Generalized symmetries and emergence in axion effective field theories

Nathaniel Craig, and Dan Sehayek · 2026

Read Generalized symmetries and emergence in axion effective field theories by Nathaniel Craig, and Dan Sehayek (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-11877.txt.

Introduction

Sehayek and Craig study how higher symmetry structures constrain axion effective field theories. Higher-group and non-invertible symmetries set limits on the energy scales where different symmetries can emerge at low energies, guiding guesses about ultraviolet physics. In axion theories coupled to abelian and non-abelian gauge bosons, with or without charged matter, they clarify these emergence limits. The limits are universally met by anomaly inflow onto topological defects, while in perturbative ultraviolet completions they prove supererogatory, given the wide separation of scales.

Catalog record

CREATORNathaniel Craig, and Dan Sehayek
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE105548
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11877

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Generalized symmetries and emergence in axion effective field theories Nathaniel Craig, and Dan Sehayek Abstract We study the phenomenological consequences of higher symmetry structures in axion effective field theories. Higher-group and non-invertible symmetries impose parametric constraints on the energy scales at which different symmetries can emerge in the infrared, providing a guide to the ultraviolet physics. We clarify and analyze these emergence constraints in axion EFTs coupled to abelian and non-abelian gauge bosons, with and without charged matter. We show that emergence constraints are universally saturated by anomaly inflow onto topological defects, while in perturbative UV completions they are supererogatory owing to the parametric separation of scales. 1 Introduction The advent of generalized or categorical symmetries 9 ; 8 ; 82 ; 77 ; 102 ; 50 ; 126 ; 51 ; 31 ; 24 ; 44 ; 20 ; 58 ; 15 ; 16 ; 42 ; 45 ; 23 ; 21 ; 25 ; 13 ; 14 ; 26 (see 49 ; 32 ; 19 ; 111 ; 110 ; 120 for reviews) has had a profound impact across mathematics, high energy physics, and condensed matter physics, enabling (among other things) the successful generalization of the Landau paradigm. Within particle physics, they show promise in generalizing the ’t Hooft paradigm 1 1 1 To paraphrase 138 in analogy with the Landau paradigm, “small parameters are classified by the symmetries they break.” 132 ; 78 ; 86 ; 127 ; 87 ; 31 ; 44 ; 137 ; 56 ; 58 ; 45 ; 117 ; 43 ; 55 ; 38 ; 53 ; 59 ; 116 ; 106 ; 54 ; 62 , although their phenomenological consequences have yet to be fully explored. The archetypal example is the generalization of ordinary global symmetries to higher-form global symmetries 77 ; 102 ; 3 acting on p -dimensional charged objects. A continuous p -form global symmetry is generally associated with a conserved (p+1) -index current J^{\mu_{1}\cdots\mu_{p+1}} whose conservation implies the existence of a topological symmetry defect operator 2 2 2 Here, J^{(p+1)}:=J_{\mu_{1}...\mu_{p+1}}dx^{\mu_{1}}\wedge\cdots\wedge dx^{\mu_{p+1}} and hence d\star J^{(p+1)}=0 , U_{\alpha}(\Sigma_{d-p-1})=\exp\left[i\alpha\int_{{\Sigma}_{d-p-1}}\star J^{(p+1)}\right], (1) which is invariant under smooth deformations of \Sigma_{d-p-1} . The collection of these symmetry defect operators and their relations can then be used to define the symmetry. Perhaps the greatest phenomenological consequences for particle physics arise not from exact higher-form symmetries, but from anomalous ones. If a given global symmetry has an ABJ anomaly, it is still often possible to construct gauge-invariant topological symmetry operators involving the associated anomalous current by decorating these operators with appropriate topological quantum field theories (TQFTs). Since such defects are generally non-invertible, ABJ anomalous global symmetries are referred to as non-invertible symmetries. Examples of non-invertible defects for ABJ anomalous symmetries can be found in 44 ; 45 ; 58 ; 137 ; 60 ; 61 . Several more examples of non-invertible symmetries can be found in 1+1d conformal field theories (CFTs) and topological phases 134 ; 115 ; 73 ; 71 ; 72 ; 2 ; 27 ; 37 ; 109 ; 130 ; 1 ; 124 ; 91 ; 36 ; 108 ; 121 , including the non-invertible Kramers-Wannier duality of the Ising CFT 107 ; 122 ; 123 . Other