AI Patents in the United States and China: Measurement, Organization, and Knowledge Flows

2026

Read AI Patents in the United States and China: Measurement, Organization, and Knowledge Flows (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-10529.txt.

Introduction

Fang, Gu, Yan, and Zhu measure AI patents in the United States and China with a sharp new sorter. Their tuned PatentSBERTa classifier beats the USPTO method at about 97 percent precision and 91 percent recall. Applied to US grants from 1976 to 2023 and Chinese grants from 2010 to 2023, it shows fast growth on both sides. US filings cluster in big firms and known hubs, while Chinese filings spread wider across places and players. AI patents lift listed firm values in both lands, and cross border cites show ties still bind.

Catalog record

YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE100505
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.10529

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI Patents in the United States and China: Measurement, Organization, and Knowledge Flows Thanks: We are grateful to Lee Fleming, Kang Shi, and Xiaoyan Zhang for insightful comments and suggestions. We also appreciate the comments from the participants at seminars of PBC School of Finance at Tsinghua University, HKUST(Guangzhou), Birmingham University and the Conference on “Frontiers in Machine Learning and Economics: Methods and Applications” (Chicago Booth, 2025) and SFS Cavalcade Asia-Pacific Conference (2025). Zhu acknowledges the financial support from Minoru Kobayashi China Economic Research Fund, and the National Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 72273071). All remaining errors are our own. Department of Economics, University of Pennsylvania & the NBER, USA. Email: [email protected] Department of Finance, Durham University, UK. Email: [email protected] School of Economics and Management, Tsinghua University, China. Email: [email protected] School of Economics and Management, Tsinghua University, China. Email: [email protected] Abstract We develop a high-precision classifier to measure artificial intelligence (AI) patents by fine-tuning PatentSBERTa on manually labeled data from the USPTO’s AI Patent Dataset. Our classifier substantially improves the existing USPTO approach, achieving 97.0% precision, 91.3% recall, and a 94.0% F1 score, and it generalizes well to Chinese patents based on citation and lexical validation. Applying it to granted U.S. patents (1976–2023) and Chinese patents (2010–2023), we document rapid growth in AI patenting in both countries and broad convergence in AI patenting intensity and subfield composition, even as China surpasses the United States in recent annual patent counts. The organization of AI innovation nevertheless differs sharply: U.S. AI patenting is concentrated among large private incumbents and established hubs, whereas Chinese AI patenting is more geographically diffuse and institutionally diverse, with larger roles for universities and state-owned enterprises. For listed firms, AI patents command a robust market-value premium in both countries. Cross-border citations show continued technological interdependence rather than decoupling, with Chinese AI inventors relying more heavily on U.S. frontier knowledge than vice versa. JEL Classifications : O31, O33, O34, O57, C55, G14. Keywords : Artificial Intelligence; Innovation; AI Patents; Institutional Structure; United States and China. 1 Introduction Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become a focal point of global technological competition, with the United States (US) and China emerging as the two dominant players. The past two decades have seen an exponential growth in AI patenting, with these two countries accounting for a majority of the global filings of AI patents. While the US continues to lead early innovation in the development of frontier AI research and infrastructure, China has rapidly caught up and increased its AI patent output, particularly in applied domains such as computer vision and smart manufacturing. 