On periodic homotopy and homology equivalences of spaces
Shaul Barkan, Gijs Heuts, Yuqing Shi · 2026
Read On periodic homotopy and homology equivalences of spaces by Shaul Barkan, Gijs Heuts, Yuqing Shi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-10867.txt.
Introduction
Barkan, Heuts, and Shi compare routes into homotopy theory at chromatic height n: T(n)-homology versus v_n-periodic groups. Building on Bousfield's observation that the two differ greatly, their tool is parametric T(n)-equivalence, a map inducing an equivalence on local systems valued in T(n)-local spectra. Results are sharpest for infinite loop spaces, including a T(n)-local Kuhn result on Morava K-theory of the Whitehead tower. They give the L_n^f-localization of Omega-infinity E with vanishing L_{n-1}^f.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shaul Barkan, Gijs Heuts, Yuqing Shi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 105945 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.10867
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On periodic homotopy and homology equivalences of spaces Shaul Barkan, Gijs Heuts, Yuqing Shi Abstract There are at least two ways to approach the homotopy theory of spaces ‘at chromatic height n n ’: one may localize with respect to T ( n ) T(n) -homology or with respect to v n v_{n} -periodic homotopy groups. It was already observed by Bousfield that these two options yield rather different results. We build on his work to prove precise comparison results between the two notions. A crucial concept is a more robust notion of T ( n ) T(n) -equivalence that we call ‘parametric T ( n ) T(n) -equivalence’: this is a map of spaces that induces an equivalence on ∞ \infty -categories of local systems valued in T ( n ) T(n) -local spectra. Our results are sharpest in the case of infinite loop spaces, where amongst other things we prove a T ( n ) T(n) -local version of a result of Kuhn on the Morava K K -theory of the Whitehead tower. As a corollary of our results we also produce a formula for the L n f \Loc_{n}^{f} -localization of an infinite loop space Ω ∞ E \operatorname{\Omega}\mathopen{}^{\infty}E of a spectrum satisfying L n − 1 f E ≃ 0 \Loc_{n-1}^{f}E\simeq 0 . 1 Introduction The chromatic philosophy is the central organizing principle of stable homotopy theory. One studies the \infty -category of spectra by decomposing it into ‘monochromatic’ pieces. This can either mean localizing with respect to the prime fields K(n) , the Morava K -theories, or localizing with respect to the telescopes T(n) , recording the v_{n} -periodic homotopy groups of spectra. The two options are closely related, but have recently been shown to differ when n\geq 2 [ 11 ] . In this paper we are concerned with unstable homotopy theory, i.e., the homotopy theory of spaces. As in the stable case one can decompose the \infty -category of spaces into periodic or monochromatic pieces, but there is potential ambiguity in what one means by this precisely. There are at least the following two possibilities to consider: (1) The localization of the \infty -category of pointed spaces \mathscr{S}_{*} with respect to v_{n} -periodic homotopy groups, denoted \mathscr{S}_{v_{n}} . We will review the \infty -category \mathscr{S}_{v_{n}} in Section 3 . This localization can be viewed as a generalization of rational homotopy theory to heights n>0 . The \infty -category \mathscr{S}_{v_{n}} admits a description in terms of Lie algebras analogous to Quillen’s results on rational homotopy theory [ 18 ] . (2) The localization of the \infty -category of spaces \mathscr{S} with respect to T(n) -homology isomorphisms (or K(n) -homology isomorphisms). This is an example of Bousfield localization with respect to a homology theory [ 3 ] . The first perspective emphasizes homotopy groups, the second focuses on homology. For the \infty -category of spectra, v_{n} -periodic homotopy and T(n) -homology groups are the same thing, so the distinction above does not play a role in stable homotopy theory. Also, in the case n=0 the theory of Serre classes shows that for spaces rational homotopy