Towards Linguistically-informed Representations for English as a Second or Foreign Language: Review, Construction and Application

Wenxi Li, Xihao Wang, Weiwei Sun · 2026

Read Towards Linguistically-informed Representations for English as a Second or Foreign Language: Review, Construction and Application by Wenxi Li, Xihao Wang, Weiwei Sun (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-09008.txt.

Introduction

Li, Wang, and Sun argue that English as a second or foreign language should be treated as its own linguistic system, not as faulty standard English. That shift calls for knowledge-rich representations, so they survey existing resources, expose their limits, and propose a construction-based design. Grounded in constructivist theories, the design treats grammatical constructions as the basic units and maps form to meaning. The result is a gold-standard resource of 1643 annotated sentences, tested in a pilot study of the Linguistic Niche Hypothesis for second language acquisition.

Catalog record

CREATORWenxi Li, Xihao Wang, Weiwei Sun
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34578
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.09008

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Towards Linguistically-informed Representations for English as a Second or Foreign Language: Review, Construction and Application Wenxi Li, Xihao Wang, Weiwei Sun Abstract The widespread use of English as a Second or Foreign Language (ESFL) has sparked a paradigm shift: ESFL is not seen merely as a deviation from standard English but as a distinct linguistic system in its own right. This shift highlights the need for dedicated, knowledge-intensive representations of ESFL. In response, this paper surveys existing ESFL resources, identifies their limitations, and proposes a novel solution. Grounded in constructivist theories, the paper treats constructions as the fundamental units of analysis, allowing it to model the syntax–semantics interface of both ESFL and standard English. This design captures a wide range of ESFL phenomena by referring to syntactico-semantic mappings of English while preserving ESFL’s unique characteristics, resulting a gold-standard syntactico-semantic resource comprising 1643 annotated ESFL sentences. To demonstrate the sembank’s practical utility, we conduct a pilot study testing the Linguistic Niche Hypothesis, highlighting its potential as a valuable tool in Second Language Acquisition research. keywords English as a Second or Foreign Language, Syntax–Semantics Interface, Constructivist Theory, SemBank 1 Introduction In today’s globalized world,, English as a Second or Foreign Language (ESFL), produced by non-native speakers who make up over 70% of English users worldwide, has become a primary tool for cross-lingual communication, particularly in open and informal contexts such as social media. This widespread usage necessitates a critical paradigm shift: ESFL may not be recognized as an erroneous approximation of native norms, but as a legitimate, distinct linguistic system shaped by the complex interplay of a speaker’s primary languages and English ( Selinker+1972+209+232 ; nemser1991language ; corder1982error ) . As such, ESFL requires dedicated linguistically-informed resources to accurately represent and process its unique structures just like any other natural language. However, a survey of existing representations for ESFL (see § 2 ), ranging from POS tagging ( diaz2010towards ) to universal syntactic frameworks ( berzak-etal-2016-universal ) and semantic annotations ( zhao-etal-2020-semantic ) , reveals a fundamental challenge. Because ESFL lacks a static “native” anchor and is characterized by high variability and rapid evolution, developing a consistent framework is difficult. Most existing resources use standard English as a rigid reference point. This creates a persistent tension: strictly adhering to native norms risks erasing the distinctive features and cross-linguistic nuances of the multilingual speaker, while relaxing those norms often compromises the coherence of the representation. To resolve this, we adopt a multilingual-centric constructivist approach. Constructivist theories posit that language consists of “constructions”, i.e., form–meaning pairings that serve as the fundamental units of linguistic analysis ( goldberg2003constructions ; croft2001radical ) . We therefore propose deriving sentence-level representations for both standard English and ESFL from a shared inventory of reusable syntactico-semantic constructions. This approach preserves the distinctive surface forms (syntax) generated by multilingual speakers while grounding them in the underlying semantic equivalents shared with English. By modeling the syntax–semantics interface as a flexible mapping, we can capture the idiosyncratic features of the ESFL grammar without sacrificing representational consistency. We implement this approach using Synchronous Hyperedge Replacement Grammar (SHRG), a