Reduced pair breaking from extended disorder in unconventional superconductors: implications to 4Hb-TaS 2
Yuval Tsur, Mark H Fischer, Jonathan Ruhman · 2026
Read Reduced pair breaking from extended disorder in unconventional superconductors: implications to 4Hb-TaS 2 by Yuval Tsur, Mark H Fischer, Jonathan Ruhman (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-11738.txt.
Introduction
Tsur, Fischer, and Ruhman study reduced pair breaking from extended disorder in unconventional superconductors. Unconventional pairing should be suppressed by nonmagnetic disorder under Abrikosov-Gor'kov rules, yet metal dichalcogenides keep pairing despite resistance. Using a multiband model with spin-orbit links and an impurity potential like chalcogen gaps or adatoms, they compare spread with on-site point defects. Extended potentials reduce pair-breaking versus transport scatter, with the rate product near one-third over a range, since disorder matches gap structure. Such pairing proves more robust than standard rules.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yuval Tsur, Mark H Fischer, Jonathan Ruhman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37378 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11738
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reduced pair breaking from extended disorder in unconventional superconductors: implications to 4Hb-TaS 2 Yuval Tsur, Mark H Fischer, Jonathan Ruhman Abstract Unconventional superconductivity is generally expected to be strongly suppressed by nonmagnetic disorder, as captured by Abrikosov–Gor’kov (AG) theory. However, several materials, including transition metal dichalcogenides, exhibit signatures of unconventional pairing despite relatively high resistivities, suggesting a breakdown of the conventional relation between momentum relaxation and pair breaking. Here, we study this problem in H-phase transition metal dichalcogenides by computing the disorder-dressed pairing susceptibility. We employ a multiband model with spin-orbit coupling and include an impurity potential that mimics a common lattice defect, namely a chalcogen vacancy or site ad-atom. This yields to an extended impurity potential, which we compare with the commonly considered on-site (point defect) potential. We evaluate the momentum-relaxation rate and the pair-breaking rate on equal footing. We find that extended impurity potentials lead to a parametrically reduced pair-breaking rate compared to the transport scattering rate, with Γ τ D ∼ 1 / 3 \Gamma\tau_{D}\sim 1/3 over a wide parameter range. This reduction originates from the momentum structure of the disorder potential, which partially matches the internal structure of the superconducting gap and suppresses pair-breaking processes. As a result, unconventional pairing states are significantly more robust than predicted by standard AG theory. Our results provide a natural explanation for the persistence of unconventional superconductivity in systems with strong disorder and substantially alleviate the apparent conflict between high resistivity and unconventional pairing in materials such as 4Hb-TaS 2 . I Introduction The study of unconventional superconductivity 23 exposes rich emergent low-energy phenomena, ranging from novel collective bosonic modes to exotic fermionic and potentially anyonic excitations. Despite this richness, much of this phenomenological landscape remains only partially explored, largely due to the challenge of unambiguously identifying unconventional superconducting states. One of the standard identifying properties of unconventional pairing, namely their response to disorder, has recently been under renewed scrutiny. The celebrated theory of Abrikosov and Gor’kov (AG) 1 predicts that non- s -wave superconductors are highly sensitive even to non-magnetic disorder. Within the AG framework, superconductivity is destroyed once the mean free path l becomes comparable to the superconducting coherence length \xi , or equivalently when the single-particle scattering rate reaches the scale of the clean transition temperature, \hbar/\tau\sim k_{\rm B}T_{\rm c}^{(0)} . This conclusion relies on several assumptions: isotropic impurity scattering treated within the (self-consistent) Born approximation, negligible vertex corrections, and an effective single-band description, in which the momentum relaxation rate directly sets the pair-breaking rate. Under these conditions, the momentum relaxation rate 1/\tau , which can be estimated from transport measurements, provides a direct measure of the pair-breaking strength. However, a growing number of candidate non- s -wave superconductors appear to violate the AG expectation. Materials, such as the cuprates 13 , doped topological insulators 12 ; 24 , iron-based superconductors 26 ; 32 , transition-metal dichalcogenides 8 ; 31 , and certain kagome superconductors 10 exhibit signatures of unconventional