Validating a Non-conventional Method for Expansion of Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) and Investigating the Evolution of a CME Substructures Using Solar Orbiter and Wind Observations

2026

Read Validating a Non-conventional Method for Expansion of Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) and Investigating the Evolution of a CME Substructures Using Solar Orbiter and Wind Observations (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-08842.txt.

Introduction

Agarwal and three colleagues test CAAP, an unusual method for gauging the current growth speed of coronal mass bursts from single point in situ readings. Radial lineup of Solar Orbiter and Wind during 3 to 5 November 2021 gives joint views of a magnet cloud center and trailing edge. That gives a direct measure of growth speed to check against CAAP guesses at both craft. The team also tracks shock, sheath, and magnet cloud parts, finding a stronger shock at Wind, near constant sheath thickness, and rising flux that breaks flux saving.

Catalog record

YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE99384
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.08842

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Validating a Non-conventional Method for Expansion of Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) and Investigating the Evolution of a CME Substructures Using Solar Orbiter and Wind Observations Abstract We present a validation of our recently proposed non-conventional method, Constant Acceleration Accounted Perspective (CAAP), for estimating the instantaneous expansion speed of coronal mass ejection (CMEs), even when only single-point in situ observations are available. This validation is enabled by the radial alignment of SolO and Wind spacecraft (0.13 AU radial and 2.3 ∘ angular separation), providing simultaneous observations of the center (at Wind) and trailing edge (at SolO) of a CME–associated magnetic cloud (MC) during 3–5 November 2021, allowing a direct measurement of its instantaneous expansion speed. These measurements are compared with CAAP-derived instantaneous expansion speed estimates at both spacecraft. The favorable spacecraft configuration also enables tracking the temporal evolution of CME substructures, including the shock, sheath, and MC. A discrepancy is noted between the low-inclination MC axis estimated from minimum variance analysis (MVA) and the highly inclined ENW-type MC axis suggested by visual inspection of in situ measurements. We also observe an apparent increase in the magnetic flux within the MC from SolO to Wind, indicating a noticeable deviation from magnetic flux conservation. During the CME’s propagation from SolO to Wind, the shock becomes unexpectedly stronger at Wind, while the sheath thickness remains nearly the same, likely due to MC acceleration from back compression by a high-speed stream and ambient solar wind variability. Our results demonstrate the applicability of the CAAP method and the importance of accounting for temporal evolution in CME substructures for space weather studies. † † journal: Space Weather † † authors: Anjali Agarwal, Wageesh Mishra, Mathew J. Owens, and Tanja Amerstorfer † † corresponding: Anjali Agarwal, [email protected] † † corresponding: Wageesh Mishra, [email protected] Indian Institute of Astrophysics, II Block, Koramangala, Bengaluru 560034, India Pondicherry University, R.V. Nagar, Kalapet 605014, Puducherry, India Space and Atmospheric Electricity Group, Department of Meteorology, University of Reading, Earley Gate, P.O. Box 243, Reading, RG6 6BB, UK Austrian Space Weather Office, GeoSphere Austria, Graz, Austria keypoints We validate our proposed constant acceleration accounted perspective (CAAP) method for estimating the instantaneous expansion speed of CMEs. Radial alignment of two spacecraft enabled simultaneous observations of the MC center (at Wind) and trailing edge (at Solar Orbiter). Radially separated two spacecraft reveal that the properties of the CME substructures evolve significantly between the two locations. Plain Language Summary Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are large clouds of magnetized plasma released from the Sun and are major drivers of space weather at Earth. As CMEs travel through space, they often expand, which influences how long Earth’s space environment remains disturbed. Therefore, it is essential to estimate the instantaneous expansion speed of the CME, which cannot be determined using conventional methods that rely on single-point in situ measurements. In this study, we validate a newly developed method, called