formalism that pairs syntactic rules, represented as trees, with corresponding semantic rules over graphs. Together, these synchronized rules form a constructional inventory that treats ESFL sentences as systematic linguistic productions rather than as random or ill-formed errors. Building on this SHRG framework, we develop ESFL SemBank, a gold-standard syntactico-semantic resource (see § 4 ). Its construction follows a rigorous Review–Revise–Rebuild workflow: we manually review silver-standard semantic graphs ( zhao-etal-2020-semantic ) , revise rejected analyses to ensure semantic fidelity, and rebuild unparsable sentences by selecting or creating appropriate SHRG rules. ESFL SemBank provides a powerful lens for language acquisition. By explicitly encoding how ESFL speakers — whose second or foreign language is English — map linguistic form to meaning, the resource enables in-depth analyses of the cognitive mechanisms and developmental trajectories underlying ESFL production. In § , we illustrate its utility through a case study of the Linguistic Niche Hypothesis ( lupyan2010language ) . Our statistical analysis shows that, while ESFL syntactic patterns largely align with those of English, ESFL often exhibits a more transparent and consistent mapping between form and meaning. This finding suggests that multilingual speakers may optimize the syntax–semantics interface for communicative clarity, offering empirical evidence of how non-native speakers navigate typological constraints to achieve cross-lingual fluency. 2 Survey: Existing Resources for ESFL Efforts to develop knowledge-intensive, task-independent, and linguistically-informed representations for human languages have become an important research area ( oepen-lonning-2006-discriminant ; slacker ; amr ; abend-rappoport-2013-universal , e.g.,) . Similar efforts have also been extended to ESFL, leading to the development of several corpora specifically designed for it. Based on their strategies for referencing standard English, we group these corpora into three categories: • Target-language-based : directly projecting English-based frameworks or models onto ESFL data (§ 2.1 ). • Multiple-criteria-based : applying various English-derived criteria to interpret ESFL phenomena (§ 2.2 ). • Universal-framework-based : using a language-neutral framework to mediate between English and ESFL (§ 2.3 ). 2.1 Target-language-based Approach One representative example using the target-language-based approach is the Konan-JIEM Learner Corpus ( nagata-etal-2011-creating ; nagata-sakaguchi-2016-phrase ) . This resource introduces a phrase-structure-based annotation scheme and a manually constructed treebank. Annotations are grounded in native English syntactic norms, consistently identifying the structure in standard English that most closely reflects the learner’s intended meaning. When learner productions cannot be aligned with any plausible native structure, the scheme introduces specialized node labels — such as -err , in , ce , xp-ord , uk , and up — to mark errors related to omission, insertion, substitution, word order, and unknown words or phrases, respectively. Another example is the SemBank of English as a Second Language ( zhao-etal-2020-semantic ) , which, so far as we know, is the only effort to construct a comprehensive semantic bank for learner English. This resource adopts a target-language-based strategy by using the ACE parser, trained on English Resource Grammar ( erg , ERG;) , to parse ESFL sentences. For each ESFL sentence S , the parser derives K -best corresponding semantic graphs. A reranking procedure then selects the candidate that best aligns with the gold-standard syntactic tree from the TLE corpus ( berzak-etal-2016-universal ) . In total, 2691 ESFL sentences are successfully parsed. 2.2 Multiple-criteria-based Approach Resources under the multiple-criteria-based approach, drawing on multiple English-derived criteria, adopt layered annotation strategies to interpret ESFL data more flexibly. For instance, diaz2010towards propose a tripartite analysis for POS tagging of ESFL in the NOCE Corpus, a Spanish learner corpus of English. Based on an empirical investigation of learner language collected in NOCE, the authors observe that applying single POS tagging scheme is problematic — the distributional, lexical, and morphological evidence for classifying a token in ESFL data often does not converge on a single POS tag. Therefore, they suggest annotating each word with three parallel POS tags to capture its lexical, morphological, and distributional forms, respectively. The Syntactically Annotated Learner Language of English (SALLE) project ( ragheb_2023_10054513 ; dickinson-ragheb-2015-grammaticality ) also proposes a multi-layer framework to represent the morpho-syntactic information of learner language. Based on the CHILDES annotation framework ( sagae-etal-2004-adding ; sagae-etal-2007-high ) , both POS tags and dependencies are

Read the complete text