On sections of Lefschetz fibrations and bundles over 2-complexes

Jonathan A. Hillman, Riccardo Pedrotti · 2026

Read On sections of Lefschetz fibrations and bundles over 2-complexes by Jonathan A. Hillman, Riccardo Pedrotti (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-10943.txt.

Introduction

Hillman and Pedrotti study when fibrations admit sections, in two settings. First, a bundle over a finite two-complex admits a section exactly when the fiber inclusion is injective on fundamental groups. The associated short exact sequence must also split. Second, for Lefschetz fibrations over the disk, they give an algebraic test for which boundary mapping torus loops extend to sections over the disk. Finally, they apply this to achiral Lefschetz fibrations over the sphere formed by doubling, ensuring at least two homologically distinct sections.

Catalog record

CREATORJonathan A. Hillman, Riccardo Pedrotti
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60537
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.10943

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On sections of Lefschetz fibrations and bundles over 2-complexes Jonathan A. Hillman, Riccardo Pedrotti Abstract . We address the question of existence of sections of fibrations in two settings. First, we show that a bundle with base a finite 2-complex admits a section if and only if the inclusion of the fiber is π 1 \pi_{1} -injective and the associated short exact sequence of fundamental groups splits. Second, for Lefschetz fibrations over the disk we provide a complete algebraic criterion characterizing which loops in the boundary mapping torus extend to continuous or smooth sections over the disk. Finally, we apply our results to achiral Lefschetz fibrations over the sphere obtained by doubling along the vertical boundary, and give a criterion ensuring the existence of at least two homologically distinct sections. 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification 55R10, 57R22, 57K43 1. Introduction Given p:E\to B a fibration, a section is a map s:B\to E such that p\circ s=\Id_{B}:B\to B. For bundles over 2 -complexes, the existence of a section is essentially governed by homotopy theory as a consequence of the Homotopy Lifting Property (HLP). This is made precise in our first result. Theorem 2.1 . Let p:E\to{B} be a fibre bundle with base B a finite 2 -complex, and let \ast_{B} and \ast_{E} be base points such that p(\ast_{E})=\ast_{B} . Then there is a map s:B\to{E} such that ps=id_{B} if and only if the inclusion of the fibre F=p^{-1}(\ast_{B}) into E induces a monomorphism from \pi_{1}F to \pi_{1}E and there is a homomorphism \mathfrak{s}:\pi_{1}B\to\pi_{1}E such that p_{*}\mathfrak{s}=id_{B} . If so, we may assume that s_{*}=\mathfrak{s} . For Lefschetz fibrations, the question of the existence of a section is more geometric in nature, since homotopy theory alone does not fully capture the topological structure of the spaces involved. At the time of writing, it is still unknown whether any (closed) Lefschetz fibration over the sphere admits a section ( [ 1 , Problem 2.22] ). A potential approach to solve this problem is the following: (1) We divide the base sphere into two disks, D^{\text{crit}}\cup_{\partial}D^{\text{triv}} , one containing all the critical values of \pi (the critical disk ) and the other not (the trivial disk ). They share a common boundary identified with the equator. (2) After choosing a trivialization \Psi:{\left.\kern-1.2ptE\mathchoice{\vphantom{\big|}}{}{}{}\right|_{D^{\text{triv}}}}\cong\Sigma\times D^{\text{triv}}, there is no obstruction to finding a section over D^{\text{triv}} as a preimage s^{\text{triv}}:=\Psi^{-1}\big(\{\ast\}\times D^{\text{triv}}\big) (3) We determine whether the loop {\left.\kern-1.2pts^{\text{triv}}\mathchoice{\vphantom{\big|}}{}{}{}\right|_{\partial}} can be extended as a section over D^{\text{crit}} . In the second part of our paper, we completely solve step (3) , by fully characterizing the family of loops that can be extended to continuous or smooth sections over D^{\text{crit}} (Thm. 3.19 ). Our algebraic criterion reads as follows. Let \pi:E\to D be a Lefschetz fibration over the disk with k critical values z_{1},\dots,z_{k} , regular fiber a smooth closed orientable surface \Sigma and monodromy \tau\in\mathrm{Aut}(\Sigma) . Theorem 3.19 . Let \pi:E\to D be a Lefschetz fibration as above. Let \Sigma_{\tau} be the mapping torus of \tau\in\mathrm{Aut}(\Sigma) identified with the boundary of E . Let ([\alpha],1)\in\pi_{1}(\Sigma_{\tau},\ast_{\Sigma}) and let s_{\alpha} be a section representative