AI generates well-liked but templatic empathic responses

Emma S. Gueorguieva, Hongli Zhan, Jina Suh, Javier Hernandez, Tatiana Lau, Junyi Jessy Li, Desmond C. Ong · 2026

Read AI generates well-liked but templatic empathic responses by Emma S. Gueorguieva, Hongli Zhan, Jina Suh, Javier Hernandez, Tatiana Lau, Junyi Jessy Li, Desmond C. Ong (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-08479.txt.

Introduction

Gueorguieva and six colleagues find that language model empathy follows a well liked template, while human empathy varies more freely. From a taxonomy of ten empathic tactics, including validating feelings and paraphrasing, they compare 3,265 machine replies with 1,290 human ones across two studies. A fixed tactic sequence matches 83 to 90 percent of machine replies and covers most of each matched reply, raising questions about the future of machine generated empathy.

Catalog record

CREATOREmma S. Gueorguieva, Hongli Zhan, Jina Suh, Javier Hernandez, Tatiana Lau, Junyi Jessy Li, Desmond C. Ong
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57733
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY SA
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.08479

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI generates well-liked but templatic empathic responses Emma S. Gueorguieva, Hongli Zhan, Jina Suh, Javier Hernandez, Tatiana Lau, Junyi Jessy Li, Desmond C. Ong Abstract Recent research shows that greater numbers of people are turning to Large Language Models (LLMs) for emotional support, and that people rate LLM responses as more empathic than human-written responses. We suggest a reason for this success: LLMs have learned and consistently deploy a well-liked template for expressing empathy. We develop a taxonomy of 10 empathic language ”tactics” that include validating someone’s feelings and paraphrasing, and apply this taxonomy to characterize the language that people and LLMs produce when writing empathic responses. Across a set of 2 studies comparing a total of n n = 3,265 AI-generated (by six models) and n n = 1,290 human-written responses, we find that LLM responses are highly formulaic at a discourse functional level. We discovered a template—a structured sequence of tactics—that matches between 83–90% of LLM responses (and 60-83% in a held out sample), and when those are matched, covers 81–92% of the response. By contrast, human-written responses are more diverse. We end with a discussion of implications for the future of AI-generated empathy. keywords Empathy, Language, AI, Communication, NLP 1 Introduction In times of distress, we often turn to others for empathy ( 14 ; 4 ) , and receiving such social support is crucial for well-being ( 3 ) . Recent growth in the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) has been accompanied by a new trend: people are increasingly seeking empathy and support from LLMs, especially for companionship and therapy ( 28 ; 44 ; 69 ) . Recent research has found that people reliably rate LLM-generated responses to support-seeking posts as more empathic, compassionate, and help people feel more heard than human-written responses across a wide range of contexts ( 36 ; 79 ; 53 ) —even when such responses are written by crisis responders ( 54 ) . Other research has found that chatting with LLMs may be associated with improved mental health ( 67 ) , reduced loneliness ( 12 ) , and even reduced suicidal ideations for some users ( 43 ) . A recent clinical trial with a generative AI-powered therapy chatbot has also suggested that it can reduce symptoms of depression, anxiety, and eating disorders ( 24 ) . Given these emerging findings, it is surprising that not many studies have gone beyond subjective ratings to investigate what is actually in the language of these LLM-generated empathic messages. Studies have noted that LLMs produce longer messages than people ( 82 ) or chose longer words in favor of more concise ones (e.g., “mathematics” over “math”) ( 5 ) , which may be interpreted by empathy recipients as a measure of empathic effort or concern ( 6 ; 81 ) . Only one study ( 36 ) applied language analyses to identify n-grams that are most predictive of perceived empathy. A focus on the language—the concrete “behaviors” that are exchanged between LLMs and their human users—is important and can complement studies on the psychological perceptions of AI-generated empathy ( 60 ; 78 ) . One reason why a focus on language is important in studying perceived empathy is that there exists a gap between psychological theories and what is required for AI models. Existing psychological theories of empathy focus primarily on empathizer capacities like the ability to share another’s feelings (experience sharing; 13 ; 63 ), the ability to take another’s perspective (perspective taking; 20 ; 34 ), or the desire to help someone in distress (empathic concern; 2 ; 81 ). But scholars have pointed out that AI has no emotions and so, according to these definitions, cannot truly empathize ( 56 ; 46 ) . Yet, this does not jive with growing evidence from psychology ( 53 ) and medicine ( 25 ) that people consistently rate AI-generated responses as more empathic than human-written responses ( 36 ; 54 ; 79 ) . The evidence for this main effect is overwhelming: two recent reviews found that 19 of 19 effect sizes ( 53 ) and 13 of 15 studies ( 25 ) found evidence in favor of AI. But psychological research also finds a second main effect: controlling for who (or what) generated the response, when people are told that a response had been generated by an AI, they perceive it as being less empathic ( 54 ; 60 ; 79 ) . This second main effect is purely psychological—perhaps relating to people’s judgments that AI lacks emotions or other emotional capacities, and so AI-generated empathy is less credible than human empathy ( 30 ; 52 ) . But the first main effect suggests a testable hypothesis about objectively measurable behavior: LLMs produce language that is higher empathic quality than those produced by people, and we should be able to identify patterns of language that support the subjective quality that people perceive in LLM-generated responses. This motivated the present focus on the language behaviors that support human perceptions of empathy. Other studies in non-empathy domains have found that LLM responses, especially for open-ended queries, lack content diversity ( 31 ) : They seem to generate repetitive phrases or overuse certain words within messages ( 58 ) , and produce responses that follow syntactic ( 62 ) and discourse ( 50 ) templates. The resulting language, therefore, can be regarded as “slop” ( 61 ) . The lack of diversity in AI-generated content can also negatively impact human creative ideation ( 1 ; 16 ; 21 ) , and consistent exposure to low quality, repetitive content may put users at risk of negative emotional and cognitive consequences ( 51 ) . Based on these findings, we expect to see similar findings when LLMs are prompted to produce emotionally supportive messages: they produce templated responses that are much more homogeneous compared to human-generated messages. In this paper, we first introduce a taxonomy of ten empathic response “tactics” that are explicitly designed to be identifiable in text—for instance, phrases that validate the other’s person feelings (validation); disclose a similar experience that the empathizer had gone through (self-disclosure); or offering advice. The focus on identifying objective behaviors is in contrast to previous studies that relied only on subjective reports of perceived empathy of a response ( 53 ; 77 ) , or asking human raters to read a response and rate if the response writer used a specific strategy (e.g., Study 2 from 79 ). Our fine-grained, text-level tactics taxonomy also differs from prior work in computationally modeling empathy, such as 65 ’s broad categories of “Emotional Reactions”, “Explorations”, and “Interpretations”; 70 ’s seven category taxonomy of perceptions of AI empathy; and 29 ’s five categories for benchmarking AI-generated empathy. These, and other previous frameworks ( 26 ; 35 ) , are all broader and more abstract characterizations of empathy that capture various aspects of empathic behavior—for instance, an empathic agent shows perspective taking, or contextual understanding ( 70 ; 29 ) . Our taxonomy complements these previous frameworks by identifying specific ways that these constructs are expressed in language. Perhaps the closest work are previous computational work that have tried to

Read the complete text