methods available in the past, and we can ask whether such methods are capable of generalizing from a sufficient number of natural and synthetic molecules to classify potentially ambiguous biomarkers. Indeed, recent efforts using AI to analyze data obtained from pyrolysis-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (py-GC-MS)—a typical instrument that would be carried by dedicated space missions—suggested that AI can discriminate between abiotic and biotic samples with accuracies approaching 98% accuracy ( Cleaves et al., 2023 ; Hystad et al., 2025 ; Wong et al., 2025 ) . However, any claim of the discovery of a biosignature is likely to be greeted with skepticism, as the likelihood of false positives is generally high ( Smith and Mathis, 2023 ) . Here we use Artificial Life to test whether a state-of-the-art classifier (a multi-layer perceptron) can be fooled into misclassifying a potential biomarker molecule that is a polymer built from a particular alphabet. Under the assumption that all life anywhere must encode information into unbranched heteropolymers ( Adami, 2024 ) , testing whether AI can discriminate between living (self-replicating) and non-living (non-replicating) polymers can provide some insight into whether AI can detect life. Of course, weakening any of these assumptions weakens the conclusions we reach, but some of the lessons learned may apply beyond the particular case we are testing. AI methods such as Deep Neural Networks (DNN) ( Goodfellow et al., 2016 ) work by fitting a model to the distribution of samples within a training set, but exhibit significant vulnerability to out-of-distribution samples ( Szegedy et al., 2013 ; Goodfellow et al., 2014 ) . For example, ( Nguyen et al., 2015 ) used evolution to find images that were confidently mis-classified by a DNN even though they were completely unrecognizable to the human eye. Gupta et al., 2025 used an even simpler procedure—a gradient-guided walk from a black canvas—to produce fooling images with only a few colored pixels splattered on a 224 \times 224 canvas. That work, fooling the most advanced AI classifiers on the largest dataset (ImageNet), showed that when the feature space is large enough, the number of out-of-distribution samples dwarfs the number of samples in the training set exponentially, so that arbitrary many fooling images are within the basins of attraction formed by the training procedure. It might seem impossible to test an AI’s generalization power for life detection because out-of-distribution samples are usually not available for life. Artificial Life provides a unique opportunity to overturn this paradigm, because in some cases we have access to the entirety of the distribution, while presenting only a small subset of those to the AI. If the space of possible life forms (the feature space) in an Artificial Life system is small, however, it is unlikely that out-of-distribution samples are a significant subset of all possible samples. Forunately, we have a dataset of significant size that may allow us to test the hypothesis that AI systems can be fooled into misclassifying life. The Digital Life system Avida ( Adami and Brown, 1994 ; Adami, 1998 ; Ofria et al., 2009 ) converts a computer’s memory into a Petri dish for self-replicating computer programs that evolve to perform complex computations on numbers they are fed as “food”. Experiments using this digital life form have led to the discovery of a number of novel evolutionary processes that have subsequently been found in biological organisms ( Adami, 2006 ) . In a standard implementation, avidian programs are drawn from an alphabet of 26 different machine instructions running on a simulated CPU (to avoid contaminating real computers with evolvable malware). Because self-replicating programs are extremely rare in this language, “ancestral” programs that are used to initiate evolution experiments are hand-written. An investigation into the likelihood that self-replicating programs could emerge via a chance process ( Adami and LaBar, 2017 ) led to a project to map all possible small self-replicators. A search of all programs of length 6 and 7 found none. But an exhaustive search of all length 8 programs found 914 “colony-forming” programs ( C G et al., 2017 ) among the 26^{8}\approx 209\times 10^{9} possible programs 1 1 1 Because self-replication does not require making exact copies, programs that create variants that are able to replicate so that a sustained growing group is formed are also deemed to be “viable”. Thus, our criterion for viability is the same as that for bacteria growing in a dish with nutrients. . An even more extensive search of all 26^{9}\approx 5.43\times 10^{12} programs of length 9 ( C G and Adami, 2021 ) found exactly 36,171 viable sequences, which form clusters in sequence space (Fig. 1 ). Figure 1: Network representation of the largest cluster of avidian replicators of length 9, containing over 94% of the replicators, with edges drawn between one-mutant neighbors. This graph consists of five sparsely connected groups of tightly-connected clusters. The viable sequences occupy a fraction of 6.66 \times 10^{-9} of the total feature space, corresponding to just a little under 6 mers of information (out of the 9 mers of sequence entropy). We will use this large fitness landscape to test whether we can fool state-of-the-art AI to misclassify non-replicators as replicators with high confidence. Figure 2: (top) Cross-entropy loss as a function of epoch for a typical training trial. Loss on training set in blue, loss on validation set in orange. (bottom) Classification accuracy on training (blue) and validation (orange) sets as a function of epoch. Experimental Design We split the 36,171 unique

Read the complete text