Global m = 1 m=1 slow mode in near-Keplerian self-gravitating torus: applications to stellar nuclear disks and AGN molecular tori

Elena Bannikova, Volodymyr Akhmetov, Peter Berczik, Serhii Skolota, Massimo Capaccioli, Maryna Ishchenko · 2026

Read Global m = 1 m=1 slow mode in near-Keplerian self-gravitating torus: applications to stellar nuclear disks and AGN molecular tori by Elena Bannikova, Volodymyr Akhmetov, Peter Berczik, Serhii Skolota, Massimo Capaccioli, Maryna Ishchenko (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-11528.txt.

Introduction

Bannikova and five colleagues simulate a self-gravitating torus around a central mass to test whether a slow lopsided mode can arise on its own. Using a high-order Hermite GPU code, they find a global m=1 mode forms from symmetric starts. Coherent apsidal alignment sustains the lopsided structure over long timescales, aided by nonlinear links of low-order modes and enough vertical thickness. The long-lived overdensity displaces the central mass from the center, offering a frame for eccentric nuclear disks like M31's and for AGN molecular tori.

Catalog record

CREATORElena Bannikova, Volodymyr Akhmetov, Peter Berczik, Serhii Skolota, Massimo Capaccioli, Maryna Ishchenko
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68045
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11528