recent examples of non-invertible symmetries in higher-dimensional theories, including lattice gauge theories and supersymmetric theories, have been discussed in 119 ; 48 ; 47 ; 6 ; 103 ; 41 ; 98 ; 57 ; 7 ; 100 ; 17 ; 46 ; 24 ; 13 ; 84 ; 4 ; 79 ; 113 ; 99 . In addition to ABJ anomalies, a global symmetry in a given theory may have ’t Hooft anomalies, which represent an obstruction to gauging the global symmetry. In some cases, a collection of symmetries that participate in a ’t Hooft anomaly can still be consistently gauged by imposing a higher-group structure. Concretely, given a collection of p_{i} -form global symmetries with p_{1}<p_{2}<\cdots<p_{n}, (2) we can introduce a set of background gauge fields B_{i}^{(p_{i}+1)} that would ordinarily transform as \delta B_{i}^{(p_{i}+1)}=d\Lambda_{i}^{(p_{i})} where \Lambda_{i}^{(p_{i})} is a p_{i} -form gauge parameter. We say that there is a (p_{n}+1) -group global symmetry if the theory is not invariant under the standard gauge transformations described above, but is instead invariant under a correlated set of background transformations of the form \delta B_{i}^{(p_{i}+1)}=d\Lambda_{i}^{(p_{i})}+\sum_{j\leq i}\Lambda_{j}^{(p_{j})}\wedge\alpha_{j}^{(i)}\left(\left\{B_{j}^{(p_{j}+1)}\right\}\right)+\mathcal{O}\left(\Lambda^{2}\right) (3) where \alpha_{j}^{(i)} is a p_{i}-p_{j}+1 -form that depends on the background gauge fields B_{j}^{(p_{j}+1)} for j<i and the terms in \mathcal{O}(\Lambda^{2}) are referred to as Schwinger terms. Well-known examples of such symmetries are the 2-group symmetries that arise from the gauging of magnetic 1-form symmetries 50 and the 3-group symmetries that arise from the mixed ’t Hooft anomaly between the axion-periodicity and electric/center 1-form symmetry in axion-Maxwell/Yang-Mills 31 ; 45 ; 52 ; 86 ; 87 . See 102 ; 18 ; 11 ; 70 ; 90 ; 127 ; 92 ; 51 ; 5 ; 88 ; 64 ; 63 ; 10 ; 12 ; 22 ; 101 for additional examples of higher-group symmetries in topological phases, QCD, spin liquids, hydrodynamics, holography and superconformal field theories. Both ABJ and ’t Hooft anomalies of 0-form global symmetries have long provided a powerful guide to the phenomenology of gauge theories as a function of scale, since the anomalies must be matched along RG flows. Unsurprisingly, the higher symmetry structures induced by anomalies are equally powerful. In particular, both higher-group and non-invertible symmetries reveal constraints on the scales at which their constituent symmetries emerge. Generically, if a theory possesses an emergent (p+1) -form higher group symmetry that correlates background gauge field transformations of a non-anomalous p -form global symmetry with those of a ’t Hooft-anomalous q -form global symmetry, then it follows that the emergence scale of the p -form symmetry must be parametrically greater than or equal to the emergence scale of the q -form symmetry. Furthermore, symmetry defects associated with non-invertible symmetries are generally constructed by half-gauging or half-higher-gauging a collection of symmetries, from which it follows that the emergence scale of the gauged symmetries must be parametrically greater than or equal to that of the non-invertible symmetry. Emergence constraints are a potentially powerful guide for phenomenology, as they must hold in any UV completion of an effective field theory with a higher symmetry structure. Such structures are ubiquitous in the Standard Model and its extensions, and some implications of emergence constraints have been explored in the context of Standard Model flavor symmetries 56 and axion effective field theories 31 ; 45 . The goal of this paper is to fully explore the physical phenomena associated with the satisfaction of emergence constraints in axion effective field theories, building on the results of 31 ; 45 . As we will see, the coupled background gauge redundancies implied by higher-form, higher-group, and non-invertible symmetries lead directly to parametric inequalities among the energy scales at which different symmetries can emerge. We show that these constraints are already visible at the level of the infrared effective description, independent of microscopic details, and that they admit a clear physical interpretation in terms of screening, dynamical charged objects, and the breakdown of topological symmetry operators. In perturbative ultraviolet completions, we find that the

Read the complete text