Social Reality Construction via Active Inference: Modeling the Dialectic of Conformity and Creativity
Kentaro Nomura, Takato Horii · 2026
Read Social Reality Construction via Active Inference: Modeling the Dialectic of Conformity and Creativity by Kentaro Nomura, Takato Horii (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-09026.txt.
Introduction
Nomura and Horii model how social reality forms, with agents both absorbing shared norms and reshaping them through creative acts. Their multi-agent simulation rests on active inference: each agent holds an internal generative model, talks with neighbours to form social priors, and creates novel observations. The team finds that created content spreads selectively and unevenly, unlike the stable diffusion of shared representations. Agents thus build cultural niches through local interaction, and the interplay of conformity and creative deviation generates and differentiates shared social reality from within.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kentaro Nomura, Takato Horii |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39085 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.09026
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Social Reality Construction via Active Inference: Modeling the Dialectic of Conformity and Creativity Kentaro Nomura, Takato Horii Abstract Social agents both internalize collective norms and reshape them through creative action, yet computational models have not captured this bidirectional process within a unified framework. We propose a multi-agent simulation model grounded in active inference that formalizes the dialectical constitution of social reality on a structured social network. Each agent maintains an internal generative model, communicates with neighbors to form social priors, creates novel observations, and selectively incorporates others’ creations into memory. Simulation experiments demonstrate three main findings. First, informationally cohesive social groups emerge endogenously, with representational alignment mirroring the cluster topology of the underlying network. Second, a circular mutual constitution arises between social representations and the observation distribution, maintained through agents’ creative acts that project representational structure onto the external world. Third, the propagation of creations exhibits selective, heterogeneous patterns distinct from the stable diffusion of social representations, indicating that agents construct cultural niches through local interaction dynamics. These results suggest that the interplay between social conformity and creative deviation can give rise to the endogenous formation and differentiation of shared social reality. Submission type: Full Paper Data/Code available at: https://github.com/jemand-rkn/social-reality-aif.git Introduction Social agents both internalize collective norms and reshape them by creating and reifying new objects of meaning in the physical world. Through local interaction, these individual acts give rise to a shared social reality that, in turn, feeds back to shape further individual action. Mead ( 18 ) located this tension within the individual, formulating it as the interaction between the norm-internalizing Me and the creatively responding I . Berger and Luckmann ( 2 ) , in contrast, characterized the same dynamic at the macro level as a dialectic of externalization, objectivation, and internalization, describing how society reproduces itself through individual action. Despite this rich theoretical tradition, the computational mechanisms by which bottom-up creative formation and top-down social regulation jointly produce stable yet evolving norms remain poorly understood. To address this gap, we propose a multi-agent simulation model grounded in the free energy principle. In this model, agents actively create novel observations and communicate via a naming game on a social network, thereby computationally realizing the dialectical process of social reality construction. Existing models in the Artificial Life community have demonstrated that shared conventions can emerge from local agent interactions, yet they uniformly treat agents as rule-following entities rather than probabilistic reasoners with internal generative models. The naming game paradigm ( 24 ; 1 ) established that shared vocabularies self-organize through pairwise interaction, undergoing a sharp phase transition to global consensus without centralized coordination. Similarly, the iterated learning framework ( 23 ; 14 ) showed that cultural transmission alone can generate compositional linguistic structure. Communicative exploration has also been shown to sustain open-ended collective novelty ( 29 ) . However, because agents in these models lack internal generative models, they cannot capture the top-down regulatory influence of social context on individual cognition or the generative capacity to produce observations that deviate from prevailing norms. Active inference ( 22 ) offers a principled framework for deriving collective behavior and social norm formation from individual surprise minimization without requiring explicit behavioral rules. Canonical collective phenomena—cohesion, milling, and directed motion—have been shown to emerge when agents minimize surprise about their conspecifics, with real-time model updates coupling individual learning to group-level properties ( 10 ) . Communication under active inference has further been shown to drive generalized synchrony and long-term convergence of generative models between agents ( 6 ; 7 ) . Norm acquisition has also been formalized as free energy minimization with respect to a model of others’ expectations ( 27 ; 12 ) . However, these models address either spatial coordination or the internalization of pre-existing expectations; none accounts for how agents’ own creative acts feed back into the formation of shared social representations. This gap corresponds to the missing bottom-up direction in niche construction theory ( 21 ; 16 ; 17 ) , which holds that organisms actively reshape their environment. This process has been formalized as free energy minimization through environmental modification, providing a variational basis for niche construction ( 4 ) . The Collective Predictive Coding (CPC) hypothesis ( 26 ) extends predictive coding and the free energy principle to the societal scale, offering a theoretical account of how shared representations such as symbol systems and social norms emerge through communicative interaction. Under CPC, social representations are formed through decentralized Bayesian inference. The Metropolis–Hastings Naming Game (MHNG) has been proposed as its concrete algorithmic realization ( 9 ; 25 ) , which has been further extended to N -agent populations through a recursive formulation ( 11 ) . However, CPC treats social representations as external shared variables that connect all agents through a joint generative model. This formulation implicitly assumes that a common representation is shared across the population, thereby precluding the natural emergence of distinct social groups. Furthermore, agents in this framework are passive observers that infer representations from observations they receive , leaving the feedback pathway from individual creative acts to social representation formation unaddressed. In the present work, social representations are instead placed inside each agent and allowed to differ across individuals, enabling representational alignment to emerge naturally from local interaction. Agents are also endowed with the capacity for active creation, closing the feedback loop between individual creativity and collective norm formation. We present a multi-agent simulation model that formalizes the bidirectional constitution of social reality within a unified active inference framework on a structured social network. Each agent is formalized as an internal generative model that is continuously updated through communication with neighbors, active creation of novel observations, and selective incorporation of others’ creations. Top-down regulation and bottom-up formation are realized as variational and expected free energy minimization, respectively, placing them in a formally adversarial yet complementary relationship. The present work makes three contributions. First, we show that informationally cohesive social groups emerge endogenously, mirroring the cluster topology of the underlying network. Second, social representations and the observation distribution are mutually constituted through agents’ creative acts. Third, creations propagate in selective, heterogeneous patterns, indicating that agents construct cultural niches through local interaction. Proposed Model Agent Architecture Each agent in the proposed model maintains an internal generative model that describes how observations are generated from social representations as latent variables. Here, observations represent information that agents experience in the physical world. The generative model is agent-specific and is updated in a fully decentralized manner. Specifically, the generative model for agent A^{k} is defined as follows: social prior: \displaystyle\bm{z}\sim p^{k}_{\textrm{social}}(\bm{z}), (1) likelihood: \displaystyle\bm{o}\sim p^{k}_{\theta}(\bm{o}|\bm{z}), (2) posterior: \displaystyle\bm{z}\sim q^{k}_{\phi}(\bm{z}|\bm{o}), (3) where \bm{z} and \bm{o} denote the social representation and the observation, respectively, and k indexes the agent. The likelihood p^{k}_{\theta}(\bm{o}|\bm{z}) and the approximate posterior q^{k}_{\phi}(\bm{z}|\bm{o}) are parameterized by neural network weights \theta and \phi , respectively. The social prior p^{k}_{\textrm{social}}(\cdot) is a probability distribution that reflects the social context in which the agent is situated. This distribution evolves as the agent interacts with others. Each agent also possesses a discriminator D^{k}_{\psi}(\bm{z},\bm{o}) that quantifies the divergence between the agent’s approximate posterior q^{k}_{\phi}(\cdot|\bm{o}) and the social prior p^{k}_{\textrm{social}}(\cdot) . The discriminator is trained to approximate the log-density ratio between