Modeling Tripartite Hyperevents in Scientific Collaboration Networks
Amin Gino Fabbrucci Barbagli, Jürgen Lerner, Viviana Amati, Domenico De Stefano · 2026
Read Modeling Tripartite Hyperevents in Scientific Collaboration Networks by Amin Gino Fabbrucci Barbagli, Jürgen Lerner, Viviana Amati, Domenico De Stefano (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-10808.txt.
Introduction
Barbagli and three colleagues model tripartite hyperevents in scientific collaboration networks. There, teams of actors, lists of prior works, and sets of labels jointly drive output. Existing multi-part methods, they note, fail to scale to current dataset sizes while testing rival ideas about output drivers. Applying relational hyperevent models to dynamic three-part hypergraphs, they model events linking any number of actors, cited works, and keywords. They test and adjust for links within and between each set.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Amin Gino Fabbrucci Barbagli, Jürgen Lerner, Viviana Amati, Domenico De Stefano |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43562 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.10808
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Modeling Tripartite Hyperevents in Scientific Collaboration Networks Amin Gino Fabbrucci Barbagli, Jürgen Lerner, Viviana Amati, Domenico De Stefano Abstract Sociological research has framed collective action in science, innovation, and culture as tripartite networks connecting teams of actors, lists of prior works, and sets of labels (e.g., keywords, topics). While methods for multipartite social networks were proposed decades ago, and have received a recent surge in interest, none of the suggested solutions scale to the size and granularity of contemporary data sets (scientific publications, patents, filmmaking) and at the same time allow for testing multiple competing hypotheses about the drivers of collective production. In this paper, we address this gap by applying Relational Hyperevent Models (RHEM) to dynamic tripartite hypergraphs. Using scientific networks as a case study, we model events linking any number of actors, references, and keywords, testing and controlling for inter-dependencies within and between each set. keywords collective production, hypergraphs, tripartite hyperevent, relational hyperevent models, scientific collaboration network 1 Introduction Scientific knowledge and production arise from interactions among researchers, between prior knowledge and innovation, and between context and specific domain ( 29 ; 18 ) . A scientific outcome is the result of collaboration among researchers who generate content that builds on prior knowledge, which identifies the topic and contribution of their work using keywords. One way to represent and describe the emergence of scientific knowledge is to use concepts and tools from network analysis ( 50 ; 4 ) . Over the past decades, it has been used to analyze interactions among different types of entities in the domain of science and innovation (for a review, see 25 and 3 , and the reference therein). Its application has been boosted over the last twenty years by the increasing availability of metadata on scientific publications and discoveries. Network analysis has been applied to scientific collaboration networks to explain how entities such as researchers and institutions interact to produce content. Much of the work on scientific collaboration networks focuses on formal interactions (tangible signs of interactions which are considered proxies for collaboration) such as co-authorship or joint collaboration in research projects. In this scenario, co-authorship networks (nodes are researchers and a link between two actors exists if they have co-authored at least one paper) have been analyzed to describe the network structure among scholars ( 37 ; 1 ; 10 ) , to reveal the presence of teams or communities ( 20 ; 9 ; 19 ) and to determine the mechanisms explaining the formation of the collaboration and its evolution over time in different domains ( 38 ; 16 ; 12 ; 14 ) . Co-authorship networks or other types of formal interactions among researchers are not the only ways to explore scientific production and its evolution. Another application of network analysis in the scientific production domain concerns citation networks where nodes are scientific publications and relationships are references to other publications ( 43 ; 44 ; 17 ) . The analysis of these networks investigates how knowledge evolves over time by building on prior work and identifies key publications, innovations and discoveries. Finally, in scientific collaboration and production, network analysis has also been adopted to identify emerging topics from the labels (e.g., tokens extracted from titles or abstracts through appropriate textual data processing) or keywords researchers use to characterize their works ( 36 ; 46 ) . In this context, nodes may be represented by keywords and their relationships are determined by their co-occurrence in the same publication or in different publications. Collective scientific production, therefore, can be explored in terms of co-authorship, citation, or keywords co-occurrence networks. These structures are usually represented as one-mode networks characterized by a single set of nodes of the same type and the relationships among them. 1.1 From one mode network to hypergraph The analysis of one-mode networks in this context faces two important limitations: the first concerns the level of analysis. By examining pairs of researchers, references and keywords, standard approaches overlook the the inherently multicast nature of such interactions and the fact that the observed ties may be originated from just one scientific product instead of implying more complex interactions, such transitivity or closure (e.g., in a co-authorship network a couple of authors whose connections depend on the fact that they shared a third common author in a past publication). For instance, a scientific product generated by researchers (e.g., A, B and C), necessarily determine links between each all dyads (AB, AC, BC), however this cannot be considered as a transitive triad ( 26 ) . A similar issue affects ties if we consider networks of cited papers and keywords co-occurrence. To address these issues, some scholars may use bipartite networks (networks in which there are two distinct sets of nodes and only relationships from one set to another are allowed) with links between researchers, keywords, references and scientific products. However, the application of bipartite networks is only a convenient representation because subsequent analyses are usually performed by projecting the two-mode networks onto one-mode networks ( 41 ) , as testified not only in networks emerging from scientific publications but also by the collaboration in patents ( 8 ) , in funded research project interactions ( 40 ) or networks in cultural productions such as movies industry ( 7 ) . This approach further extends to multi-mode networks where three or more distinct types of entities and their interactions are considered, even though the projection inherently entails information loss and precludes the examination of competing relational mechanisms simultaneously ( 13 ) . The second limitation lies in the fact that the co-authorship network, the citation network, and the keyword network are typically analyzed separately, thus neglecting their interdependencies. Researchers become recognizable through their use of keywords and citation patterns; keywords take their meaning from the documents and scholars related to them, and publications gain importance from their conceptual framing and social embeddedness. Folksonomy ( 22 ) exemplifies such interdependence: the users’ activity and tagging behavior lead to a tripartite structure of actors, descriptors, and artefacts ( 28 ; 49 ; 22 ) . This conceptualization fits into the broader framework of Breiger’s theory of duality ( 6 ) and its generalization ( 30 ) illustrating how actors and collectives mutually constitute one another – e.g., individuals are defined by groups they belong to, and groups are defined by their members. The disjoint analysis provides only a partial view and misses the inherent interdependencies that characterize scientific knowledge production. Given these issues, the analysis of the dynamics of collective scientific production based on longitudinal observations of one-mode networks remains limited, as one-mode networks cannot properly capture the evolution of co-authorship, citations, and keywords co-occurrence. To overcome these issues, researchers have recently used hypergraphs, which are networks connecting multiple entities of the same type and where every connection in the subset of nodes constitutes a hyperedge. Recently, 27 analyzed co-authorship networks to describe general features of “real-world” hypergraphs. 34 , 31 , 14 and 5 used Relational Hypervent Models (RHEM) to investigate the determinants of co-authorship dynamics. 12 and 33 recently extended this work to the joint analysis of co-authorship and citations. 47 investigated interactions among different types of entities (authors, chemicals,