pairing despite disorder levels that would naively imply \hbar/\tau\gtrsim k_{\rm B}T_{\rm c} . However, resistivity probes the momentum relaxation rate, whereas superconductivity is controlled by the pair-breaking rate \Gamma . These need not be equivalent: For example, in multiband systems with internal anisotropy, pair breaking is governed primarily by interband scattering processes that mix gap sectors with opposite signs, while intraband scattering dominates momentum relaxation 9 . Consequently, a large resistivity does not necessarily imply strong suppression of unconventional pairing. More generally, pair breaking is sensitive to scattering between regions with different gap phases, whereas the transport lifetime is controlled by backscattering, and the two need not coincide. In this context, the transition-metal dichalcogenide 4Hb-TaS 2 provides an intriguing example. It exhibits signatures of unconventional superconductivity together with a relatively high resistivity 28 . Structurally, 4Hb-TaS 2 consists of alternating H (trigonal prismatic) and T (rhombohedral) layers held together by van der Waals forces. The bulk T phase is a correlated insulator proposed to realize a quantum spin liquid 14 ; 29 , whereas the bulk H phase is metallic and superconducting at low temperatures. Unlike bulk 2H-TaS 2 , however, the 4Hb polytype displays a range of unconventional phenomena, including gapless edge modes, a \pi -phase shift in Little–Parks experiments 2 , magnetic memory above T_{\rm c} 25 , finite thermal conductivity and specific heat far below T_{\rm c} 34 , and an enhanced muon depolarization rate often interpreted as evidence for time-reversal-symmetry breaking 28 . At the same time, the measured resistivity is approximately 65 \mu\Omega cm 8 , which corresponds to a naive estimate of the transport life time \hbar/\tau_{\rm tr}\sim 10 meV, far exceeding the superconducting energy scale k_{\rm B}T_{\rm c}\sim 0.2 meV 22 . Several theoretical works have recently addressed similar discrepancies by generalizing AG theory to multiband systems or systems with strong spin-orbit coupling. In particular, Michaeli and Fu showed that odd-parity pairing in Dirac systems can be robust against density disorder 17 , a result later understood as a symmetry-based generalization of Anderson’s theorem 33 involving the product of chiral and time-reversal symmetry 6 . A further route to stabilizing unconventional superconductivity incorporates the specific site symmetry of the scatterer 10 ; 11 . Additionally, related ideas have been formulated in terms of superconducting fitness 27 ; 4 . Finally, in the context of monolayer transition-metal dichalcogenides, it has been shown that Ising spin-orbit coupling can induce parity-mixed superconductivity and qualitatively modify the response to magnetic fields and scalar disorder 18 ; 19 ; 20 . These approaches retain the core structure of AG theory but reveal that symmetry, band structure, and spin-orbit coupling can strongly suppress effective pair breaking. An open question is whether one must go even further beyond the standard AG assumptions—for instance by incorporating vertex corrections in the impurity problem—to obtain a complete description 1 1 1 The AG framework typically neglects vertex corrections in the impurity-averaged pairing interaction. In systems with strongly momentum-dependent or extended impurity potentials, such corrections may further renormalize the effective pair-breaking rate. . Motivated by these developments, we investigate disorder effects in 4Hb-TaS 2 within an AG-based framework adapted to its realistic band structure with Ising spin-orbit coupling and study various non- s -wave pairing states. Treating sulfur–selenium substitution as the main source of disorder, we compare the resulting finite-range impurity potentials with conventional on-site scattering. Since experiments primarily measure resistivity rather than the microscopic scattering rate, we analyze the ratio between the computed pair-breaking rate \Gamma and the momentum relaxation rate 1/\tau obtained from Boltzmann transport theory for fixed impurity concentration and coupling strength. We find that the dimensionless quantity \Gamma\tau depends sensitively on the impurity range and decreases with increasing spin-orbit coupling. For realistic parameters and extended-defect potentials, certain non- s -wave pairing states can withstand momentum lifetimes up to five times shorter than predicted by naive AG theory. While our results do not fully eliminate the discrepancy between experiment and conventional expectations, they substantially narrow the gap by demonstrating that large momentum relaxation rates do not necessarily imply comparably strong pair breaking. The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Section II, we present our model Hamiltonian, which includes an effective single-orbital model and two