Direct Lagrangian tracking simulation of droplet growth in vertically-developing turbulent cloud
2026
Read Direct Lagrangian tracking simulation of droplet growth in vertically-developing turbulent cloud (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-10564.txt.
Introduction
Iwashima and Onishi track rain drops through a tall simulated cloud column. Their model pairs direct flow simulation with particle tracking from ground to cloud top. It covers activation, condensation growth, collision merging, and settling in warm clouds. Runs with and without wind gusts show gusts spur merging of like sized drops mid cloud. Later, big drops sweep up small ones lower down, and ground rain starts sooner and larger.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35389 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.10564
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Direct Lagrangian tracking simulation of droplet growth in vertically-developing turbulent cloud Abstract We developed a new explicit cloud microphysical model, based on direct numerical simulation (DNS) with Lagrangian particle tracking. The model employs a vertically-elongated quasi-1D computational domain extending from the ground to the cloud top to explicitly capture the vertical structure of clouds. This allows us to simulate the all warm-cloud microphysical processes, including activation, condensation growth, collision-coalescence growth, and sedimentation. A homogeneous isotropic turbulence field is incorporated into this domain to explicitly resolve the turbulent wind fluctuations. Cloud microphysics simulations with and without turbulent wind fluctuations were performed to clarify the impact of turbulence on droplet growth. We obtained new insights into the altitude- and time-dependent microphysical statistics, which cannot be obtained through conventional DNS researches for a cubic box domain with periodic boundaries. The comparison have shown that turbulence promoted the collision-coalescence growth of droplets. During the early developing stage, where the updraft was present, turbulence promoted the collisions between droplets with similar sizes (autoconversions) in the middle layer of the cloud. In later stage, relatively large droplets produced by autoconversions actively collected smaller droplets (accretions) in the middle and lower layers. The onset of precipitation at the ground occurred earlier and the first raindrop at the ground was larger in turbulence case than that in non-turbulence case. \Author [1][[email protected]]MasayaIwashima \Author [2][[email protected]]RyoOnishi 1]Engineering School, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Science Tokyo 2]Supercomputing Research Center, Institute of Integrated Research, Institute of Science Tokyo \pubdiscuss \published † † firstpage: 1 \introduction In numerical simulations for atmospheric science, cloud modeling that represents cloud microphysics has been one of the central topics of discussion for more than a half century ( Grabowski et al. 2019 ) . Cloud modeling has generally adopted the Euler method, which treats grid-average quantities (e.g. mass or/and number of liquid water) as continuous fields. The Euler method is generally classified into bulk method and spectral (bin) method. In the bulk method, for several hydrometeors such as cloud water and rainwater, mass (or/and number) is/are used as prognostic variable(s) to calculate growth and advection ( Kessler 1969 ; Wisner et al. 1972 ; Lin et al. 1983 ) . On the other hand, in the bin method, the size distributions of hydrometeors are discretized into several bins. The mass (and/or number) of hydrometeors in each bin are prognostic variables ( Berry 1967 ; Li et al. 2009 ; Onishi and Takahashi 2012 ) . With the recent increase in computational power, Lagrangian methods have also been developed ( Liu et al. 2023 ) . Shima et al. 2009 proposed a super-droplet method (SDM) combined with large-eddy simulation (LES). SDM is a Lagrangian particle tracking-based cloud modeling, in which each computational particle called super-droplet represents multiple real precipitation particles with the same properties. In this method, the advection of hydrometeors is calculated as the motion of super-droplets. The collision-coalescence growth is calculated by a stochastic scheme ( Shima et al. 2009 ; Shima et al. 2020 ) . In parallel, direct tracking method combined with direct numerical simulation (DNS) has also been developed ( Onishi et al. 2015 ; Saito and Gotoh 2018 ; Chen et al. 2018 ) . In this approach, the motion and growth of individual precipitation particles are