Entanglement inequalities for timelike intervals within dynamical holography

Gaurav Katoch, Debajyoti Sarkar, Bhim Sen · 2026

Read Entanglement inequalities for timelike intervals within dynamical holography by Gaurav Katoch, Debajyoti Sarkar, Bhim Sen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-11158.txt.

Introduction

Katoch, Sarkar, and Sen take timelike entanglement rules from one interval to two in a changing holographic model. This extends their earlier work on a single timelike region, now with two regions in play. Where regions do not overlap, timelike mutual information stays positive and a weak monotone rule holds. Subadditivity and the Araki-Lieb rule still hold when intervals overlap. Strong subadditivity, though, generally fails for timelike intervals, as their worked examples show.

Catalog record

CREATORGaurav Katoch, Debajyoti Sarkar, Bhim Sen
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65681
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11158

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Entanglement inequalities for timelike intervals within dynamical holography Gaurav Katoch, Debajyoti Sarkar, Bhim Sen Abstract This paper extends our previous work (arXiv:2504.14313) of a single timelike subregion to two, in the framework of AdS 3 -Vaidya holography. We confirm the positivity of timelike mutual information and the statement of weak monotonicity when the subregions are non-overlapping. We also study entanglement inequalities such as Araki-Lieb inequality and strong subadditivity when the intervals start to overlap. In line with the recent findings in the literature, we provide explicit working examples showing that the timelike version of the strong subadditivity is generally violated in these setups, even though the statements of subadditivity and Araki-Lieb inequality hold true. Keywords: AdS 3 -Vaidya, Timelike mutual information, Strong subadditivity. 1 Introduction It won’t be an overstatement to say that perhaps the most attractive feature of holography [ 25 , 13 , 33 ] is that it provides the geometrization of field theory quantities, and thereby supplies an alternative tractable handle on complicated field theoretic relationships governing them. One prime example of this is the geometrization of entanglement entropy (EE) of the boundary field theory in terms of the bulk Ryu-Takayanagi (RT) surfaces [ 32 ] . This quantity has been studied in exhaustive detail, and many of its features and distinctions are entailed via strong subadditivity, Araki-Lieb inequality, weak monotonicity, monogamy of mutual information etc. These properties are already of utmost significance purely within the subject of quantum information theory [ 34 ] , but they can also be rigorously worked out staying within the holographic setup [ 15 , 16 ] . To appreciate the simplicity and geometric intuition that the holography offers, for comparison, one can be invited to have a look at the highly non-trivial proof of strong subadditivity contained in [ 24 ] . Despite having such desirable features, holographic entanglement entropy is riddled with short-distance divergences proportional to the area of the RT surface, and any regulator dependent methods to render it finite essentially ends up making it scheme dependent. However, one can unequivocally define a scheme independent linear combination of entanglement entropies (called the mutual information) for two disjoint systems, that can be rendered free of UV divergences due to cancellation of short-distance singularities. Mutual information provides a measure of degree of correlation only between the disjoint subsystems and not with the rest of the system. It roughly tries to answer the question of how much information does the two disjoint systems share. Moreover, mutual information I(A,B) can be used to study the evolution of correlations in non-equilibrium systems. Other than being UV finite, it also satisfies a positivity statement ( I(A,B)\geq 0 ), with the inequality saturating to zero only when the density matrix of the combined interval is factorizable. In other words, mutual information vanishes only when the two systems lose their mutual correlation. This latter setup is often called a ‘disconnected’ phase, where the combined EE of the two intervals is simply a sum of their individual EE with the rest of the system. A positive mutual information therefore occurs in the ‘connected’ phase. All of these above notions can be straightforwardly generalized to the case when the intervals are timelike. Therefore, if one instead considers two non-overlapping timelike subregions A and B anchored at different boundary times, one can investigate the behaviour of timelike version of mutual information defined to be \displaystyle\tilde{I} \displaystyle\equiv\tilde{S}(A)+\tilde{S}(B)-\tilde{S}(A\cup B)\,. (1) Above, the various \tilde{S} denote the real part of the corresponding timelike entanglement entropy (TEE). 1 1 1 TEE is a complex quantity. For time independent states, in equations like ( 1 ), the imaginary parts cancel out. However, as we will see, this is not generally the case for the dynamical scenarios. In most of our analyses in this paper, we will always strip away the imaginary parts from the various TEEs of interest and just focus on their real parts. The discussion of such timelike mutual information (TMI) made its first appearance in [ 8 ] , where it was defined by replacing the usual entanglement entropies (in mutual information) by their timelike counterparts. The above expression for TMI can also be written alternatively in a more suggestive manner, namely \displaystyle\tilde{I} \displaystyle\equiv\tilde{S}^{D}_{AB}-\tilde{S}(A\cup B)\,. (2) Here \tilde{S}^{D}_{AB}=\tilde{S}(A)+\tilde{S}(B) denotes the collective timelike entanglement entropy in the disconnected phase, and \tilde{S}(A\cup B) is the collective TEE of the dominating phase (the phase with lesser entropy). The dominating phase can either be the disconnected phase or the connected phase depending upon the separation between the two subsystems. Following the work of [ 8 ] , one can show that for static cases (particularly for boundaries dual to pure AdS or BTZ black hole [ 4 ] ), TMI behaves exactly like its spacelike counterpart. In particular, when the two timelike intervals are separated by large times, the dominating phase is the disconnected one, yielding a vanishing TMI. However as their temporal separation decreases, TMI hits a turning point at which the connected phase becomes the dominating one, rendering a monotonically increasing positive TMI. In a previous paper [ 21 ] , following the works of [ 7 , 8 ] in static states, we computed the holographic timelike entanglement entropy (HTEE) of a globally quenched CFT dual to AdS 3 -Vaidya spacetime resulting from the spherical null shell collapse. Our holographic computations closely parallelled the covariant generalization (but now for the timelike case) of the RT prescription (known as HRT surfaces [ 18 ] ) that one implements for the spacelike intervals. In the original works of [ 7 , 8 ] the TEE was inspired from the ‘pseudo entropy’ developed in the context of non-hermitian states, which also appears in the discussions of de Sitter/conformal field theory (dS/CFT) correspondence [ 30 , 31 , 7 , 8 ] . However, there is no formal proof (unlike e.g. the proofs of [ 22 , 9 ] for the spacelike case) of the holographic TEE prescription for the dynamical cases. Therefore, it would be important to subject the validity of our results (particularly for the dynamical case) to test by investigating whether they also obey the analogous quantum information theoretic inequalities as mentioned above. For example, for the spatial subregions, the validity of strong subadditivity (SSA) in the static spacetimes was proven holographically in [ 15 ] using the dual RT surfaces (with a more detailed analysis presented in [ 16 ] ). The question of its validity for time dependent spacetimes like AdS 3 -Vaidya was carried out in [ 5 , 12 ] using the relevant HRT prescriptions. 2 2 2 Purely within quantum information theory, the statement of strong subadditivity is closely related to the concavity of von Neumann entropy, and in a way uniquely characterizes the von Neumann entropy by providing the strongest constraining condition (together with the continuity of the eigenvalues of density matrix, and its invariance under unitary transformations [ 17 ] ). However, the status of SSA for pseudo entropy is still in a relatively shaky ground. Although it lacks ample examples, it was shown in [ 28 ] (for free massive scalar fields living on the asymptotic boundary of Lifshitz spacetime), that pseudo entropy may sometimes

Read the complete text