Enhanced Self-Learning with Epistemologically-Informed LLM Dialogue CCS: Human-centered computing Interactive systems and tools CCS: Applied computing Education

Yi-Fan Cao, Kento Shigyo, Yitong Gu, Xiyuan Wang, Weijia Liu, Yang Wang, David Gotz, Zhilan Zhou, Huamin Qu · 2026

Read Enhanced Self-Learning with Epistemologically-Informed LLM Dialogue CCS: Human-centered computing Interactive systems and tools CCS: Applied computing Education by Yi-Fan Cao, Kento Shigyo, Yitong Gu, Xiyuan Wang, Weijia Liu, Yang Wang, David Gotz, Zhilan Zhou, Huamin Qu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-10545.txt.

Introduction

Cao and eight colleagues shape self study chats with old ideas about knowledge. Learners often stall in deep talks and drown in tangled facts. Their CausaDisco tool weaves Aristotle's four causes into prompts that spawn apt follow ups. A first study of 26 learners mapped how knowledge views steer chat habits. A trial with 36 learners then found livelier talks, deeper probes, and wider angles than baseline chats.

Catalog record

CREATORYi-Fan Cao, Kento Shigyo, Yitong Gu, Xiyuan Wang, Weijia Liu, Yang Wang, David Gotz, Zhilan Zhou, Huamin Qu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE101274
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.10545

