Planetesimal-Driven Instabilities in Resonant Chains of Cold Neptunes and Their Dynamical Outcomes astropy ( 4 ; 2 ; 3 ) , colorcet ( 49 ; 7 ) , labellines ( 10 ) , matplotlib ( 45 ) , numpy ( 38 ) , REBOUND ( 82 ) , REBOUNDx ( 87 )
Ryan LoRusso, Cristobal Petrovich, Hareesh Bhaskar · 2026
Read Planetesimal-Driven Instabilities in Resonant Chains of Cold Neptunes and Their Dynamical Outcomes astropy ( 4 ; 2 ; 3 ) , colorcet ( 49 ; 7 ) , labellines ( 10 ) , matplotlib ( 45 ) , numpy ( 38 ) , REBOUND ( 82 ) , REBOUNDx ( 87 ) by Ryan LoRusso, Cristobal Petrovich, Hareesh Bhaskar (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-08383.txt.
Introduction
LoRusso, Petrovich, and Bhaskar simulate chains of cold Neptune planets locked in orbital resonances and later stirred by leftover planetesimal discs. Discs holding about 1 to 4 percent of the planets' mass break the chains and spark system wide instability, sometimes long after the gas disc has gone. Planets then collide, break apart, or fly off, and many survivors get thrown inward, offering a natural route to hot Neptunes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ryan LoRusso, Cristobal Petrovich, Hareesh Bhaskar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 78254 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.08383
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Planetesimal-Driven Instabilities in Resonant Chains of Cold Neptunes and Their Dynamical Outcomes astropy ( 4 ; 2 ; 3 ) , colorcet ( 49 ; 7 ) , labellines ( 10 ) , matplotlib ( 45 ) , numpy ( 38 ) , REBOUND ( 82 ) , REBOUNDx ( 87 ) Ryan LoRusso, Cristobal Petrovich, Hareesh Bhaskar Abstract Cold Neptunes and sub-Neptunes are among the most common products of planet formation and likely dominate the angular-momentum budgets in most planetary systems; yet their dynamical impact on planetary architectures remains poorly understood. Using N-body simulations, we investigate the evolution of multi-Neptune systems assembled into resonant chains during the gas-disk phase and later coupled to remnant planetesimal disks. We show that planetesimal disks containing ≃ 1 \simeq 1 – 4 % 4\% of the planetary mass efficiently disrupt resonant chains and trigger global dynamical instabilities on timescales of 1 Myr 1\penalty\ \mathrm{Myr} – 1 Gyr 1\penalty\ \mathrm{Gyr} , providing a pathway for delayed instability long after gas-disk dispersal, albeit with instability timescales that are highly sensitive to disk mass. The ensuing instability drives large-scale orbital rearrangement and loss of planets through collisions, tidal disruption, and ejections. Notably, in most systems at least one planet is scattered inward to ∼ 0.1 au \sim 0.1\penalty\ \mathrm{au} on ∼ 10 \sim 10 – 100 100 Myr timescales (for ∼ 5 \sim 5 – 50 M ⊕ 50\;M_{\oplus} planets) following instability onset, with a substantial fraction undergoing tidal capture or disruption. This tidal capture can provide a natural pathway to hot Neptune formation, while compact inner chains, if present, would be destroyed on ∼ 100 Myr \sim 100\penalty\ \mathrm{Myr} timescales by cold sub-Neptunes, naturally explaining the observed decline in the resonant fraction. We argue that the predictions of our model, which yields mass-segregated planets and corresponding relative abundances of cold, wide-orbit, and free-floating planets, can be tested by ongoing and upcoming microlensing surveys. I Introduction I.1 The Dominance of Cold Neptunes Kepler revealed that planets with Neptune-like radii are far more abundant than Jupiter-size planets on orbits interior to \sim 1\;\mathrm{AU} ( 43 ) . Combined with radial-velocity measurements, these results imply that Neptune-like planets—here defined as planets with masses of \sim 10 – 30M_{\oplus} —are significantly more common than Jupiter-mass planets at these separations ( 94 ) . Radial-velocity surveys further suggest that this dominance likely extends to longer orbital periods ( 65 ) , although current constraints remain limited by sensitivity and observational biases. At wider separations ( a\sim a few au), gravitational microlensing provides the strongest constraints on Neptune-mass planets. Microlensing surveys consistently find that cold Neptunes are significantly more common than cold Jupiters ( 97 ) , reinforcing the conclusion that Neptune-mass planets dominate the intermediate-to-wide orbital regime. These results imply that while only \sim 10\% of Sun-like stars host cold Jupiters ( 25 ) , the majority of planetary systems may host cold Neptunes as their most massive planets. As a consequence, Neptune-mass planets may often control the angular-momentum budget of planetary systems and play a dominant role in shaping