Bulk versus interface nucleation of CO 2 hydrates from computer simulations
Joanna Grabowska*, Samuel Blazquez, Carlos Vega, Eduardo Sanz ∗ · 2026
Read Bulk versus interface nucleation of CO 2 hydrates from computer simulations by Joanna Grabowska*, Samuel Blazquez, Carlos Vega, Eduardo Sanz ∗ (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-08187.txt.
Introduction
Grabowska and three colleagues study bulk versus interface growth of carbon dioxide solids through computer simulations. Gas hydrates matter greatly for oil work and nature. Knowing how these solids form from watery mixes is key to steering their growth. Tests have often hinted hydrate growth starts where water meets the guest-gas supply. To test this idea, the team runs atom-scale dynamics simulations of carbon dioxide nucleation. First, they set hydrate seeds at varied spots near the interface and watch them evolve, finding bulk-buried seeds abler to grow.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joanna Grabowska*, Samuel Blazquez, Carlos Vega, Eduardo Sanz ∗ |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49413 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.08187
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bulk versus interface nucleation of CO 2 hydrates from computer simulations Joanna Grabowska*, Samuel Blazquez, Carlos Vega, Eduardo Sanz ∗ Abstract Abstract Gas hydrates are of great relevance to both the oil industry and the environment. Understanding how these solid structures nucleate from aqueous solutions is essential to controlling their formation. Experimental studies have often suggested that hydrate nucleation originates at the interface between the aqueous phase and the guest-molecule reservoir. To assess this hypothesis, we perform molecular dynamics simulations of CO 2 hydrate nucleation. First, we place hydrate seeds at different positions relative to the interface and monitor their evolution, finding that seeds embedded in the bulk are more likely to grow than those located near or at the interface. Second, we analyse spontaneous nucleation simulations with and without an interface. Our previous work showed that nucleation rates are indistinguishable in both systems, strongly indicating that the interface does not play a role. Here, trajectory analysis reveals that hydrates nucleate in regions of locally high CO 2 concentration, which arise spontaneously in the bulk and are not associated with the interface. Our results indicate that hydrate nucleation does not preferentially occur at the interface, at least at the at deep supercooling conditions explored in this work. Further work at higher temperatures, and considering alternative nucleation locations, is needed to reconcile experiments and simulations, and thereby reach a deep understanding of the mechanism of hydrate formation. ∗ Corresponding authors: J. Grabowska: [email protected], E. Sanz: [email protected] I Introduction Clathrate hydrates are crystalline structures in which gas molecules are trapped within cages of water molecules. Sloan and Koh 2008 Methane hydrates are primarily found in deep-sea sediments and permafrost regions, and serve as a substantial reservoir of methane and other fuel molecules. In addition to their potential as an energy source, gas hydrates offer a promising avenue for carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) sequestration, as CO 2 could replace methane within hydrate structures, Hirohama et al. 1996 ; Park et al. 2006 ; Lee et al. 2003 ; Lee et al. 2013 providing a dual benefit of reducing greenhouse gas emissions while facilitating methane extraction. Hydrogen hydrates are also important because they offer a potential method for safe and compact storage of hydrogen, supporting the transition to cleaner energy sources. Methane hydrates, however, pose significant challenges for the oil and gas industry, particularly due to their tendency to form blockages in pipelines during hydrocarbon production and transportation, leading to operational inefficiencies and safety risks. Sloan 2021 It is thereby crucial to characterise and understand the formation and stability of hydrates. Numerous experimental studies Lekvam and Ruoff 1993 ; Devarakonda, Groysman, and Myerson 1999 ; Takeya et al. 2000 ; Herri et al. 2004 ; Abay and Svartaas 2010 ; Jensen, Thomsen, and von