1 1 1 The emergence of the Chinese AI startup DeepSeek in December 2024 exemplifies this trend. These patterns suggest both convergence and divergence in the geography of AI innovation: convergence in the overall volume and intensity of R&D, and divergence in the technological specialization and institutional foundations. Assessing the dynamics of this rivalry—whether it is characterized by convergence or divergence—is critical to understanding the future geography of innovation and productivity growth. However, empirical analysis of this competition is currently limited by a fundamental identification problem: we lack a reliable “ruler” to measure AI innovation accurately at scale. To evaluate global competition in AI innovation, a critical first step is to accurately identify AI-related patents. The US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) released the Artificial Intelligence Patent Dataset (AIPD) in 2023 for the US ( 14 ; 23 ) , which employs a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) model to classify AI patents. In this paper, we demonstrate that the current standard for identifying AI patents—the USPTO’s AIPD—suffers from significant measurement error in the labeled training dataset. We show that the AIPD’s classifier yields a precision of 40.5% and a recall of 37.5%. This implies that nearly 63% of true AI patents are missed, and close to 60% of the patents flagged as ‘‘AI’’ patents are true AI patents. 2 2 2 Precision , or Positive Predictive Value, summarizes the fraction of true positives (TP) among all predicted positives (TP + FP), i.e., \textsl{Precision}=\textsl{TP}/(\textsl{TP}+\textsl{FP}) , where FP represents “False Positives.” Recall , or Sensitivity, or True Positive Rate, summarizes the fraction of truly positives that are identified as positives, i.e., \textsl{Recall}=\textsl{TP}/(\textsl{TP}+\textsl{FN}) , where FN represents true positives that are falsely classified as negatives. Accuracy summarizes the fraction of cases that are correctly classified, i.e., \textsl{Accuracy}=\textsl{(TP+TN)}/\textsl{(TP+TN+FP+FN)}. The F1 Score is the harmonic mean of Precision and Accuracy, namely, \textsl{F1 Score}=2\times\textsl{Precision}\times\textsl{Recall}/(\textsl{Precision}+\textsl{Recall}) . While 23 update the dataset, they do not report the performance metrics of the test set. Such noise introduces substantial attenuation bias into any economic analysis of firm-level innovation or aggregate productivity. Our first contribution is methodological. We propose a new classifier of AI patents, which we call the FGYZ classifier, via applying modern natural language processing (NLP) techniques and fine-tune a suite of large language models (LLMs) to construct a novel, high-resolution dataset of AI patents. Specifically, we fine-tune PatentSBERTa , a transformer-based language model pre-trained on patent texts, using the manually labeled AIPD seed and antiseed data from 14 and 23 . 3 3 3 PatentSBERTa was originally developed by 4 . Further details about the model are provided in Online Appendix A.1 . PatentSBERTa captures rich semantic and contextual features specific to the patent domain and has been shown to outperform traditional embedding methods in classification tasks. We apply the fine-tuned classifier to the universe of patents granted by the USPTO and China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA), assigning each patent to one or more of the eight AI subfields: Machine Learning , Natural Language Processing (NLP) , Speech , Vision , Planning , Knowledge Processing , Hardware , and Evolutionary Computation . Using our classifier, we are able to identify 876,668 unique AI patents over the period of 1976-2023 in the US and 651,630 AI patents for the period of 2010-2023 in China, matched to a total of nearly 400,000 unique individual inventors. In the AIPD seed and anti-seed data, our fine-tuned model achieves strong classification performance in seven of the eight AI subfields, with an average accuracy of 97%, recall of 91.3%, precision of 97.0% and F1 score of 94.0%. The only exception is the subfield of Evolutionary Computation , due to limited training examples. We therefore exclude this subcategory from our subsequent empirical analyses. In general, our classifier significantly outperforms the LSTM-based model adopted by the USPTO. We first validate our AI patent classification using citation-based connectivity measures that capture technological relatedness across patent groups. Specifically, we partition patents based on the joint outcomes of two classification systems: the USPTO’s Artificial Intelligence Patent Dataset (AIPD) and our classifier (FGYZ). Patents classified as AI by both classifiers form a high-confidence positive set. We show that patents identified as AI only by FGYZ show systematically stronger citation connectivity to this benchmark set, and significantly weaker connectivity to patents classified as non-AI by both classifiers. This pattern holds across AI subfields and is particularly pronounced in core domains such as machine learning, natural language processing, and planning. In contrast, patents classified as AI only by the USPTO show weaker links to the AI benchmark and stronger connections to non-AI technologies. These results indicate that patents captured by our

Read the complete text