Differentially Private Modeling of Disease Transmission within Human Contact Networks

Shlomi Hod, Debanuj Nayak ∗, Jason R. Gantenberg, Iden Kalemaj, Thomas A. Trikalinos, Adam Smith · 2026

Read Differentially Private Modeling of Disease Transmission within Human Contact Networks by Shlomi Hod, Debanuj Nayak ∗, Jason R. Gantenberg, Iden Kalemaj, Thomas A. Trikalinos, Adam Smith (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-07493.txt.

Introduction

Hod and five colleagues build a safe pipeline for tracking disease spread on sensitive contact networks. Contact data can expose sexual relationships or drug use, so summaries are computed under node-level differential privacy. A statistical network model fitted to those summaries makes synthetic networks for agent-based spread simulation. Tests on ARTNet sexual-network data show privacy noise is small beside sampling and model error, so curators can share useful epidemic insights while protecting people.

Catalog record

CREATORShlomi Hod, Debanuj Nayak ∗, Jason R. Gantenberg, Iden Kalemaj, Thomas A. Trikalinos, Adam Smith
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93596
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.07493

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Differentially Private Modeling of Disease Transmission within Human Contact Networks Shlomi Hod, Debanuj Nayak ∗, Jason R. Gantenberg, Iden Kalemaj, Thomas A. Trikalinos, Adam Smith Abstract Epidemiologic studies of infectious diseases often rely on models of contact networks to capture the complex interactions that govern disease spread, and ongoing projects aim to vastly increase the scale at which such data can be collected. However, contact networks may include sensitive information, such as sexual relationships or drug use behavior. Protecting individual privacy while maintaining the scientific usefulness of the data is crucial. We propose a privacy-preserving pipeline for disease spread simulation studies based on a sensitive network that integrates differential privacy (DP) with statistical network models such as stochastic block models (SBMs) and exponential random graph models (ERGMs). Our pipeline comprises three steps: (1) compute network summary statistics using node-level DP (which corresponds to protecting individuals’ contributions); (2) fit a statistical model, such as an ERGM, using these summaries, which allows generating synthetic networks reflecting the structure of the original network; and (3) simulate disease spread on the synthetic networks using an agent-based model. We evaluate the effectiveness of our approach using a simple Susceptible-Infected-Susceptible (SIS) disease model under multiple configurations. We compare both numerical results, such as simulated disease incidence and prevalence, as well as qualitative conclusions such as intervention effect size, on networks generated with and without differential privacy constraints. Our experiments are based on egocentric sexual network data from the ARTNet study (a survey about HIV-related behaviors). Our results show that the noise added for privacy is small relative to the other sources of error (sampling and model misspecification, for example). This suggests that, in principle, curators of such sensitive data can provide valuable epidemiologic insights while protecting privacy. 1 Introduction Simulation models of infectious disease transmission are important tools for developing causal explanations [ 29 , 2 ] and public health responses to both endemic and epidemic pathogens [ 64 , 69 ] . For many pathogens, the structures of human contacts act as the substrate through which the pathogen propagates, governing transmission dynamics [ 59 , 60 ] and epidemic potential [ 5 ] . For this reason, epidemiologic models (e.g., network agent-based models [ 50 ] ) often incorporate detailed information about human contact networks as a means to simulate realistic transmission scenarios. Information on individuals and their relationships (connections) is naturally modeled as a a graph (hereon, network graph or network ), where nodes represent individuals and edges the relationships between them [ 50 , 76 , 89 ] . In infectious disease modeling, edges represent relationships relevant to transmission. For instance, edges in a model of HIV or sexually transmitted disease may represent sexual [ 33 , 47 , 7 ] or injection drug use partnerships [ 91 ] , whereas in a model for influenza edges may represent sufficient conditions for transmission based on physical proximity [ 74 , 71 ] . The detailed network data poses risks to privacy [ 52 ] . Study participants who provide data on disease status or illegal behavior risk re-identification, with potentially grave social or legal consequences [ 63 ] . This risk is not limited to the release of individual-level information [ 52 , 8 , 79 ] and may be incurred even when researchers present data summaries, including network summary statistics [ 27 ] . Such summaries could (indirectly) reveal information about an individual’s presence in the dataset. Simply knowing an individual’s position in a network—for example, a person that represents the sole connection between two otherwise isolated groups of individuals [ 89 ] —could reveal information about this person’s identity. Given the extent to which network structures govern transmission dynamics, we suspect that even summary outputs from infectious disease simulations could reveal information that increases the risk of privacy violation, possibly in combination with external information or other summaries derived from the same data. That is, stochastic epidemic simulations may not be inherently privacy-preserving. Differential privacy [ 25 ] (DP) is a widely studied and deployed formal privacy guarantee for data analysis. We say that an algorithm or a statical analysis is differentially private if the probability distribution of its output looks nearly indistinguishable for any two input datasets that differ only in the data of a single individual. In other words, a DP algorithm is robust to changing an individual record in the dataset. A common building block in constructing a differentially private version of a statistical query, such as count and median, is to add calibrated noise that masks the contribution of an individual data point while still providing sufficiently accurate results. In the context of databases representing human contact networks, where nodes represent individuals, the change of one person’s data amounts to changing their connections in the network, and possibly all of them. This concept is captured by node differential privacy ( Definition B.3 ) (or, more concisely node-DP) [ 39 ] where the indistinguishability guarantee applies to two networks which can differ on one node (individual) and all its edges (connections). The current work focuses on node-DP given that we aim to protect all of the information pertaining to one individual in a human contact network. In order to support the responsible collection, use, and sharing of these growing network datasets for epidemic simulations, we present and evaluate in this paper a pipeline to analyze such networks through node-DP algorithms. In our pipeline, illustrated in Figure 1 , a differentially private algorithm produces network summaries that are released and subsequently used to generate synthetic networks in which epidemics are simulated. The input data is a network, possibly with additional attributes for nodes such as age and race. The final outputs typically include statistics on these simulations, such as the effect of an intervention on a disease’s prevalence. Our core research question in this work is whether a differentially private synthetic network, which provides rigorous privacy constraints, can yield accurate estimation of epidemic simulation outcomes. That is, whether DP synthetic networks can match the accuracy of both simulations on the original network and non-private synthetic networks commonly used in epidemic research. 1.1 Summary of Contributions (1) A privacy-preserving pipeline for epidemic simulation. We design and implement a pipeline ( Section 2 ) that enables epidemiologists to perform disease spread simulations on sensitive network data while satisfying node-level differential privacy guarantees. (2) A comprehensive evaluation framework. We designed an experimental framework ( Section 3 ) to systematically assess the pipeline across multiple dimensions, including network modeling choices, population-level and subgroup-level epidemic statistics, and various sources of variance. This enables studying the effect of DP noise in comparison to other error sources such as modeling, simulation, and network sampling. (3) Empirical findings on sources of error and variance. Through extensive experiments on realistic network data, we demonstrate that ( Section 4 ): 1. Network model misspecification, when present, dominates all other sources of bias and is unrelated to differential privacy ( Section 4.1 ); 2. Introducing differential privacy has a limited impact on epidemic analysis accuracy for reasonable parameter choices ( Section 4.2 ); 3. Accurate epidemic statistics are maintained at the granular subgroup level when network models are correctly specified

Read the complete text