equivalences and rational homology isomorphisms agree, at least in the simply-connected case, so that (1) and (2) are almost identical. However, in the cases n>0 , the localizations (1) and (2) behave very differently for the category of spaces. Let us illustrate this by some examples: (a) A v_{n} -periodic equivalence of pointed spaces f\colon X\to Y need not be a T(n) -homology isomorphism. For example, any truncated space X=\tau_{\leq k}X has vanishing v_{n} -periodic homotopy groups, but need not have vanishing T(n) -homology. Indeed, the T(n) -homology of Eilenberg–MacLane spaces K(\mathbb{F}_{p},k) is nontrivial for k\leq n by the calculations of Ravenel–Wilson [ 26 ] . (b) There exist more sophisticated examples of v_{n} -periodic equivalences that are not T(n) -homology isomorphisms and which cannot be avoided by imposing connectivity hypotheses. Indeed, consider the space X=BU . Then X has vanishing v_{2} -periodic homotopy groups, but it does not have vanishing T(2) -homology. One can show that any highly connected cover of BU will have the same features. (See 1.4 for more on this phenomenon.) (c) In the converse direction, a T(n) -homology isomorphism need not be a v_{n} -periodic equivalence. For example, Langsetmo–Stanley [ 24 ] construct modifications of the Adams map \alpha\colon S^{k+2(p-1)}/p\to S^{k}/p that retain the property of it being a T(1) -homology isomorphism, but fail to be v_{1} -periodic equivalences. In his extensive work on homotopical and homological localizations, Bousfield gives many results on the relation between the notion of v_{n} -periodic equivalences and T(n) -homology isomorphisms [ 5 , 6 , 8 ] . These play an important role in recent developments in unstable periodic homotopy theory [ 18 ] and in the study of telescopically localized algebraic K -theory [ 23 ] . In this paper we further clarify the relation between localizations (1) and (2) above. Main results The starting point of our work is the following: rather than focusing on maps f inducing isomorphisms on T(n) -homology, it turns out to be more robust to consider maps giving T(n) -isomorphisms ‘with local coefficients’, in the following sense. We call a map f\colon X\to Y of spaces a parametric T(n) -equivalence if it induces an equivalence of \infty -categories f^{*}\colon\mathrm{Fun}(Y,\mathrm{Sp}_{T(n)})\to\mathrm{Fun}(X,\mathrm{Sp}_{T(n)}). In other words, we want f to identify the \infty -categories of parametrized T(n) -local spectra over X and over Y , hence the term. A parametric T(n) -equivalence is in particular a T(n) -homology isomorphism; we will discuss the relation between the two notions in more detail in Section 2 . The main thread of this paper will be to compare the three notions of v_{n} -periodic equivalence, T(n) -equivalence, and parametric T(n) -equivalence. Theorems 1.1 , 1.2 , and 1.3 are general comparison results that are sharpenings of Bousfield’s existing work on the topic. The main novelty here is 1.6 , which gives a rather sharp answer for infinite loop spaces. Its proof involves not only our first set of results, but also a collection of results on T(n) -local \mathbb{E}_{\infty} -rings that might be of independent interest. Note that when we speak of T(n) , we have implicitly already chosen a prime number p . To state our results we adopt the following somewhat nonstandard convention: we say a space X is weakly p -local if for any basepoint x\in X , the homotopy groups \pi_{n}(X,x) are p -local abelian groups for n\geq 2 . (We are not assuming anything about \pi_{0} and \pi_{1} , nor any type of nilpotence condition.) Similarly, we call X weakly p^{\infty} -torsion if the homotopy groups \pi_{n}(X,x) are p^{\infty} -torsion (meaning every element is annihilated by some power of p ) for n\geq 2 . In other words, X is weakly p^{\infty} -torsion if it is weakly p -local and its simply connected cover has trivial rationalization. Theorem 1.1 . Suppose X is a weakly p -local space and n\geq 0 a natural number. Then X\to* is a parametric T(i) -equivalence for every i\leq n if and only if X is (n+1) -connected and has vanishing v_{i} -periodic