Which Phases Are Thermodynamically Realizable? A Local Entropy Criterion
C. Evans Hedges · 2026
Read Which Phases Are Thermodynamically Realizable? A Local Entropy Criterion by C. Evans Hedges (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-10225.txt.
Introduction
Hedges asks when a prescribed ergodic measure is the unique equilibrium state of a continuous potential. For actions of infinite discrete amenable groups on compact spaces, a local entropy condition characterizes the property. The measure is uniquely attainable when this entropy function is weak-star upper semicontinuous at the zero measure. Entropy semicontinuity at the measure alone does not suffice. He builds a shift space with entropy upper semicontinuous at every ergodic measure, yet continuous at a fixed-point measure that is no equilibrium state of any potential.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | C. Evans Hedges |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36106 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.10225
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Which Phases Are Thermodynamically Realizable? A Local Entropy Criterion C. Evans Hedges Abstract . In the variational approach to statistical mechanics, equilibrium states are the rigorous analogues of thermodynamic phases; the question of which invariant measures can arise as equilibrium states is therefore the question of which phases are thermodynamically realizable. We prove that for continuous actions of locally compact amenable groups on compact metrizable spaces with finite topological entropy, an ergodic measure μ \mu is an equilibrium state for some continuous potential if and only if the entropy map h h is upper semicontinuous at μ \mu ; equivalently, the unrealizable phases are exactly those hidden behind the convex envelope of the free energy. More generally, the same criterion applies whenever ( X , T ) (X,T) has bounded entropy and embeds as an invariant subsystem of a compact metrizable system. As a canonical case, one-point compactification yields a C 0 C_{0} -potential realization theorem for locally compact σ \sigma -compact systems, with applications to countable-state Markov shifts. We also show that the equilibrium-face realization stated by Jenkinson (2006) omits a necessary continuity hypothesis, exhibiting a counterexample on the full shift, and give the sharp corrected statement: a weak- ∗ * closed set ℰ \mathcal{E} of ergodic measures determines an equilibrium face if and only if h | ℰ h|_{\mathcal{E}} is continuous and h h is upper semicontinuous at each point of ℰ \mathcal{E} . 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 37D35, 37A35, 37B10, 82B20, 46A55 1. Introduction In the variational formulation of thermodynamic formalism, equilibrium states play the role of thermodynamic phases: they are the invariant measures that maximize the pressure h(\mu)+\int\phi\,d\mu (equivalently minimize the free energy) for a given potential (interaction) \phi . A basic question is which phases are thermodynamically realizable, i.e., which invariant measures arise as equilibrium states for some continuous potential. This paper gives a complete answer: an ergodic measure \mu is attainable as an equilibrium state if and only if the entropy map h is upper semicontinuous at \mu . The obstruction to realizability is thus a local regularity condition on the entropy landscape near the phase in question. This result extends to weak- * closed sets of ergodic measures \mathcal{E} with the additional hypothesis that h is continuous when restricted to \mathcal{E} . More generally, the criterion applies whenever (X,T) embeds as an invariant subsystem of a compact metrizable system with bounded entropy; one-point compactification then yields a C_{0} -potential realization theorem for locally compact \sigma -compact systems, with applications to countable-state Markov shifts. The equilibrium-state realization problem sits between classical thermodynamic formalism and ergodic optimization. In lattice statistical mechanics, the Gibbs/equilibrium correspondence goes back to Dobrushin [ 2 ] and Lanford–Ruelle [ 12 ] ; in uniformly hyperbolic dynamics, the corresponding framework was developed by Sinai [ 17 ] , Bowen [ 1 ] , Ruelle [ 16 ] , and Walters [ 18 ] . Israel [ 9 ] recast the theory in a convex-analytic framework developed specifically for lattice gas models, and the Israel–Phelps [ 8 ] study of the subdifferential of the pressure