From Scalars to Tensors: Declared Losses Recover Epistemic Distinctions That Neutrosophic Scalars Cannot Express
Tony Mason · 2026
Read From Scalars to Tensors: Declared Losses Recover Epistemic Distinctions That Neutrosophic Scalars Cannot Express by Tony Mason (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-09602.txt.
Introduction
Mason extends work on neutrosophic evaluation, where truth, indeterminacy, and falsity vary independently rather than summing to one. Earlier work found hyper-truth, totals above one, in 35 percent of complex cases judged by language models. Replicating across five model families from five vendors, he finds it in 84 percent of unconstrained evaluations. He then exposes a blind spot: models in an Absorption position score identically for paradox, ignorance, and contingency. Adding declared losses, structured notes on what a model cannot judge and why, largely restores those distinctions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tony Mason |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35386 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.09602
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
From Scalars to Tensors: Declared Losses Recover Epistemic Distinctions That Neutrosophic Scalars Cannot Express Tony Mason Abstract Leyva-Vázquez and Smarandache (2025) demonstrated that neutrosophic T/I/F evaluation, where Truth, Indeterminacy, and Falsity are independent dimensions not constrained to sum to 1.0, which reveals “hyper-truth” (T+I+F ¿ 1.0) in 35% of complex epistemic cases evaluated by LLMs. We extend their work in two directions. First, we replicate and extend their experiment across five model families from five vendors (Anthropic, Meta, DeepSeek, Alibaba, Mistral), finding hyper-truth in 84% of unconstrained evaluations, which confirms the phenomenon is cross-vendor under our prompt protocol. Second, and more significantly, we identify a limitation of scalar T/I/F that their framework cannot address: models adopting an “Absorption” position (T=0, I=1, F=0) produce identical scalar outputs for fundamentally different epistemic situations (paradox, ignorance, contingency), collapsing the very distinctions neutrosophic logic was designed to preserve. We demonstrate that extending the evaluation to include declared losses (structured descriptions of what the model cannot evaluate and why) substantially recovers these distinctions. Models producing identical scalars for paradox and ignorance produce nearly disjoint loss vocabularies (Jaccard similarity ¡ 0.10 on loss description keywords), with domain-specific, severity-rated loss declarations that differentiate the nature of their uncertainty. This suggests that scalar T/I/F is a necessary but insufficient representation of epistemic state, and that tensor-structured output (scalars + losses) provides a more faithful model of LLM epistemic capabilities. 1 Introduction The application of Neutrosophic Logic to LLM uncertainty quantification ( [ 2 ] ) represents an important departure from probabilistic frameworks. By treating Truth (T), Indeterminacy (I), and Falsity (F) as independent dimensions, the neutrosophic approach allows models to express internal conflicts that probabilistic constraints (T+I+F=1) suppress. Their finding that 35% of evaluations exhibit “hyper-truth” (T+I+F ¿ 1.0) under unconstrained prompting demonstrates that LLMs carry richer epistemic information than probabilistic output formats can express. However, their study has three limitations that constrain the generalizability of their findings: 1. Single vendor : All four models (GPT-4o, GPT-4-turbo, GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4o-mini) come from OpenAI. The observed hyper-truth could be an artifact of OpenAI’s training pipeline rather than a general property of LLMs. 2. Single shot : Each cell (model × phenomenon × strategy) was evaluated once, providing no measure of intra-model consistency or statistical significance. 3. Unpublished prompts : The specific prompts used for each strategy were not committed to the repository, preventing independent replication. We address all three limitations. More importantly, we identify a fourth problem that scalar T/I/F cannot solve even in principle: the Absorption problem , where some models collapse all uncertain states to (T=0, I=1, F=0), losing the distinction between types of uncertainty that neutrosophic logic was designed to preserve. We then demonstrate that this problem is solved by extending the output format from scalars to tensors: specifically, by requiring models to declare structured losses alongside their T/I/F values. 