the Constant Acceleration Accounted Perspective (CAAP), which estimates the instantaneous expansion speed of CMEs using single-point spacecraft observations. We apply this method to a CME observed on 3 November 2021 by two radially aligned spacecraft, Solar Orbiter and Wind, allowing a rare direct measurement of CME instantaneous expansion for comparison. The CAAP method estimates show good agreement with the measured instantaneous expansion speed, confirming the method’s reliability. We also examine how different CME regions–the shock, sheath, and magnetic cloud–evolve as the CME travels through space, finding that their properties can be strongly influenced by fast solar wind streams behind the CME and variability in background solar wind conditions. 1 Introduction Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are magnetized plasma bubbles that are ejected from the solar corona into the heliosphere Webb & Howard (2012) ; Mishra & Teriaca (2023) ; Temmer et al. (2023) , and are the primary drivers of space weather phenomena Schwenn (2006) ; Schrijver et al. (2015) . The magnetic and plasma characteristics of CMEs in the heliosphere are commonly inferred using in situ observations that sample the structures along a one-dimensional spacecraft trajectory, while remote observations offer complementary constraints on their global and plasma properties Burlaga et al. (1981) ; Bothmer & Schwenn (1998) . Using these observations, CME substructures–such as the shock, sheath, and the leading edge (LE) and trailing edge (TE) of magnetic cloud (MC)– can be identified based on their characteristic magnetic field and plasma signatures Zurbuchen & Richardson (2006) ; Mishra & Teriaca (2023) . MCs are often identified as having flux-rope-like magnetic configurations, inferred from in situ measurements. The flux rope structure is often characterized by plasma embedded within an enhanced magnetic field region, where the magnetic field lines are helically wrapped around a central axis, with pitch angles (the angle between the magnetic field vector and the flux rope axis) increasing from the center (axis) towards the periphery, and the structure typically expands as it travels outward from the Sun. Depending on the wrapping and inclination, the flux ropes can be classified into different types. There are two types of flux rope that exist, based on their inclination (i) low-inclined and (ii) high-inclined flux rope, and each type of flux rope can be further divided into four categories based on their polarities, i.e., rotation of field vector across the MC Burlaga et al. (1981) ; Bothmer & Schwenn (1998) ; Mulligan et al. (1998) ; Nieves-Chinchilla et al. (2018) . A CME can drive an interplanetary shock if its speed in the solar wind frame exceeds the local magnetosonic speed. Sheath is a turbulent, compressed, and heated region of solar wind between the shock and the MC Tsurutani et al. (1988) ; K.E.J. Huttunen et al. (2002) ; K. Huttunen & Koskinen (2004) . The properties of shock, sheath, and flux rope evolve as they propagate through the solar wind and therefore, studying them at different distances from the Sun, using multiple spacecraft, helps in understanding their evolution, influence on the local environment, and planetary space weather Temmer et al. (2014) ; Harrison et al. (2018) ; Amerstorfer et al. (2021) ; Xu et al. (2022) ; Chi et al. (2023) ; Chi et al. (2024) . Although in situ observations provide several information about the dynamics and plasma properties of CMEs, such observations from a single vantage point are insufficient to infer the presence of all the substructures of a CME and its global properties Burlaga et al. (1981) ; Crooker & Intriligator (1996) ; Nieves-Chinchilla et al. (2013) . The measured properties depend on the geometric selection effect–spacecraft trajectory through the nose or flank of the CME itself, impact parameter (the distance of closest approach to the flux rope axis), and flux rope orientation. The absence of any substructures in these observations does not strictly imply their absence within the CME itself, but rather may be a result of the spacecraft’s unfavorable one-dimensional trajectory through the CME. For example, in situ observations, only 30%-40% CMEs exhibit flux rope (i.e., MC) substructure Gosling (1990) ; Chi et al. (2016) ; Mishra, Doshi & Srivastava (2021) , which is understood to be due to geometric selection effect Gopalswamy (2006) ; Zhang et al. (2013) . The local single-point in situ observations of CMEs are also understood to provide inaccurate estimation of CME expansion

Read the complete text