their long-term dynamical evolution. I.2 Observational Evidence for Dynamical Instabilities of Neptunes The large inferred population of free-floating Neptune-mass planets ( 85 ) suggests that dynamical scattering and ejection processes operate efficiently in planetary systems hosting Neptunes. While ejections are more readily produced by massive Jovian planets, the low occurrence rate of cold Jupiters implies that they cannot be the primary source of the observed free-floating population ( 25 ; 32 ) . Accounting for the inferred abundance of free-floating Neptunes using only Jupiter-mass perturbers would require an implausibly large number of ejections—on the order of \gtrsim 10 Neptune-mass planets per Jupiter-hosting system ( 32 ) . Given the high intrinsic occurrence rate of Neptune-mass planets, it is therefore natural to expect that Neptunes themselves frequently eject one another through mutual dynamical instabilities. Additional evidence for violent dynamical histories emerges from the short-period regime. Analogous to hot Jupiters, an emerging population of hot Neptunes with orbital periods of \sim 3 – 6 days has been identified ( 11 ) . These planets frequently exhibit large stellar obliquities ( 17 ) and, in some cases, residual eccentricities ( 41 ; 20 ) , pointing to a history of strong dynamical excitation followed by high-eccentricity tidal migration ( 18 ; 9 ) . The excitation of extreme eccentricities is typically attributed to massive outer companions—cold Jupiters or stellar companions. However, long-term radial-velocity monitoring rules out the presence of cold Jupiters in most hot Neptune systems ( 22 ; 37 ) . In contrast, Neptune-mass companions at wider separations often fall below current detection limits. Given the high intrinsic occurrence rate of Neptune-mass planets and the relative scarcity of cold Jupiters, Neptune–Neptune interactions provide a natural pathway for driving the dynamical excitation required for high-eccentricity migration. Taken together, these observations indicate that dynamical instabilities among Neptune-mass planets are likely common and may play a central role in shaping both bound and unbound Neptune populations. What physical processes initiate these instabilities, and on what timescales do they emerge following gas-disk dispersal? I.3 Planetesimal-Driven Migration and Delayed Instability During the gas-disk phase, interactions with the protoplanetary disk naturally drive orbital migration and eccentricity damping, frequently leading to capture into mean-motion resonances and the assembly of compact resonant chains ( 47 ; 31 ; 74 ) . Transit surveys support this picture, revealing a significant excess of multi-planet systems near orbital commensurabilities, as well as widespread transit-timing variations in young systems with ages of \sim 10 – 100\penalty\ \mathrm{Myr} ( 15 ; 59 ) . In contrast, among older systems the fraction of planets residing in resonant chains drops sharply, with fewer than \sim 10\% of systems remaining resonant. This decline indicates that most resonance chains are disrupted on timescales long after the gas disk has dispersed, yet the physical mechanism responsible for this delayed resonance breaking remains uncertain ( 56 ) . A natural candidate for driving this evolution is a remnant planetesimal disk. Planetesimal populations are expected to be common, as suggested by the high incidence of debris disks, particularly around young stars ( 67 ; 66 ) . Gravitational scattering and ejection of planetesimals exchange angular momentum with planets, producing planetesimal-driven migration. In two-planet systems, this process is known to generate divergent migration and resonance breaking ( 13 ; 27 ; 96 ) . How planetesimal-driven migration operates in higher-multiplicity systems of cold Neptunes---beginning from disk-assembled resonant chains---remains largely unexplored 1 1 1 Only recently, 33 and 14 explored resonance chain breaking by planetesimal disks, focused on short-period planets. . In such systems, collective interactions can amplify small perturbations, potentially triggering large-scale dynamical instabilities ( 79 ; 46 ; 29 ) . I.4 Consequences of Instabilities The dynamical outcomes of planetary instabilities depend sensitively on the Safronov number 2 2 2 Here the parabolic Safronov number is used, where the relative velocity between bodies is approximately the Keplerian v_{orb} . See also 91 pages 442 & 454. , \Theta=\frac{v_{\rm esc}^{2}}{2v_{\rm orb}^{2}}, (1) which measures the relative importance of gravitational scattering compared to physical collisions. In systems dominated by cold Jupiters ( \Theta\gg 1 ), close encounters typically lead