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Global m = 1 m=1 slow mode in near-Keplerian self-gravitating torus: applications to stellar nuclear disks and AGN molecular tori Elena Bannikova, Volodymyr Akhmetov, Peter Berczik, Serhii Skolota, Massimo Capaccioli, Maryna Ishchenko Abstract Context. Global m = 1 m=1 asymmetries are observed in a variety of self-gravitating astrophysical systems and are often interpreted as large-scale slow modes in near-Keplerian potentials. Prominent examples include eccentric nuclear disks in galactic centres, such as the double nucleus of M31. However, the dynamical origin and long-term stability of such modes remain poorly understood. Aims. We investigate the dynamical evolution and stability of a self-gravitating, collisionless torus orbiting a dominant central mass, with the aim of determining whether a slow non-axisymmetric ( m = 1 m=1 ) mode can arise spontaneously. Methods. We performed a suite of direct N N -body simulations exploring a range of torus-to-central mass ratios and different initial particle distributions. The calculations were carried out with the high-order Hermite GPU integrator ( ϕ \phi -GPU ), enabling us to follow the long-term dynamical evolution of systems with a large number of particles. Results. We find that a global slow m = 1 m=1 mode forms spontaneously from initially axisymmetric configurations without imposed perturbations. The lopsided structure is sustained by coherent apsidal alignment of orbits and persists over secular timescales. Its maintenance requires hierarchical nonlinear coupling of low-order modes, including the participation of the m = 3 m=3 component, as well as a sufficient vertical thickness of the torus, indicating that the instability is inherently three-dimensional. As a dynamical consequence of the long-lived overdensity, the central mass acquires an essential displacement with respect to the system barycenter. Conclusions. Our results demonstrate that a long-lived global m = 1 m=1 mode can arise naturally in a geometrically thick self-gravitating torus orbiting a central mass. The mechanism identified here provides a dynamical framework for understanding eccentric nuclear disks, such as the double nuclei of M31 and NGC 4486B, as well as the molecular tori in AGNs, and suggests that the resulting lopsided asymmetry may produce observable offsets of the central supermassive black hole. 1 Introduction Lopsided ( m=1 ) modes are a common feature of stellar systems, appearing from galactic disks to the immediate vicinity of supermassive black holes (SMBHs). Such modes represent global eccentric distortions and can manifest as off-centred density enhancements, double nuclei, or one-armed spirals. They are found in different classes of astrophysical systems, including large-scale lopsided disks in spiral galaxies ( 28 ) and eccentric nuclear stellar disks around SMBHs, observed as nuclei with asymmetric surface-brightness distributions, such as in M 31 ( 20 ; 15 ; 16 ; 14 ) . A double (eccentric) nucleus is also present in the compact elliptical galaxy NGC 4486B ( 19 ; 6 ; 32 ) . High-resolution HST observations have revealed that asymmetric or double nuclei are not rare among early-type galaxies, with estimated occurrence rates of order 10% ( 17 ) . Recent ALMA observations reveal that molecular tori in nearby AGN are not axisymmetric. High-resolution maps of NGC 613 show that the central depletion region is displaced from the AGN position, indicating an m=1 asymmetry in the torus ( 10 ) . These findings motivate a detailed investigation of the formation and dynamical evolution of global m=1 modes. A number of theoretical and numerical studies have shown that near-Keplerian stellar systems can support slowly precessing m=1 configurations. Early interest in this problem was largely motivated by the interpretation of the nuclear stellar disk in M 31. In particular, 33 proposed that the observed double nucleus of M 31 can be understood as an eccentric stellar disk associated with a global lopsided ( m=1 ) mode. In this framework, the apparent double structure arises because stars spend more time near apocentre than pericentre, producing an asymmetric surface-brightness distribution with two apparent peaks. This interpretation naturally led to a number of theoretical models aimed at reproducing such lopsided configurations. In most early models of eccentric nuclear disks, the lopsided geometry was imposed or externally triggered. Within the thin-disk approximation, 12 found no linear m=1 instability in razor-thin annular disks orbiting a dominant central mass. Instead, finite-amplitude eccentric distortions were introduced, after which the system evolved into long-lived, slowly precessing lopsided states, with pattern speed increasing approximately linearly with the disk-to-central mass ratio. 26 constructed eccentric-disk models for M 31 by superposing Keplerian stellar orbits around a central mass and fitting a parameterized distribution function to reproduce the observed photometric and kinematic properties. The m=1 structure is prescribed through the eccentricity profile, with orbits computed in a fixed Keplerian potential without including disk self-gravity. The problem was further explored using high-resolution N -body simulations by 2 , who modelled the nuclear disk of M 31 as a self-gravitating stellar system orbiting a SMBH. Their three-dimensional simulations showed that an initially eccentric, apsidally aligned disk can remain stable and long-lived. Subsequent self-consistent orbit-superposition models were presented in ( 30 ) and ( 9 ) , constructing equilibrium eccentric disks from aligned Keplerian orbits around a central mass, typically neglecting disk self-gravity. These models reproduce the observed structure but treat the m=1 configuration as prescribed. More recent studies have largely followed similar lines, considering eccentric nuclear disks in which the m=1 geometry is imposed through initial conditions or external perturbations. N -body simulations show that a coherent mode can be maintained when apsidal alignment is present initially, while orbit-based and secular approaches construct such configurations by design ( 34 ; 29 ) . External mechanisms, including SMBH recoil and galaxy interactions, can also produce eccentric disks through imposed perturbations ( 1 ; 27 ) . Recent studies indicate that self-gravity can help maintain coherent m=1 modes by counteracting differential precession, although long-lived global modes may require additional conditions ( 22 ; 21 ) . Following our earlier results ( 4 ; 5 ; 3 ) , we revisit this problem by focusing on the intrinsic dynamical role of torus self-gravity. In contrast to models in which the m=1 geometry is imposed or externally triggered, we consider an initially axisymmetric toroidal distribution of massive particles orbiting a central mass. Using high-resolution direct 3D N -body simulations, we demonstrate that a global m=1 mode emerges spontaneously after the system reaches a quasi-equilibrium state, without imposed asymmetry or external perturbations. We further investigate the conditions for the long-term persistence of this mode. Finally, we apply our results to stellar nuclear disks in M 31 and NGC 4486B, as well as to the molecular torus in NGC 613. 2 Initial conditions and integration procedure We consider a toroidal distribution of N massive particles of equal mass m orbiting a central mass ( M_{\text{c}} ). We choose a random initial distribution of particles in Keplerian elements: the semi-major axes of all particles a_{k} are randomly distributed within the interval [ R_{\text{tor}}-R_{0} ,.., R_{\text{tor}}+R_{0} ] , with eccentricities in the range e_{k}=[0,..,e_{\text{max}}] . In this case, the mean radius of the particle distribution is located in the equatorial plane and corresponds to the major radius of the torus R_{\text{tor}} . The characteristic radius R_{0} represents the minor torus radius which determines the width of the particle spread (Fig. 1 ). Figure

Read the complete text