From Answers to Arguments: Toward Trustworthy Clinical Diagnostic Reasoning with Toulmin-Guided Curriculum Goal-Conditioned Learning
Chen Zhan, Xiaoyu Tan, Gengchen Ma, Yu-Jie Xiong, Xiaoyan Jiang, Xihe Qiu · 2026
Read From Answers to Arguments: Toward Trustworthy Clinical Diagnostic Reasoning with Toulmin-Guided Curriculum Goal-Conditioned Learning by Chen Zhan, Xiaoyu Tan, Gengchen Ma, Yu-Jie Xiong, Xiaoyan Jiang, Xihe Qiu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-11137.txt.
Introduction
Zhan and five colleagues establish a framework for trustworthy clinical reasoning. Language models in decision support are obstructed by weak reasoning. In healthcare, correct answers alone are not enough; practice demands clarity for safety and duty. A weakness is correct answers through flawed reasoning. This signals grasp and risk of errors. The authors propose Curriculum Goal-Conditioned Learning, training models to generate diagnostic arguments following Toulmin structure. Its three-part curriculum builds by listing facts and diagnoses. It backs an idea while denying alternatives, gives a verdict.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chen Zhan, Xiaoyu Tan, Gengchen Ma, Yu-Jie Xiong, Xiaoyan Jiang, Xihe Qiu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69870 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11137
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
From Answers to Arguments: Toward Trustworthy Clinical Diagnostic Reasoning with Toulmin-Guided Curriculum Goal-Conditioned Learning Chen Zhan, Xiaoyu Tan, Gengchen Ma, Yu-Jie Xiong, Xiaoyan Jiang, Xihe Qiu Abstract The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) into clinical decision support is critically obstructed by their opaque and often unreliable reasoning. In the high-stakes domain of healthcare, correct answers alone are insufficient; clinical practice demands full transparency to ensure patient safety and enable professional accountability. A pervasive and dangerous weakness of current LLMs is their tendency to produce "correct answers through flawed reasoning." This issue is far more than a minor academic flaw; such process errors signal a fundamental lack of robust understanding, making the model prone to broader hallucinations and unpredictable failures when faced with real-world clinical complexity. In this paper, we establish a framework for trustworthy clinical argumentation by adapting the Toulmin model to the diagnostic process. We propose a novel training pipeline: Curriculum Goal-Conditioned Learning (CGCL) , designed to progressively train LLM to generate diagnostic arguments that explicitly follow this Toulmin structure. CGCL’s progressive three-stage curriculum systematically builds a solid clinical argument: (1) extracting facts and generating differential diagnoses; (2) justifying a core hypothesis while rebutting alternatives; and (3) synthesizing the analysis into a final, qualified conclusion. We validate CGCL using T-Eval , a quantitative framework measuring the integrity of the diagnosis reasoning. Experiments show that our method achieves diagnostic accuracy and reasoning quality comparable to resource-intensive Reinforcement Learning (RL) methods, while offering a more stable and efficient training pipeline. 1 1 1 https://github.com/Leonard-zc/CGCL. 1 Introduction Figure 1: Clinical Diagnostic Reasoning Paradigms. Large Language Models (LLMs) are rapidly reshaping both science and society, and healthcare shows this impact most vividly ( 49 ; 39 ) . From automating clinical note summarization and assisting in image interpretation to accelerating drug discovery ( 30 ; 25 ) , LLMs are now entering critical stages of the medical pipeline. Recent systems such as GPT-5 and Gemini-2.5-Pro have posted record-breaking results on medical benchmarks like MedQA and the USMLE, in some cases even surpassing human experts ( 29 ; 19 ; 41 ) . But standardized exams are not the same as real clinical practice. Clinical decision-making is not about picking the right option from a fixed set. Instead, it is about reasoning under uncertainty, integrating messy and incomplete information, and making judgments where the cost of error is human life ( 13 ; 28 ) . This leads us to the core scientific question: Do today’s LLMs truly have the capacity to function as reliable clinical decision-makers, or are they only test-takers with no license to practice? At the heart of this gap is a dangerous illusion: models that produce correct answers for the wrong reasons. Most current evaluation paradigms fixate on whether the final answer is correct, while overlooking the reasoning path that leads there ( 42 ; 20 ) . In medicine, however, the path matters as much as the