A Lapse in the Cosmological Constant Problem

Justin Khoury, Benjamin Muntz, Antonio Padilla · 2026

Read A Lapse in the Cosmological Constant Problem by Justin Khoury, Benjamin Muntz, Antonio Padilla (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-08659.txt.

Introduction

Khoury, Muntz, and Padilla propose a new route through the cosmological constant problem using a lapse function in a higher dimensional gravity theory. Inspired by Horava-Lifshitz gravity, they study a five dimensional spacetime where scaling differs along a compact extra dimension while keeping four dimensional Lorentz invariance. Varying the lapse in the deep infrared yields a global constraint akin to vacuum energy sequestering, cancelling radiative vacuum energy contributions at all orders.

Catalog record

CREATORJustin Khoury, Benjamin Muntz, Antonio Padilla
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24626
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.08659

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Lapse in the Cosmological Constant Problem Justin Khoury, Benjamin Muntz, Antonio Padilla Abstract We present a new mechanism for addressing the cosmological constant problem based on global constraints arising from a lapse function in a higher-dimensional gravitational theory. Inspired by Hořava–Lifshitz gravity, we consider a 5d spacetime with anisotropic scaling along a compact extra dimension, while preserving Lorentz invariance in four dimensions. In the deep infrared limit, variation with respect to the lapse generates a global constraint on the 4d geometry, closely analogous to that of vacuum energy sequestering. Although the resulting effective gravitational equations differ from standard sequestering, radiative contributions to the Standard Model vacuum energy are nevertheless cancelled at all orders. I Introduction For a generic effective field theory (EFT) valid up to an ultraviolet cut-off scale \Lambda_{\rm cutoff} , standard quantum field theory arguments imply that the vacuum energy density receives radiative contributions of order \rho_{\rm vac}\sim\Lambda_{\rm cutoff}^{4} . In the absence of gravity this presents no inconsistency: a constant shift of the Lagrangian has no effect on the equations of motion and is therefore physically irrelevant. The situation changes fundamentally once gravity is included. In General Relativity (GR), vacuum energy gravitates universally and appears as an effective cosmological constant. As a result, \rho_{\rm vac} is directly probed by large-scale cosmological observations, which indicate an anomalously small value consistent with the observed dark energy density, \rho_{\rm vac}^{\rm obs}\lesssim(\text{meV})^{4} . For an EFT with a cut-off as low as the TeV scale, this corresponds to a discrepancy of at least sixty orders of magnitude between the expected and observed vacuum energy densities. While it is always possible to cancel quantum contributions order by order by introducing a finely tuned counterterm in the effective Lagrangian, this procedure must be repeated at every loop order and for every threshold in the theory. The resulting sensitivity of the gravitational dynamics to ultraviolet physics represents an extreme violation of naturalness and signals a deep incompatibility between standard EFT reasoning and the gravitational response to vacuum energy. For a range of reviews of the cosmological constant problem, see 39 ; 4 ; 6 ; 31 ; 37 ; 2 ; 3 ; 34 ; 1 . One possibility is that the cosmological constant problem is signalling a structural failure in how vacuum energy gravitates. Modifying gravity to address cosmological problems at both short and long distances is nothing new 7 ; 21 . The difficulty with the cosmological constant is that it is a long wavelength source in the gravitational field equations. Modifying gravity at large distances is often in conflict with phenomenology, owing to the presence of new light degrees of freedom in the theory 32 . For example, these light fields can lead to fifth forces, spoiling precision tests of gravity. The standard response is to rely on so-called screening mechanisms that are often poorly understood. An interesting and perhaps unique exception to this rule is to consider the extreme case of a global modification of gravity, where the differences only apply to sources of infinite wavelength. This is a promising direction since vacuum energy is the infinite wavelength source of the gravitational field equations. All other sources like planets and stars have finite wavelength and should gravitate normally, enjoying the same observational successes as GR. The prototypical example of this is vacuum energy sequestering (VES), where new global degrees of freedom are added to the gravitational action 24 ; 25 ; 26 ; 22 ; 23 ; 27 ; 11 ; 35 ; 9 ; 12 . These new degrees of freedom act like Lagrange multipliers imposing global constraints. The result is that radiative contributions to \rho_{\rm vac} do not gravitate. Localised sources trigger the same gravitational response as in GR. However, the origin of the global degrees of freedom in VES is not so well understood. One heuristic possibility is motivated by wormhole configurations where fundamental constants can vary from one “universe” to another 15 ; 16 . The resulting ensemble can be written as an integration over the value of the fundamental constants in the path integral 8 , with the saddle points giving global constraints 34 . However, this interpretation is expected to exhibit the so-called wormhole catastrophe leading to a breakdown of semi-classical control and loss of predictability 13 ; 36 . On the other hand, the manifestly local formulation of VES 22 makes use of three-form fields and their corresponding four-form field strengths, extending the four-form formulations of unimodular gravity 17 ; 33 . Such fields do not introduce any local dynamics but instead modify the global structure of the theory by enforcing global constraints. While this formulation opens up a possible pathway toward embedding VES in a UV-complete framework 35 ; 12 , a concrete realisation of such an embedding is still lacking. In this paper, we explore a new route to VES-like global constraints, inspired by Hořava–Lifshitz gravity 18 ; 19 . Hořava–Lifshitz gravity is a proposal for quantum gravity in four spacetime dimensions in which Lorentz invariance is replaced in the ultraviolet by a preferred foliation and an anisotropic scaling between time and space. In the projectable version of the theory, the lapse function is restricted to depend only on the preferred time coordinate; a structure preserved by the underlying symmetries. As a result, variation of the action with respect to the lapse yields a global constraint on the spatial geometry. Here we promote this idea to five spacetime dimensions by introducing a preferred spatial direction associated with a compact extra dimension. Lorentz invariance is preserved along four spacetime directions, with anisotropic scaling along the fifth dimension in the far infrared. We then perform an ADM decomposition adapted to this foliation of the 5d spacetime and take a projectable limit in which the lapse depends only on the preferred spatial coordinate. Analogous to the projectable version of Hořava-Lifshitz gravity, variation with respect to the lapse generates a global constraint along the foliation slices, which in our case corresponds to a 4d spacetime. We therefore obtain a global constraint on the 4d geometry, as in VES. Interestingly, however, the form of the constraint is subtly different from that of VES, leading to a distinct effective theory of gravity. The mechanism nevertheless cancels radiative contributions to the Standard Model vacuum energy and points to a one-parameter family of theories that generalises the global cancellations found in VES. II Solving the cosmological constant problem with anisotropic scaling Lorentz invariance in four spacetime dimensions has been tested to extraordinary precision, with no violations observed at the level of one part in 10^{21} 38 . In theoretical models involving extra dimensions, it is often assumed that Lorentz symmetry extends to the full higher-dimensional theory. However, there is no direct experimental evidence for Lorentz invariance beyond the observed four dimensions (given there is also no evidence of extra dimensions!). An intriguing and relatively unexplored possibility is that Lorentz invariance holds strictly in the observed 4d spacetime, while being explicitly broken along the extra dimensions via anisotropic scaling. This idea is reminiscent of Lifshitz field theories, originally introduced in the context of critical phenomena 29 ; 30 ; 20 , in which some coordinates scale differently near a

Read the complete text