What Happens When Institutional Liquidity Enters Prediction Markets: Identification, Measurement, and a Synthetic Proof of Concept

Shaw Dalen · 2026

Read What Happens When Institutional Liquidity Enters Prediction Markets: Identification, Measurement, and a Synthetic Proof of Concept by Shaw Dalen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-10005.txt.

Introduction

Dalen designs a study for institutional liquidity entering prediction markets, now resembling electronic markets. The paper defines a market-quality lens, separates the main entry channels, and maps identification problems. A synthetic laboratory serves as proof of concept for the measurement pipeline. Its narrow lesson: coverage, incentives, and automation need not share one channel. Average gains need not reach all traders equally. The sharpest losses likely hit shock states, when slow takers receive the least pass-through. The synthetic results stress-test the design without settling the live question.

Catalog record

CREATORShaw Dalen
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36603
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.10005

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

What Happens When Institutional Liquidity Enters Prediction Markets: Identification, Measurement, and a Synthetic Proof of Concept https://x.com/DaedalusRsch Shaw Dalen Abstract Prediction markets are starting to look less like crowd polls and more like electronic markets. The central question is therefore no longer only whether these markets forecast well, but what happens when institutional liquidity enters: do spreads tighten, does price discovery improve, and do those gains actually reach the traders who are slowest to react when information arrives? This paper offers a research design for answering that question. It defines a broad market-quality lens, separates the main channels through which institutional liquidity enters, and maps the identification problems that arise in live venue data. It also uses a synthetic microstructure laboratory as a proof of concept for the measurement pipeline. The main lesson of the synthetic exercise is deliberately narrow. Market-maker coverage, liquidity incentives, and automation do not have to work through the same channel; average liquidity gains do not have to translate into equal gains for all traders; and the sharpest welfare losses are most likely to appear in shock states, when slower takers receive the least pass-through of tighter quoted markets. The synthetic results are useful because they stress-test the design, not because they settle the live empirical question. 1 Introduction Prediction markets have long been studied as mechanisms for aggregating dispersed information into probabilistic forecasts [ 37 , 38 , 28 , 1 , 3 , 35 , 30 , 11 ] . In the classic formulation, the main question is whether market prices summarize collective beliefs more effectively than polls, committees, or experts. That literature established a durable result: under many conditions, market prices are informative, reasonably calibrated, and practically useful for forecasting [ 37 , 1 , 35 ] . The problem this paper focuses on is more specific and more contemporary. Once institutional liquidity enters prediction markets through maker programs, exchange-run incentives, and automated quoting, the market can look easier to trade on average while still becoming harsher for slower or less informed traders. A narrower quoted spread does not automatically mean that every participant actually receives better execution. The key economic question is therefore simple: when institutional liquidity enters prediction markets, who really gets the benefit? A concrete example helps. Imagine a contract on whether a CPI release will come in above consensus. Before the announcement, market-maker support and automated quoting may compress the displayed spread. At the release time, however, some participants react almost instantly while others arrive late. The same market can therefore look more liquid in the book and yet become less forgiving for slower takers exactly when information arrives. This paper is organized around that tension. The market that now matters in practice is also richer than the one emphasized in the earliest forecasting literature. The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission has recently treated prediction markets and event contracts as an explicit regulatory object [ 9 , 10 ] . Kalshi publicly documents both a market-maker program and a liquidity incentive program, while also exposing order-book and public-trade feeds through its API [ 22 , 21 , 23 , 20 ] . Polymarket similarly documents CLOB data and public order-book access [ 34 , 33 ] . Institutional interest has also become more visible through strategic ICE investments in Polymarket [ 18 , 19 ] . Together, these developments move prediction markets toward the domain of electronic market design and market microstructure. This paper answers the resulting question in a deliberately scoped way. It develops a research design with a synthetic proof of concept: the aim is to define the relevant outcome family, separate the channels through which institutional liquidity enters, clarify what the live empirical paper must measure, and demonstrate that the pipeline can be implemented end-to-end before private or venue-level data are attached. Contribution and scope. The paper makes three contributions. First, it argues that prediction markets should be evaluated with a joint market-quality lens spanning liquidity, information efficiency, forecast quality, internal consistency, and trader-level welfare. Second, it replaces an omnibus institutionalization dummy with a channel-based treatment map: market-maker coverage, liquidity-incentive eligibility, automation/API intensity, and participant-composition shifts. Third, it states the live-data empirical agenda explicitly, including staggered-adoption identification, mediator measurement, richer heterogeneity, and welfare decomposition. The synthetic laboratory serves only to illustrate the estimands, tables, and figures that such a live paper should ultimately deliver. What public data can already tell us. Even without account-level data, a live public-data paper can say a great deal about quoted spreads, effective spreads, realized spreads, pass-through, and several forms of internal consistency. What it cannot cleanly sign on its own are informed-trader rents and genuine risk-sharing gains. Bringing that distinction forward helps clarify both the ambition and the limits of the empirical agenda. Roadmap. Section 2 lays out the institutional-liquidity decomposition and hypotheses. Section 3 defines the empirical agenda and the main identification challenges. Section 4 introduces the synthetic proof-of-concept and explains how it should be interpreted. Section 5 defines the outcome family. Section 6 distinguishes descriptive recovery inside the simulator from estimators appropriate for the live paper. Section 7 reports the synthetic illustrations. Section 8 deepens the welfare discussion and formalizes mediator measurement. Section 10 concludes. 2 Institutional Liquidity, Treatment Channels, and Hypotheses Prediction markets as electronic markets. A modern event contract is a binary claim paying $1 if a specified event occurs and $0 otherwise. Unlike equities, event contracts have bounded payoffs and deterministic convergence to 0 or 1 at settlement. They are also unusually shock-driven: macro releases, debate performances, court rulings, injuries, and protocol announcements can all move beliefs discontinuously. For that reason, market quality in prediction markets cannot be assessed from one dimension alone. Spread, depth, resiliency, price impact, forecast calibration, and cross-contract consistency all matter. Why institutional liquidity entry must be decomposed. The phrase “institutional participation” is too broad for causal work. To study institutional liquidity entry, the live empirical paper should instead distinguish at least four separable channels: 1. Designated market-maker coverage. Formal maker status, quoting obligations, or program enrollment. 2. Liquidity-incentive eligibility. Exchange subsidy rules for displayed orders or resting quotes. 3. Automation/API intensity. The ability and willingness of participants to quote or react through public or private infrastructure. 4. Participant-composition shifts. A change in the share of professional, systematic, or cross-venue-capable flow. The first three are candidate entry channels or treatments ; the fourth is better viewed as a mediator or equilibrium outcome . This distinction is important. A convincing live paper should estimate what maker designation, incentive eligibility, and automation access do separately, and then ask whether they work through a reweighting of participant composition. Conceptual trade-off. The microstructure intuition is standard. More institutional liquidity can tighten spreads, replenish depth, and reduce transitory price impact [ 13 , 24 , 27 , 4 , 31 , 15 , 16 ] . Modern algorithmic participation can also improve liquidity in other electronic markets [ 17 , 29 ] . But the same infrastructure can sharpen toxicity filters and concentrate information rents against less-informed traders. Prediction markets should therefore exhibit a familiar tension between better average execution and more selective extraction in shock states. Hypothesis 1 (Liquidity) . Market-maker coverage, liquidity incentives, and

Read the complete text