explicitly calculated. Compared to SDM, direct tracking methods reduce stochastic treatments and can more accurately represent collision-coalescence growth. In addition, as DNS resolves the smallest scales of turbulence, direct tracking methods enable a more explicit representation of turbulence-particle interactions than SDM and Euler approaches. The influence of turbulence on cloud microphysics is known to be significant and has been a subject of active discussion for decades ( Vaillancourt and Yau 2000 ; Shaw 2003 ; Grabowski and Wang 2013 ) . Saffman and Turner 1956 proposed that, during the early stage of cloud formation, turbulence can promote collision-coalescence among small droplets, leading to the formation of larger droplets. In their study, the influence of turbulence on the growth of precipitation particles was formulated for the first time. Since the 1990s, advances in computational power have enabled the use of computationally expensive numerical approaches. In fluid engineering, the influence of turbulence on particle motion has been investigated numerically using direct numerical simulation (DNS) of turbulence combined with particle tracking calculations ( Squires and Eaton 1990 ; Wang and Maxey 1993 ; Sundaram and Collins 1997 ; Reade and Collins 2000 ) . Following this development, similar approaches were introduced in cloud microphysics, where DNS coupled with particle tracking has been used to examine the effects of turbulence on cloud microphysical processes ( Vaillancourt et al. 2001 ; Franklin et al. 2005 ; Woittiez et al. 2009 ) . Through these DNS-based studies, a theoretical framework for particle collisions that incorporates the effects of turbulence has been established. Wang et al. 1998 proposed the collision kernel K^{c}_{1,2} between particles 1 and 2 expressed as K^{c}_{1,2}=2\pi R_{1,2}^{2}\left\langle\left|w_{r1,2}(r=R_{1,2})\right|\right\rangle g_{1,2}(r=R_{1,2}), (1) where R_{1,2} is the sum of the particle radii (collision radius), \left\langle\left|w_{r1,2}(r=R_{1,2})\right|\right\rangle is the mean radial relative velocity (RRV) at contact, and g_{1,2}(r=R_{1,2}) is the radial distribution function (RDF) at contact. This formulation describes two primary mechanisms by which turbulence enhances particle collisions: one is the increase in the RRV due to turbulent shear. The other is the preferential concentration of inertial particles, which leads to the increase in RDF at contact. Subsequent studies in cloud microphysics have further advanced DNS with particle tracking through the incorporation of more detailed microphysical processes. For example, Michel et al. 2023 and Ababaei et al. 2024 developed DNS that account for particle-particle interactions, such as flow disturbances induced by particle motion and lubrication forces. In addition, Onishi et al. 2015 , Saito and Gotoh 2018 , and Chen et al. 2018 developed models that incorporate collision-coalescence processes, enabling the direct simulation of precipitation particle growth in turbulent flows. This method is particularly valuable for investigating how turbulence affects collision-coalescence growth of droplets, and ultimately precipitation formation. However, due to their high computational cost, the use of the method has been restricted to fundamental research on cloud microphysics and turbulence. Most of the previous studies adopted cubic domains with periodic boundaries ( Onishi et al. 2015 ; Saito and Gotoh 2018 ; Chen et al. 2018 ) . Although the periodic box domain is numerically convenient, it is not physically realistic: real atmospheric clouds have vertical structure in terms of, for example, supersaturation ratio or droplet size distribution. However, the periodic box domain cannot represent such vertical structures of the clouds. To overcome this limitation, Kunishima and Onishi 2018 introduced a vertically-elongated quasi-1D computational domain, which covers from the ground to the cloud top, to a direct tracking method. In addition, a model for cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation was implemented to the method. From these extensions, the all warm-cloud microphysical processes (CCN activation, condensation/evaporation growth, collision-coalescence growth, and sedimentation) could be treated by the direct tracking method. However, they did not incorporate turbulence into their computation. Thus, the purpose of the present study is to extend the framework proposed in Kunishima and Onishi 2018 and incorporate turbulence. We aim to investigate how turbulence influences the warm-cloud microphysics using a vertically elongated quasi-one-dimensional