Scale-dependent surface and volume density properties of filaments in molecular clouds
Guo-Yin Zhang, Alexander Men’shchikov, Jin-Zeng Li · 2026
Read Scale-dependent surface and volume density properties of filaments in molecular clouds by Guo-Yin Zhang, Alexander Men’shchikov, Jin-Zeng Li (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-11485.txt.
Introduction
Zhang, Men'shchikov, and Li analyze filaments in seven clouds via getsf. They also derive volume density profiles. Widths grow as power laws. Surface widths scale to the one-half, volume widths to about thirty-seven hundredths. Widths span one hundredth to one parsec against a tenth-parsec width. Median density slopes near two point one to two point four sit below the isothermal cylinder value four. Volume contrasts of seventeen to fifty-two far exceed surface contrasts near one to three, so filaments stand out far more in three dimensions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Guo-Yin Zhang, Alexander Men’shchikov, Jin-Zeng Li |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88360 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11485
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Scale-dependent surface and volume density properties of filaments in molecular clouds Guo-Yin Zhang, Alexander Men’shchikov, Jin-Zeng Li Abstract We present a systematic analysis of scale-dependent properties of filamentary structures in seven nearby molecular clouds – Taurus , Ophiuchus , Perseus , Orion A , California , IC 5146 , and Vela C – using the multiscale extraction method getsf . Alongside the usual surface density profiles Σ ( r ) \Sigma(r) , we derive volume density profiles ρ ( r ) \rho(r) for a large sample of filaments, providing new observational constraints on their three-dimensional structure. The half-maximum widths H H and h h of the surface and volume density profiles, respectively, increase systematically with spatial scale, following power laws H ~ ∝ Y 0.50 \tilde{H}\propto Y^{0.50} and h ~ ∝ Y 0.37 \tilde{h}\propto Y^{0.37} , with distributions spanning ∼ \sim 0.01–1 pc across all scales, challenging the notion of a universal filament width of ∼ \sim 0.1 pc. The median volume density slopes β ~ ≈ 2.1 \tilde{\beta}\approx 2.1 – 2.4 2.4 are systematically lower than the value β = 4 \beta=4 expected for an isothermal cylinder in hydrostatic equilibrium. For shallow profiles with β ≲ 1 \beta\lesssim 1 , the volume density width h h falls below the surface density width H H by one to two orders of magnitude, demonstrating that surface density widths overestimate the true physical extent of filaments with shallow profiles. Volume density contrasts are substantially higher than surface density contrasts ( C ~ ρ ≈ 17 \tilde{C}_{\rho}\approx 17 – 52 52 vs. C ~ Σ ≈ 1.1 \tilde{C}_{\Sigma}\approx 1.1 – 2.7 2.7 ), confirming that filaments are substantially more prominent in three dimensions than their projected appearance suggests. The median linear densities of filaments increase linearly with spatial scale, Λ ~ ∝ Y \tilde{\Lambda}\propto Y , with the fraction of supercritical filaments ( Λ > 15 M ⊙ \Lambda>15\,M_{\odot} pc -1 ) increasing strongly with scale and varying widely among clouds, from ∼ \sim 7% in Taurus and Ophiuchus to ∼ \sim 54% in Vela C, broadly consistent with the known star formation activity of the clouds. The statistical properties of the combined filament linear density function across all seven clouds will be presented in a subsequent paper. Measured filament widths and slopes depend systematically on angular resolution and distance, highlighting the importance of accounting for resolution bias in comparative filament studies. 1 Introduction Filamentary structures in the cold interstellar medium (ISM) play a central role in star formation ( 15 ; 50 , for recent reviews) . Herschel 1 1 1 Herschel is an ESA space observatory with science instruments provided by European-led Principal Investigator consortia and with important participation from NASA ( 49 ) . imaging surveys of nearby Galactic clouds have revealed that filaments dominate the mass budget of molecular clouds at high densities and host most prestellar cores and star formation ( 4 ; 40 ; 52 ; 27 ; 32 ; 10 ) . A notable result from Herschel studies is the apparently common width ( {\sim\,}0.1 pc) of filaments observed in various molecular clouds ( 5 ; 6 ) . Similar widths were found in molecular clouds such as Taurus, Ophiuchus, and IC 5146, appearing largely independent of filament surface density