for it. There exists a continuous section \sigma_{\alpha} of E extending s_{\alpha} if and only if the following condition is met: choose a compatible factorization of the monodromy \tau : \tau=\tau_{V_{k}}\circ\cdots\circ\tau_{V_{1}}. Then, as a based loop in \Sigma , \alpha can be decomposed as \alpha\sim\alpha_{1}\star\tau_{V_{1}}^{-1}\alpha_{2}\star\cdots\star(\tau_{V_{k-1}}\circ\cdots\circ\tau_{V_{1}})^{-1}\alpha_{k}, where each \alpha_{i} is “twisted-conjugated” to some multiple of a based representative \widetilde{V_{i}} of the i -th vanishing cycle V_{i} . I.e. there exist an integer m_{i} and a based loop \zeta_{i} in \Sigma such that \alpha_{i}\sim\zeta_{i}\star\widetilde{V_{i}}^{m_{i}}\star\tau_{V_{i}}^{-1}(\overline{\zeta_{i}}). Moreover, the section \sigma_{\alpha} is smoothable if and only if \forall i\ m_{i}\in\{0,1\} . We remark that a compatible positive factorization of the monodromy, arising for example after choosing an ordered set of vanishing paths, is an auxiliary choice in our theorem. If the loop \alpha can be successfully decomposed with respect to one positive factorization, then it can be decomposed for any other factorization obtained via Hurwitz moves. Therefore, the property of being extendable is a property of \alpha , and not of the specific choice of vanishing paths (see Rem. 3.20 ). In [ 3 , Theorem 1.1] , the author constructed an example of an achiral Lefschetz fibration whose fiber \Sigma has arbitrarily high genus, as a double of a Lefschetz fibration f_{0}:X_{0}\to S^{2} with horizontal boundary \partial X=\sqcup S^{3} and such that f_{0} does not admit any sections. The argument relies primarily on observing that f_{0} does not admit a section for homology reasons: the (relative) fundamental class of the fiber is not primitive in H_{2}(X_{0}) and the restriction f_{0}:\partial X_{0}\to S^{2} is a union of several Hopf fibrations. By doubling X_{0} , the author obtains an example of a (closed) achiral Lefschetz fibration D(X_{0})\to S^{2} with no section. In this paper we start with a Lefschetz fibration over the disk E\to D and regular (closed) fiber \Sigma and we double along its vertical boundary. We obtain an achiral Lefschetz fibration D(E)\to S^{2} with many sections since both E and the gluing locus (a mapping torus), poses no homological obstructions. Our last result in this paper is the following criterion for these sections to be homologically essential. Theorem 3.21 . If there exists an index j\in\{1,\dots,k\} and an integer m such that m\cdot[V_{j}]\notin\mathrm{Im}(\Id_{\ast}-\tau_{*})\subset H_{1}(\Sigma;\mathbb{Z}) , then D(E) admits at least two homologically distinct sections. We conclude by remarking that if the total monodromy \tau of E\to D is trivial, then the criterion of Theorem 3.21 is automatically satisfied (see Cor. 3.22 ) Acknowledgments. We are grateful to İnanç Baykur for his careful explanations and insightful conversations about Lefschetz fibrations, and to Bob Gompf for several helpful discussions on his recent work. 2. Sections of bundles over 2 -complexes A bundle projection p:E\to B with base B and fibre F aspherical closed surfaces has a section if and only if the associated short exact sequence of fundamental groups splits. This is an immediate consequence of the Homotopy Lifting Property (HLP). For since E is aspherical any splitting homomorphism is realized by a based map s:B\to E such that ps\simeq id_{B} , and s is then homotopic to a section, by the HLP. Theorem 2.1 . Let p:E\to{B} be a fibre bundle with base B a finite 2 -complex, and let \ast_{B} and \ast_{E} be base points such that p(\ast_{E})=\ast_{B} . Then there is a map s:B\to{E} such that ps=id_{B} if and only if the inclusion of the fibre F=p^{-1}(\ast_{B}) into E induces a monomorphism from \pi_{1}F to \pi_{1}E and there is a homomorphism \mathfrak{s}:\pi_{1}B\to\pi_{1}E such that p_{*}\mathfrak{s}=id_{B} . If so, we may assume that s_{*}=\mathfrak{s} . Proof. The necessity of these conditions follows from the exact sequence of homotopy for the bundle If p has a section s , so that ps=id_{B} , then \pi_{2}(p) is an epimorphism, so \pi_{1}F\to\pi_{1}E is injective, and \mathfrak{s}=s_{*} is a splitting homomorphism. Suppose that \pi_{1}F\to\pi_{1}E is a monomorphism and \mathfrak{s}:\pi_{1}B\to\pi_{1}E is a splitting homomorphism for p_{*} . Let B^{[1]} be the 1-skeleton of B , and let j:B^{[1]}\to{B} be the inclusion, Then B^{[1]}\simeq\vee^{r}S^{1} for some r\geq 0 , where each copy of S^{1} represents a generator a_{i} of \pi_{1}(B) . For each such generator a_{i} ,

Read the complete text