Large or bright satellite constellations
O. R. Hainaut , · 2026
Read Large or bright satellite constellations by O. R. Hainaut , (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-09427.txt.
Introduction
Hainaut studies proposed satellite fleets on trail losses, diffuse background, and scattered sky brightness. Fleets range from current launches to mega-fleets and bright mirrors. A number model for Mie and Rayleigh bounce in the V band, adapted from moonlight math, is joined with SatCon. Fleets of about 60,000 craft under the brightness rule exert tiny effect, adding only about a ten-thousandth of natural dark sky. By contrast, mega-fleets with a million craft render trails rife, and a 5,000-craft bright fleet raises background by 20 to 30 percent.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | O. R. Hainaut , |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71755 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.09427
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Large or bright satellite constellations O. R. Hainaut , Abstract Context. Large satellite constellations impact astronomy through both visible trails and the generation of diffuse and atmospherically scattered light. Quantification of this cumulative sky-background component is essential to assess the full ramifications of extant and proposed systems. Aims. This study evaluates the effect of proposed constellations — ranging from current deployments to mega-constellations and very bright reflector concepts — on direct trail losses, diffuse background, and scattered sky brightness. Methods. The methodology employs a numerical model for Mie and Rayleigh scattering in the V V band, adapted from moonlight sky-brightness calculations and validated against observations of moonlight and stellar background light. This is combined with the SatConAnalytic package to quantify scattered light, diffuse light from undetected satellites, and direct losses from detected trails. Results. Constellations comprising ∼ 60 000 \sim 60\,000 satellites that adhere to the V 550 km ≥ 7 V_{\mathrm{550\penalty\ km}}\geq 7 recommendation exert a negligible effect on sky brightness, contributing only about 10 − 4 10^{-4} of the natural dark sky. Conversely, mega-constellations with 10 6 10^{6} satellites render trails pervasive, thereby affecting the majority of long exposures. Bright satellites, such as spacecraft analogous to AST SpaceMobile, significantly impact saturating detectors even when their number is moderate. Extremely bright satellites pose a far more severe threat: a 5000-satellite Reflect Orbital-like constellation could elevate the scattered sky background by 20%–30%, and a population of 50 000 50\,000 could increase it by 200%–300%. Conclusions. The constellations currently proposed for launch, which exceeds 1 700 000 objects and including satellites brighter than V 550 km = 7 V_{\mathrm{550\penalty\ km}}=7 , would substantially degrade astronomical observations. Maintaining satellite brightness below V 550 km = 7 V_{\mathrm{550\penalty\ km}}=7 is important for all instruments, but critical for safeguarding saturating instruments, such as the Rubin LSST camera and for limiting sky-background pollution. Even under this constraint, the total satellite population should remain below ∼ 100 000 \sim 100\,000 satellites to ensure that field-of-view losses do not exceed typical technical downtime. Effects on observations, including on the background sky brightness 1 Introduction The darkness of the sky background is one of the key parameters determining the quality of an observatory: for any background-dominated observation, the exposure time required to reach a given signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) scales linearly with sky brightness. This is also critical for \gamma - and cosmic-ray observations based on Cherenkov radiation from cascades of secondary particles produced when the primary particle interacts with atoms in the atmosphere, for which a stable, dark background is essential. Because of this linear dependence of exposure time on sky brightness, critical observations in the visible can be carried out only from sites with the darkest possible skies, during moonless nights. Moonlight precludes such observations, and telescopes typically switch instead to infrared instruments, for which moonlight is not an issue. Light pollution from cities and industries can raise sky brightness by orders of magnitude over distances of up to hundreds of kilometres ( 13 ) . Professional observatories have therefore retreated to remote sites in search of skies where light pollution remains below 1% of the natural dark-sky brightness. Light pollution at the 10% level is incompatible with state-of-the-art observatories 40 . The effects of artificial light at night (ALAN) and possible mitigation methods are well documented ( 7 , for a review, see) . New satellite constellations are being announced, some extremely large and others extremely bright. In this work, we evaluate their contribution to scattered and diffuse light in the optical regime and discuss their direct effects on observations. 1.1 Large satellite constellations Figure 1: Example of the effect of SpaceX’s one-million-satellite Orbital Data Center constellation on a 300-second FORS2 exposure at Paranal. Even 1.3 h after the end of astronomical twilight, more than half the sky is still affected, with an average of more than eight satellite trails per image at zenith. In regions corresponding to the constellation cusps, more than 20 trails cross each image. The effect on a 15-second exposure with the 3^{\circ} LSST camera at the Rubin observatory is similar. The figure is a map of the sky above the observatory (indicated at top left), with the zenith at the centre and the horizon along the outer circle. The dark region toward the east corresponds to the part of the sky where the satellites are already in the Earth’s shadow and are therefore invisible. The \odot symbol on the horizon indicates the Sun’s azimuth; its position is given at bottom left. The sky maps in this paper correspond to solar elevations e_{\odot}\leq-21^{\circ} , i.e. well after astronomical twilight. The red grid marks hour angle and declination. The grey circles correspond to elevations of 10 ∘ , 20 ∘ , 30 ∘ , and 60 ∘ above the horizon (most observations are made above 30 ∘ ). The colour scale on the right gives, in this example, the number of satellite trails per exposure. The annotations at top right and bottom right give details of the satellite constellation and the characteristics of the individual satellites. Since the spectacular launch of the first batch of SpaceX’s Starlink satellites in May 2019, the number of artificial satellites orbiting the Earth has increased from \sim 2000 to over 14 000, dominated by the deployment of the Starlink telecommunication constellation and a few other smaller constellations. That number rises further to over 32 000 when including dead satellites and debris (from Jonathan McDowell’s satellite statistics web page 1 1 1 https://planet4589.org/space/stats/acdec.html , Feb. 2026). Early spectacular satellite ‘‘photo-bombing’’ of wide-field images 2 2 2 e.g. this example from DECam: https://noirlab.edu/public/images/iotw1946a/ triggered the astronomical community to react. This resulted in a series of publications investigating the number and period of visibility of the constellation satellites ( 33 , e.g.) , as well as quantifying their impact on astronomical observations ( 17 ; 9 , e.g.) . In parallel, international conferences were organized — SatCon-1 ( 39 ) and -2 ( 18 ) , Dark and Quiet Skies 1 ( 40 , D&QS, ) and -2 ( 41 ) — where the optical and radio astronomy communities met with the satellite industry and relevant policy-makers. One of the key recommendations resulting from the SatCon conferences is that satellites must be fainter than magnitude V=7 in absolute terms and, for satellites with altitudes higher than 550 km, their magnitudes reduced to 550 km, V_{\mathrm{550\penalty\ km}} , must also be fainter than 7 (Priority No. 1 recommendation 41 , p. 1237) . This ensures that the satellites are not visible to the naked eye (matching its limiting magnitude in optimal conditions) and that they do not saturate the detector of the NSF-DOE Vera C. Rubin Observatory (see Sect. 2.1 for more details on this). Large satellite constellations also have a significant impact on radio astronomy. This is obvious if a satellite’s directional antenna directly illuminates a radio telescope pointing at that satellite. There is also a cumulative impact through the side lobes of the satellites and the telescopes, and through unintended emissions by the satellites. The SatCon and D&QS reports also discuss these matters. In what follows, we focus on the optical regime. Since the first launches,