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Enhanced Self-Learning with Epistemologically-Informed LLM Dialogue CCS: Human-centered computing Interactive systems and tools CCS: Applied computing Education Yi-Fan Cao, Kento Shigyo, Yitong Gu, Xiyuan Wang, Weijia Liu, Yang Wang, David Gotz, Zhilan Zhou, Huamin Qu Abstract . Large Language Models (LLMs) have advanced self-learning tools, enabling more personalized interactions. However, learners struggle to engage in meaningful dialogue and process complex information. To alleviate this, we incorporate epistemological frameworks within an LLM-based approach to self-learning, reducing the cognitive load on learners and fostering deeper engagement and holistic understanding. Through a formative study (N=26), we identified epistemological differences in self-learner interaction patterns. Building upon these findings, we present CausaDisco , a dialogue-based interactive system that integrates Aristotle’s Four Causes framework into LLM prompts to enhance cognitive support for self-learning. This approach guides learners’ self-learning journeys by automatically generating coherent and contextually appropriate follow-up questions. A controlled study (N=36) demonstrated that, compared to baseline, CausaDisco fostered more engaging interactions, inspired sophisticated exploration, and facilitated multifaceted perspectives. This research contributes to HCI by expanding the understanding of LLMs as educational agents and providing design implications for this emerging class of tools. Figure 1. CausaDisco provides users with original learning materials (A) and a core concept graph (B) to facilitate self-learning. Once a user initiates a dialogue, the LLM chatbot offers preliminary answers and then automatically generates four epistemologically-informed follow-up questions (C) to encourage deeper exploration. Concurrently, CausaDisco creates a query tree map (D) to assist users in managing their conversation records. When users are satisfied with the results of multi-turn dialogues (T1-3), they can proceed to explore and learn about new topics. This figure presents the interface and interaction design of CausaDisco, which enhances self-learning by providing original materials and a core concept graph for guidance. When users start a dialogue, the LLM chatbot offers initial answers and generates four follow-up questions to promote deeper understanding. Simultaneously, a query tree map is created to help users manage conversation records. Once users are satisfied with multi-turn dialogues, they can explore new topics. 1. Introduction The rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has revolutionized education, introducing a new generation of dialogue-driven learning tools ( 72 ; 19 ; 112 ) . These tools have greatly improved the efficiency of independent learning, supporting a wide range of tasks, from spoken language practice ( 53 ) and text editing ( 57 ) to literature searches ( 113 ; 114 ) and information summarization ( 82 ) . With the adoption of prompt engineering techniques, the potential of LLM-based educational tools to facilitate deeper learning and knowledge construction has been further explored ( 100 ) . These dialogue-driven tools can help streamline the cognitive processes involved in sensemaking, enabling learners to acquire, comprehend, integrate, and apply new knowledge more effectively ( 1 ; 39 ) . Although LLM-based educational tools promote a flexible and intuitive “search-as-learning” sensemaking process ( 69 ) , many still require substantial effort from learners to engage in meaningful dialogue and process complex information. This is particularly challenging when using less customized LLM tools, as learners often spend considerable time crafting precise questions to elicit responses aligned with their specific needs. Such exploratory and iterative dialogue-driven interactions can be especially demanding for less proactive learners accustomed to more passive input-driven sensemaking. Consequently, even with LLM-based tools, many learners still encounter substantial, yet often hidden, cognitive load. Extensive studies have focused on enhancing the contextuality ( 2 ; 95 ; 18 ) and workflow ( 100 ; 38 ; 93 ) of LLM-based educational tools to support learners’ sensemaking processes. However, existing work often centers on domain-specific applications ( 94 ; 20 ) or caters to early adopters already proficient in strategically engaging with LLM chatbots ( 114 ) . This focus overlooks a fundamental aspect of human-AI interaction: sensemaking is a highly individualized cognitive process. This process is shaped by one’s epistemological schema , which represents structured beliefs about the nature , source , and justification of knowledge ( 50 ; 11 ; 7 ; 5 ) . Consequently, a critical gap exists in understanding how diverse mental models, reflected in different LLM interaction behaviors influence the design of effective, usable, and inclusive educational tools. To bridge this knowledge gap, we conducted a formative study with 26 participants. Data collection was triangulated ( 13 ) through dialogue records captured by a probe system, online surveys, and semi-structured interviews 1 1 1 Please refer to the supplementary materials for details of our survey and semi-structured interview protocols. . Through a thematic analysis of the collected data, we derived a query taxonomy that revealed distinct interaction behaviors, while also examining participants’ underlying epistemological schemas. The synthesis of these analyses identified four interaction patterns : proactive , validation-seeking , content-focused , and receptive . We revealed key differences by analyzing these patterns within the epistemological framework of knowledge nature, source, and justification, particularly between proactive and receptive patterns. The proactive pattern was characterized by active knowledge construction, evidenced by participants formulating effective questions, requesting elaborations, and synthesizing information. Conversely, the receptive pattern was characterized by fewer questions, less exploration, and a preference for receiving direct answers from LLMs rather than actively building understanding. Furthermore, the proactive pattern was associated with high-performing participants, while the receptive pattern was often observed in those who struggled in the learning process. The observed epistemological differences and learning outcomes across different patterns highlight the need for tools to accommodate diverse learner needs. We identified three primary challenges in designing inclusive learner-LLM interactions : limited interactivity , inefficient information verification , and confirmation bias . Addressing these challenges requires educational tools that support: (1) lower cognitive load, (2) sustained engagement, (3) multidimensional thinking, (4) metacognition, and (5) validation assistance. Guided by these requirements, we developed CausaDisco , a proof-of-concept system designed to support more effective learner-LLM interactions. CausaDisco comprises four main views (see Fig. 1 ): an Embedded Content View providing access to original learning materials; a Concept Graph visualizing relationships between core concepts; a Q&A Conversation View prompting epistemologically-informed follow-up questions; and a Tree Map View displaying the underlying query logic. Specifically, in the Q&A Conversation View , we incorporate epistemological frameworks with LLM prompt engineering to enhance self-learners sensemaking. This approach is inspired by pedagogical research demonstrating the benefits of structured, epistemologically-informed frameworks for critical thinking, analytical depth, and knowledge acquisition in self-learning contexts ( 80 ; 7 ; 59 ) . Drawing on these insights, as well as the interaction patterns distilled from our formative study, we identified the need for a systematic approach to generating follow-up questions that support comprehensive sensemaking. We selected Aristotle’s Four Causes ( 49 ; 32 ) –a classical epistemological framework for knowledge construction–due to its remarkable alignment with our empirically derived query taxonomy. This framework prompts users to consider the Material , Formal , Efficient , and Final causes of concepts, effectively mapping to the diverse types of questions learners naturally ask. To evaluate the efficacy of CausaDisco , we conducted a controlled user study with 36 participants employing a between-subjects design. We assessed both objective and subjective measures, including quiz scores and Likert-scale ratings to assess engagement, efficiency, comprehensiveness, sophistication, and usability of the

Read the complete text