was motivated by the geometry of phase diagrams. In the Choquet-theoretic setting, Phelps [ 15 ] proved that when the entropy function on the simplex of invariant measures is affine and upper semicontinuous, every ergodic measure is the unique equilibrium state of some continuous potential. On the ergodic-optimization side, Jenkinson [ 11 ] proved that every ergodic measure is uniquely maximizing and stated that, under global upper semicontinuity, weak- * closed ergodic sets generate equilibrium faces (see also [ 10 ] ). The main compact result of the present paper is a local sharpening of the Israel–Phelps framework, replacing global upper semicontinuity of the entropy map by upper semicontinuity at the chosen ergodic measure. Specifically, let G be a locally compact amenable group acting on a compact metric space X via homeomorphisms \{T_{g}\}_{g\in G} . Let M_{T}(X) be the collection of T -invariant probability measures on X and let C(X) be the collection of all real-valued potentials on X . We say that \mu\in M_{T}(X) is an equilibrium state for \phi\in C(X) if h(\mu)+\int\phi d\mu=P(\phi) where h is the Kolmogorov-Sinai entropy map and P is the pressure function, which via the variational principle can be shown to satisfy P(\phi)=\sup\{h(\nu)+\int\phi d\nu:\nu\in M_{T}(X)\} . Throughout, upper semicontinuity of h refers to the weak- * topology on M_{T}(X) . We can now state our primary theorem: Theorem 1 . If \mu\in M_{T}^{erg}(X) and h is upper semicontinuous at \mu , then there exists \phi\in C(X) such that \mu is the unique equilibrium state for \phi . Since the converse is immediate, we obtain: Corollary 2 . For an ergodic \mu\in M_{T}^{erg}(X) , the following are equivalent: (1) h is upper semicontinuous at \mu . (2) \mu is an equilibrium state for some \phi\in C(X) . (3) \mu is the unique equilibrium state for some \phi\in C(X) . We note here that by combining Corollary 2 with [ 5 ] , we see that \mu is a freezing state for some potential if and only if h is upper semicontinuous at \mu . Corollary 3.2 provides an equivalent formulation via the pointwise dual formula: for ergodic \mu , h is upper semicontinuous at \mu if and only if h(\mu)=\min_{\phi\in C(X)}\left(P(\phi)-\int\phi\,d\mu\right). This dual formula admits a convex-analytic interpretation in the spirit of Israel [ 9 ] and Israel–Phelps [ 8 ] . Setting \Phi(\mu)=-h(\mu) , the pressure P=\Phi^{*} is the Legendre-Fenchel conjugate, and the biconjugate \Phi^{**}(\mu)=\sup_{\phi}(\hat{\phi}(\mu)-P(\phi))=-\inf_{\phi}(P(\phi)-\hat{\phi}(\mu)) recovers the continuous-affine majorant envelope of h at \mu . The dual formula is then a pointwise Fenchel-Moreau theorem: \Phi^{**}(\mu)=\Phi(\mu) if and only if \Phi is lower semicontinuous at \mu . In the language of classical thermodynamics, the passage from \Phi to \Phi^{**} is the Maxwell construction (see [ 9 ] ): the biconjugate replaces a non-convex free energy with its convex envelope, and phases where \Phi^{**}(\mu)<\Phi(\mu) are thermodynamically inaccessible. Our main result thus characterizes the realizable pure phases as exactly those not hidden behind the Maxwell construction: an ergodic measure is an equilibrium state for some interaction if and only if it lies on the convex envelope of the free energy landscape. The singleton result extends to the equilibrium-face realization problem. In [ 11 ] , Jenkinson stated (Theorems 5 and 6) that under global upper semicontinuity of entropy, every weak- * closed set of ergodic measures determines an equilibrium face. We show that this formulation omits a necessary continuity hypothesis (Example 3.4 ), and give the corrected statement: Theorem 3 . Let \mathcal{E}\subset M_{T}^{erg}(X) be nonempty and weak- * closed. If h|_{\mathcal{E}} is weak- * continuous and h is upper semicontinuous at every \mu\in\mathcal{E} , then there exists \phi\in C(X) such that the set of equilibrium states for \phi is exactly \overline{\operatorname{co}}(\mathcal{E}) . The continuity hypothesis on h|_{\mathcal{E}} is sharp: if F=\operatorname{Eq}(\phi) for any \phi\in C(X) , then h|_{F} is automatically continuous affine (Proposition 3.3 ). In physical terms, the face realization problem asks which families of pure thermodynamic phases can coexist at equilibrium for a single interaction; our corrected theorem shows that coexistence requires both a local entropy regularity condition at each phase and continuity of entropy across the coexisting phases. These results