1.1 Related Work Neutrosophic logic foundations. The formal basis for independent truth, indeterminacy, and falsity dimensions comes from neutrosophic logic and set theory ( [ 8 , 7 ] ), with subsequent critical analysis of expressiveness and interpretability tradeoffs ( [ 5 ] ). Our work operates within this tradition but focuses on an empirical question for modern LLMs: what epistemic distinctions current output formats preserve versus collapse. Neutrosophic uncertainty in LLMs. The immediate empirical precursor is Leyva-Vázquez and Smarandache’s LLM study ( [ 2 ] ), which introduced S1–S3 prompting strategies and reported hyper-truth under unconstrained evaluation. We extend this line with cross-vendor repeated trials and a new S4 tensor-output protocol designed to expose representational loss within scalar T/I/F outputs. Adjacent uncertainty frameworks in LLMs. Recent work on abstention and risk control in LLM systems emphasizes calibration, selective prediction, and refusal policies ( [ 10 , 9 , 4 ] ). This literature asks when a model should abstain. Our question is orthogonal: when a model does provide a T/I/F assessment, how much epistemic structure is lost by restricting output to three scalars. Honesty and self-knowledge. Research on honesty, overconfidence mitigation, and reasoning-linked reliability ( [ 3 , 11 , 1 ] ) is closely related to our “declared losses” mechanism. We treat losses as structured self-reports of epistemic limits and evaluate whether those reports carry discriminative content beyond scalar uncertainty. 2 Cross-Vendor Replication 2.1 Method We designed prompts for all three strategies described by Leyva-Vázquez and Smarandache (see Appendix A for full prompts): • S1 (Neutrosophic) : Independent T, I, F on [0,1], explicitly stated as not constrained to sum to 1.0 • S2 (Probabilistic) : T + I + F constrained to 1.0 • S3 (Entropy-Derived) : Binary P(yes)/P(no), indeterminacy derived from Shannon entropy [ 6 ] : H = -(p \cdot log 2 p + (1-p) \cdot log 2 (1-p)). Note: since T=P_yes and F=P_no with T+F=1.0 by construction, S3 Sum = 1.0 + H, meaning S3 produces hyper-truth by mathematical construction whenever P_yes is not exactly 0 or 1. S3 hyper-truth rates are therefore not directly comparable to S1 and are not used in our analysis We evaluated five models from five vendors via OpenRouter’s OpenAI-compatible API: Model Provider Parameters Claude Sonnet 4.6 Anthropic Undisclosed Llama 4 Maverick Meta Undisclosed DeepSeek V3 DeepSeek 671B MoE Qwen3-235B Alibaba 235B MoE Mistral Medium 3.1 Mistral Undisclosed Each cell was evaluated 5 times (temperature=0.7), yielding 375 evaluations (5 models × 5 phenomena × 3 strategies × 5 reps). Of these, 373 produced valid JSON parses; 2 responses were garbled or truncated (1 DeepSeek, 1 Llama) and are excluded from analysis. All data, code, and prompts are published in the repository. Important caveat : Because the original prompts were not published, we designed our prompts from the strategy descriptions in the paper. We cannot claim direct replication, which is a parallel experiment with independently constructed prompts. The S2 control (below) provides evidence that our prompt framing is not radically different from the original. 2.2 Results S2 constraint validation. Under probabilistic constraint (S2), all 125 evaluations across all models and phenomena produced Sum = 1.000 ± 0.000, with 0% hyper-truth. This matches the original study exactly and provides evidence that our prompt construction is compatible with theirs: the constraint mechanism behaves identically. S1 hyper-truth is cross-vendor and amplified. Under unconstrained neutrosophic evaluation (S1): Model Hyper% Mean Sum CV(Sum) Claude Sonnet 4.6 100% 1.810 0.110 DeepSeek V3 100% 1.475 0.161 Qwen3-235B 80% 1.464 0.242 Llama 4 Maverick 76% 1.348 0.230 Mistral Medium 3.1 64% 1.312 0.281 Overall S1 hyper-truth: 84% (104/124 valid cells; 1 garbled response excluded), compared to the original study’s 35% (7/20 cells). Because our prompts were independently constructed, this gap should be read as a cross-study difference rather than a direct effect-size comparison. Hyper-truth is not an OpenAI artifact as it emerges across all five vendor families. Phenomenon-level comparison with original: Phenomenon Original Sum Ours (S1) Delta Paradox (Logical) 1.500 1.480 -0.020 Ignorance (Epistemic) 1.125 1.526 +0.401 Vagueness (Fuzzy) 1.125 1.382 +0.257 Contradiction (Ethical) 1.475 1.690 +0.215 Contingency (Future) 1.000 1.325 +0.325 Ethical contradiction achieves 100% hyper-truth across all models in our data, confirming the original study’s finding that moral conflict is the strongest driver of hyper-truth. 2.3 Three Philosophical Positions on Paradox The liar’s paradox (“This sentence is false”) reveals three distinct interpretations of