Can Locality, Unitarity, and Hidden Zeros Completely Determine Tree-Level Amplitudes?

Kang Zhou · 2026

Read Can Locality, Unitarity, and Hidden Zeros Completely Determine Tree-Level Amplitudes? by Kang Zhou (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-07195.txt.

Introduction

Zhou asks whether three principles alone can pin down tree-level scattering amplitudes in particle physics. He rebuilds the single-soft rules for Yang-Mills amplitudes and the double-soft rules for nonlinear sigma model amplitudes from locality, unitarity, and newly found hidden zeros. Earlier work shows full amplitudes follow from those soft rules. He therefore concludes that the three principles fully determine the tree-level amplitudes in both theories.

Catalog record

CREATORKang Zhou
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69656
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.07195

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Can Locality, Unitarity, and Hidden Zeros Completely Determine Tree-Level Amplitudes? Kang Zhou Abstract In this note, we address the question of whether locality, unitarity, and newly discovered hidden zeros can completely determine tree-level amplitudes, from the perspective of soft limit. We reconstruct the single-soft theorems of tree YM amplitudes and the double-soft theorems of tree NLSM amplitudes from locality, unitarity, and hidden zeros. A series of studies have shown that the full YM and NLSM amplitudes can be constructed from these soft theorems; therefore, we conclude that locality, unitarity, and hidden zeros completely determine the tree-level YM and NLSM amplitudes. 1 Introduction In the modern study of scattering amplitudes, a milestone idea is to directly construct amplitudes based on physical criteria, without relying on traditional Lagrangians or Feynman rules. A paradigmatic example is the BCFW on-shell recursion relation at tree-level Britto:2004ap ; Britto:2005fq . This approach, rooted in locality and unitarity, recursively constructs tree-level amplitudes through the factorization behavior of residues at physical poles. However, relying solely on factorization at poles is usually insufficient to construct the complete amplitude. For instance, when applying the BCFW method to Yang-Mills (YM) amplitudes, one relies on gauge invariance to ensure that the boundary terms can be avoided by choosing appropriate BCFW-deformations Arkani-Hamed:2008bsc . This indicates that the foundation underlying the on-shell calculation of tree YM amplitudes is that locality, unitarity, together with gauge invariance, completely determine the amplitude. There is also another scenario where, although boundary terms cannot be avoided, the on-shell method can be generalized by incorporating new criteria. For example, combining the BCFW method with the Adler zero leads to new recursion relations applicable to a class of effective field theories, exemplified by the nonlinear sigma model (NLSM) Cheung:2015ota . Evidently, the foundation underlying this new approach is that locality, unitarity, together with the Adler zero, completely determine the amplitudes. From the above discussion, it is evident that obtaining new on-shell methods that do not rely on Lagrangians or Feynman rules requires specifying a minimal set of criteria sufficient to determine the amplitudes. More precisely, we need a set \{ locality, unitarity, X\} . For YM amplitudes, X is gauge invariance; for NLSM amplitudes, X is the Adler zero. However, a less satisfactory aspect emerging from the above two examples is that each physical model appears to require its own specific X . Thus, a natural question arises: does there exist a universal X that applies to a broad class of models? The hidden zeros of tree-level amplitudes, discovered recently, hold promise for answering the above question. In Arkani-Hamed:2023swr , the authors found that when the kinematic variables of external particles satisfy certain constraints, the tree-level amplitudes for {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) , NLSM, and YM theories vanish. This behavior is referred to as hidden zeros. In subsequent works, hidden zeros were extended to the tree-level amplitudes of a broader range of physical models, including Einstein gravity (GR), Dirac-Born-Infeld, special Galileon, as well as Yang-Mills and GR amplitudes with specific higher derivative corrections Rodina:2024yfc ; Bartsch:2024amu ; Li:2024qfp ; Zhang:2024efe ; Huang:2025blb ; Zhou:2025tvq . The zeros of loop-level Feynman integrands have also been investigated accordingly Backus:2025hpn . Prior to this, the study of zeros of amplitudes had been far less extensive and in-depth than that of poles. The aforementioned developments have partially filled this gap. Since the hidden zero is a novel analytic property distinct from the factorization at poles, one may naturally ask that whether hidden zeros could serve as the X in the set \{ locality, unitarity, X\} . If the answer is affirmative, then we obtain a universal X that covers a wide range of models. The most direct approach to addressing this question is to establish an effective method based on locality, unitarity, and hidden zeros, capable of computing amplitudes. However, this is not an easy task. In previous work Li:2025suo , we combined the BCFW approach with hidden zeros and developed an on-shell recursive method applicable to NLSM amplitudes. Unfortunately, this method is too specific, and at present, it is entirely unclear how to extend it to other models such as YM. Given the above difficulty, in this note we approach the question of whether hidden zeros can play the role of X from another, less direct perspective. Various research in the area of scattering amplitudes has shown that a large variety of tree amplitudes can be completely determined by their behavior in the soft limit Elvang:2018dco ; Nguyen:2009jk ; Boucher-Veronneau:2011rwd ; Rodina:2018pcb ; Ma:2022qja ; Luo:2015tat ; Zhou:2022orv ; Du:2024dwm ; Zhou:2024qjh ; Zhou:2024qwm ; Wei:2023yfy ; Hu:2023lso . Therefore, we can investigate whether locality, unitarity, together with hidden zeros, can fully determine such soft behaviors. The answer to this new question will directly reveal whether hidden zeros can serve as a universal X . Therefore, in this note, we construct the soft behaviors of YM and NLSM amplitudes based on locality, unitarity, and hidden zeros. More specifically, for YM, we construct the single-soft behavior obtained by taking the soft limit of a single gluon; for NLSM, we construct the double-soft behavior obtained by taking the simultaneous soft limit of two pions. We determine the parts of the soft behavior that contain specific poles through factorization at these poles, as dictated by locality and unitarity, and then probe the parts without such poles using hidden zeros. In the absence of any known theorem-such as one stating that locality, unitarity, together with hidden zeros, completely determine the amplitude-we cannot logically guarantee that the soft behavior constructed through the above approach is complete. Nevertheless, we can compare the results obtained from the above approach with known soft theorems. Since the soft limit behaviors of the YM and NLSM amplitudes obtained through the above method exactly match the known standard soft theorems, we conclude that locality, unitarity, and hidden zeros completely determine the YM and NLSM amplitudes. Near each hidden zero, there exists a novel factorization behavior known as the 2 -split Cao:2024gln ; Cao:2024qpp ; Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd ; Guevara:2024nxd ; Zhou:2024ddy ; Feng:2025ofq ; Feng:2025dci ; Cao:2025hio ; Zhang:2025zjx ; Zhang:2026dcm . In previous work Zhou:2025xly , we combined the traditional factorization at poles with the new factorization near zeros to construct the soft behaviors of amplitudes. It is therefore worthwhile to compare the method developed in this note with that previous approach. Since each 2 -split gives rise to two off-shell currents, constructing soft behavior via 2 -splits cannot rely solely on on-shell information; in contrast, the property of the hidden zero is entirely on-shell. Therefore, the construction of soft behavior presented in this note is significantly more convenient. Moreover, from the perspective of constructing amplitudes, the set \{ locality, unitarity, hidden zeros \} is clearly more advantageous than the set \{ locality, unitarity, 2 -splits \} . The reason is again that employing 2 -splits confronts one with off-shell currents, which, due to being off-shell, also cause a host of complexities such as dependence on the choice of gauge. The remainder of this note is organized as follows. In section 2 , we review the hidden zeros of tree YM and NLSM amplitudes. In section 3 , we construct the single-soft theorems of tree YM amplitudes at

Read the complete text