Solms 2018 ; Maeda 2018 ; Maeda and d. Shen 2019 ; Liang et al. 2019 have been conducted to better understand the formation, growth and dissociation of gas hydrates under various thermodynamic and kinetic conditions. Researchers have investigated the effects of temperature, pressure, gas composition and the presence of inhibitors or promoters on hydrate crystallization and stability. There seems to be compelling experimental evidence that hydrates nucleate at the interface between the solution and the hydrate former reservoir. Maeda 2015 ; Stoporev et al. 2018 ; Sloan and Koh 2008 ; Adamova, Stoporev, and Manakov 2018 ; Li et al. 2024 ; Jeong et al. 2022 ; Maeda 2015 ; Sloan Jr and Koh 2007 This is a likely scenario given that the solubility of hydrate former molecules (CO 2 , CH 4 , H 2 S etc.) in water is typically much lower than the proportion of gas former molecules in the solid hydrate, which is 1 molecule per 5.75 water molecules in a perfect sI hydrate lattice. Thus, it appears reasonable that only in the vicinity of the interface there is enough hydrate former concentration to nucleate the hydrate. Experimental techniques, however, do not enable a direct visualization of the first hydrate embryo that nucleates from a disordered molecular arrangement, given its nanoscopic size and its short lifespan. A theoretical approach is very useful for understanding and rationalizing the competition between homogeneous and interfacial nucleation; however, the values of the relevant parameters that enter the theoretical description require experimental validation, and the theory does not provide a molecular-level representation of the nucleation process. Kashchiev and Firoozabadi 2002 Molecular simulations can help bridge the gap in our understanding of nucleation at a molecular scale, Báez and Clancy 1994 ; Rodger, Forester, and Smith 1996 ; Alavi, Ripmeester, and Klug 2005 ; Alavi, Ripmeester, and Klug 2006 ; Walsh et al. 2009 ; English and Tse 2009 ; Walsh et al. 2011 ; Sarupria and Debenedetti 2012 ; Knott et al. 2012 ; Liang and Kusalik 2013 ; Barnes et al. 2014a ; Yuhara et al. 2015 ; Zhang et al. 2016 ; Lauricella et al. 2016 ; Arjun, Berendsen, and Bolhuis 2019 ; Arjun and Bolhuis 2020 ; Arjun and Bolhuis 2021 ; Arjun and Bolhuis 2023 ; Liang and Kusalik 2013 ; Zhang, Kusalik, and Guo 2018 ; Zhang et al. 2020 ; Wang and Sadus 2003 ; Jiménez-Ángeles and Firoozabadi 2014 ; Jiménez-Ángeles and Firoozabadi 2018 ; cai Zhang et al. 2022 ; Tanaka, Matsumoto, and Yagasaki 2023 ; Tanaka, Matsumoto, and Yagasaki 2024 particularly so with the emergence of realistic water models that have proven to be highly accurate in predicting the equilibrium behaviour of real hydrates. Conde and Vega 2010 ; Míguez et al. 2015 ; Blazquez et al. 2024 ; Algaba et al. 2024 ; Waage, Vlugt, and Kjelstrup 2017 Most simulation studies of hydrate nucleation, however, focus on the homogeneous nucleation of the hydrate in the bulk aqueous solution Knott et al. 2012 ; Yuhara et al. 2015 ; Grabowska et al. 2023 ; Zerón et al. 2025 ; Arjun and Bolhuis 2020 ; Arjun and Bolhuis 2021 ; Li et al. 2020 ; Walsh et al. 2009 ; Sarupria and Debenedetti 2012 (in many cases with a guest molecule concentration way higher than the saturation concentration to enhance the nucleation rate) and the hypothetical location of the nucleus at the interface has not been properly assessed. Some clues regarding the location of hydrate nucleation can be found in Refs. Jacobson, Hujo, and Molinero 2010 and Zhang et al. 2025 . In Ref. Jacobson, Hujo, and Molinero 2010 , focused on unveiling the molecular path leading to the formation of hydrates (blobs of guest molecules give rise to hydrate nuclei), it was mentioned that nuclei can indistinctly appear in the bulk or at the interface. According to Ref. Zhang et al. 2025 , in contrast, nucleation in the bulk is not considered as a possibility (it either takes place at the interface with the hydrate-former rich phase or with a solid substrate at low and high temperatures respectively). The fact that homogeneous nucleation cannot compete with nucleation at the interface is inconsistent with our recent simulation study. Zerón et al. 2025 In Ref. Zerón et al. 2025 we conducted simulations of spontaneous CO 2 hydrate nucleation from a bulk CO 2 saturated solution and from a CO 2 saturated solution in