destination. Take a patient with fever and elevated white blood cell count. An LLM might flag a bacterial infection and suggest antibiotics seemingly correct, but only by matching patterns in the text. What it may miss are subtle but critical indicators of sepsis, such as rising lactate levels or borderline hypotension, which demand urgent intervention. In this case, the model’s “right” answer is anchored in shallow reasoning that would fail under real clinical pressure ( 15 ) . Such brittle correctness is not a minor academic flaw; it is a systemic hazard. By rewarding outcomes without probing reasoning, current benchmarks inflate our perception of what LLMs can actually do. This misalignment fuels a growing trust crisis and stands as the central obstacle between impressive lab performance and safe, reliable use at the bedside. Figure 1 summarizes this shift from answer-centric evaluation to the structured clinical reasoning paradigm studied in this paper. This trust crisis is rooted not just in model behavior, but in the very way we evaluate and train them. On the evaluation side, current practices mostly reduce performance to answer accuracy or rely on subjective human ratings ( 2 ) . Neither provides a structured, quantitative way to assess the quality of reasoning—the logical steps, evidentiary grounding, and robustness of an argument remain largely invisible. On the training side, mainstream methods such as Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning (RL) inherit the same bias toward final answers ( 18 ) . The result is a cycle of over-optimizing for correctness while under-optimizing for reasoning. In theory, RL could help address this by shaping richer objectives, but in practice, the barriers are steep: designing reliable reward models is notoriously difficult, training can be unstable, and the computational demands can be substantial in practice. Breaking this bottleneck calls for new paradigms that are both stable and resource-efficient, while directly targeting reasoning as a first-class objective rather than a byproduct ( 27 ; 24 ) . A natural foundation for clinical reasoning is the Toulmin model of argumentation, which emphasizes how claims must be supported by evidence, qualified by uncertainty, and defended against counter-arguments ( 40 ) . This structure closely mirrors the reasoning clinicians use when moving from symptoms and lab results to a defensible diagnosis ( 17 ; 4 ) . Yet current LLM pipelines neither evaluate nor learn in this structured way, leaving their “reasoning” opaque and often superficial. To close this gap, we place the Toulmin model at the core of both evaluation and training. On the evaluation side, we introduce T-Eval , a scalable framework that quantitatively assesses an LLM’s diagnostic reasoning by explicitly measuring the strength of claims, evidence, and rebuttals ( 51 ) . On the training side, we design Curriculum Goal-Conditioned Learning (CGCL) , a pipeline that teaches a model to reason in Toulmin’s structured form, following the progression of clinical training ( 3 ; 35 ; 1 ) . In Stage 1 (Fact Gathering), the model plays the role of a junior resident, extracting findings and proposing an initial differential. In Stage 2 (Hypothesis Testing), it advances to a senior resident, justifying its main hypothesis with physiological evidence while refuting alternatives. In Stage 3 (Synthesis & Conclusion), it acts as an attending physician, integrating all evidence into a well-qualified final diagnosis. This curriculum can effectively operationalize Toulmin-style reasoning through imitation learning (e.g., SFT) without relying on RL. In experiments on complex real-world medical cases, CGCL-trained models not only achieve diagnostic accuracy competitive with strong baselines, but also substantially improve structured reasoning quality under T-Eval, with the clearest gains on smaller models. Figure 2: The Synergistic Architecture of CGCL and T-Eval for Trustworthy Clinical Reasoning. We make the following key contributions: (1) T-Eval: A Toulmin-based framework for evaluating clinical reasoning. We introduce the first scalable method to move beyond answer accuracy and directly measure the structure and integrity of diagnostic arguments, capturing how claims are supported, qualified, and defended. (2) CGCL: A training paradigm that instills Toulmin-style reasoning. We design a three-stage, goal-conditioned curriculum that mirrors medical training, systematically teaching LLMs to gather facts, test hypotheses, and synthesize conclusions in a transparent and stable manner. (3) Extensive validation on real-world clinical cases. Through comprehensive experiments, we demonstrate that a well-structured curriculum can match the