or environmental conditions ( 46 ; 2 ; 6 ) . This characteristic width may represent a fundamental property associated with the physics underlying filament formation and evolution, potentially linked to the magnetized turbulent correlation length within molecular clouds ( 3 ) . Recent work for Ophiuchus indicates, however, that while the median width is consistent with this typical value, it represents a cloud-averaged property with a broad distribution ( 23 ) . Early observational evidence for a true cylindrical geometry was provided by 29 , who used multiple HC 3 N transitions toward the B213 filament in Taurus to derive a line-of-sight dimension comparable to its projected width, supporting the view that filaments are finite structures with a well-defined outer boundary, consistent with the finite-cylinder model developed in 39 . However, the interpretation of these observed widths faces both observational and methodological challenges. Recent studies have raised important questions regarding this universal width, suggesting that measured filament widths could be significantly affected by the insufficient angular resolution of Herschel observations ( 48 ; 47 ) , similar to distance effects reported for observed sources ( 31 ) . The observed correlation between filament widths and distances to molecular clouds ( 47 ) challenges the concept of a universal intrinsic scale for filaments. Although convergence tests by 3 confirmed nearly constant widths for filaments in nearby star-forming regions, suggesting that resolution effects may not fully explain the observed width distribution, the issue remains contentious. Beyond resolution effects, filament properties derived in previous studies may be affected by systematic methodological biases. 39 demonstrated that the traditional approach of fitting surface density profiles with the Plummer function is fundamentally inconsistent with the finite nature of filamentary structures and showed that deriving filament widths and slopes by fitting median surface density profiles can lead to large systematic errors. Furthermore, they found that the standard assumptions relating volume and surface density slopes via \beta=\gamma+1 and assuming similar widths ( h\approx H ) are generally invalid for shallow profiles ( \beta\lesssim 2 ). To address these issues, we developed a fitting method that accounts for the finite nature of filaments, providing an analytical fitting function for surface density profiles and enabling consistent derivation of physical volume density parameters. The formation of filamentary structures involves complex interplay between turbulence, magnetic fields, and gravity ( 14 ; 20 ; 19 ; 12 ; 11 , e.g.,) . Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) simulations consistently produce filaments as natural outcomes of turbulent ISM evolution, with widths influenced by gravitational collapse and magnetic support ( 53 ; 43 ) . Observational studies have revealed hierarchical substructuring of filamentary structures, with larger-scale filaments containing intertwined smaller-scale sub-filaments or fibers ( 17 ; 16 ; 13 ; 54 , e.g.,) . These findings challenge simplistic models of uniform cylindrical filaments and have implications for both filament formation theories and fragmentation processes leading to star formation, potentially influencing the resulting core mass function (CMF) and stellar initial mass function ( 41 ; 1 ; 27 ; 26 ; 31 ) . Despite this progress, fundamental questions remain concerning the physical mechanisms controlling filament widths, the role of filament substructures in star formation, and the impact of finite angular resolution on derived filament properties. Addressing these questions requires systematic study of filaments and sub-filaments (fibers) detected at distinct spatial scales. The multiscale, multiwavelength extraction method getsf ( 37 ) is specifically designed to separate sources from filaments, subtract filament backgrounds, and detect filaments at arbitrary spatial scales while automatically producing their measurements. Critically, getsf has no free parameters, eliminating subjective decisions in parameter selection that affect other methods. The performance of getsf has been carefully evaluated in detailed benchmarks ( 36 ) , demonstrating its reliability for systematic studies of filaments and cores. In this work, we explore filamentary structures in Herschel images of well-known star-forming regions at distances of 140 to 920 pc across a wide range of