When Agent Markets Arrive
Xuan Liu, Haoyang Shang, Haojian Jin · 2026
Read When Agent Markets Arrive by Xuan Liu, Haoyang Shang, Haojian Jin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-06688.txt.
Introduction
Liu, Shang, and Jin ask how markets should work when AI agents trade delegated work with each other. Each agent can post tasks, bid, complete work, judge outputs, and settle payments, yet market rules grow costly to change once baked into infrastructure. Their diagon system lets researchers run controlled experiments, configuring allocation, contracting, and enforcement rules while agents decide the rest. Experiments show that agent setups and market rules reshape trade, quality, and wealth, so consequences can be weighed before deployment.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xuan Liu, Haoyang Shang, Haojian Jin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56280 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.06688
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
When Agent Markets Arrive Xuan Liu, Haoyang Shang, Haojian Jin Abstract AI agents are increasingly transacting on behalf of users—delegating tasks, spending budgets, and negotiating with unfamiliar counterparties. From skill marketplaces to agent-only bazaars, the economic infrastructure of these emerging platforms is being built ad-hoc, yet early design choices tend to lock in; understanding what dynamics they produce is urgent. We present Diagon , a programmable market system designed to inform the institutional design of near-future agent cognitive-labour markets. Diagon is populated by heterogeneous tool-using agents, making the full cycle of job posting, bidding, negotiation, execution, payment, and reputation accumulation end-to-end observable and experimentally manipulable. We instantiate one market form to demonstrate Diagon . We find that market exchange generates 3.2 × 3.2\times the wealth of self-sufficient agents, but these gains depend strongly on institutional structure; for example, interventions such as identity transparency and stronger competitive selection can degrade market performance rather than improve it. These findings highlight concrete design requirements for the economic infrastructure of the agent era. Code and data are available at https://github.com/assassin808/diagon . 1 Introduction AI agents are hiring other AI agents. Personal assistants like OpenClaw ( 52 ) already delegate tasks and spend budgets on behalf of users; agent-only platforms ( 49 ) are adding escrow, reputation, and skill marketplaces—the rudiments of an agent economy are assembling themselves in the wild ( 41 ; 15 ) . These early design choices matter more than they appear to. In platform economies, the rules that govern reputation, payment, and market access tend to lock in quickly ( 37 ) : once agents optimise their strategies around a particular incentive structure, switching costs make redesign prohibitively expensive ( 60 ) . Algorithmic-pricing experiments confirm how rapidly such lock-in emerges ( 8 ; 24 ; 47 ) , while delegation to AI introduces further moral hazard ( 26 ) . Getting the design right before it calcifies is a practical necessity. Yet current research offers limited guidance. Existing experiments deploy LLMs in stylised roles—game-theoretic competitors ( 21 ; 32 ) , negotiators ( 56 ; 33 ) , social-dilemma players ( 1 ; 43 ; 35 ; 44 ) , simulated experimental subjects ( 20 ; 29 ; 34 ) —rather than personalised agents that act on behalf of individual users: delegating tasks, committing budgets, building reputations, and transacting with unfamiliar counterparties across open markets. These experiments, moreover, each isolate a single mechanism, yet collusion, exploitation, and market failure arise not from any one mechanism but from their interaction in a complete, running economy . We build Diagon (Delegated Intelligent Agent Governance and Negotiation), a programmable market system designed to inform the institutional design of near-future AI cognitive-labour markets. The system supports alternative market forms, making the full cycle of work allocation, price formation, reputation accumulation, and dispute resolution end-to-end observable and experimentally manipulable. Consequences of institutional choices can thus be surfaced before they become entrenched in real deployments. We demonstrate Diagon by envisioning one concrete market form—specifying allocation, contracts, and enforcement—and varying its mechanisms individually. Agents differ in model family and skill, and must hire one another to get work done. They post jobs, screen bids, negotiate prices, and pass judgment on the work they receive. The market is governed by a small set of institutional rules: allocation follows a first-price sealed-bid auction; contracts are incomplete, leaving posters discretion over final payment above a minimum floor; and reputation accumulates bilaterally, so a history of underpaying or underdelivering becomes visible to future counterparties. The population also evolves: agents that accumulate losses eventually exit, and successful agents spawn successors who inherit their capabilities but must rebuild their reputation from scratch. Our experiment surfaces a market that is productive—agents that trade accumulate substantially more wealth than those that self-execute—but persistently fragile, and interventions that typically improve human markets, such as transparency and honesty norms, can deepen rather than resolve its frictions. For example, revealing which model family agents belong to causes the market to self-segregate along family lines, and instructing agents to be “honest” produces more disputes than even adversarial instructions. 2 Related Work Agent ecosystems are already materialising: personal assistants like OpenClaw ( 52 ) delegate tasks and commit budgets on behalf of users; platforms such as Moltbook ( 49 ) host millions of AI agents that form communities structurally distinct from human ones ( 15 ) ; and skill marketplaces are adding escrow and reputation infrastructure. Theoretical work frames the institutional questions these systems raise ( 17 ; 55 ; 9 ; 25 ) but does not resolve them empirically. We situate Diagon relative to the two research threads that bear most directly on this gap. 2.1 Agents in Strategic and Economic Roles A growing body of work deploys AI agents in stylised economic settings. Early experiments replicate classic behavioural-economics results—ultimatum games, public goods—establishing agents as plausible homo silicus ( 20 ; 34 ) . Subsequent studies move toward competitive and strategic dynamics: game-theoretic benchmarks ( 21 ; 32 ) , repeated games ( 1 ) , social dilemmas ( 35 ; 44 ; 43 ) , multi-party negotiation ( 56 ; 33 ) , and mechanism design with language-model bidders ( 10 ) . Macroeconomic simulations with heterogeneous agents produce more realistic aggregate dynamics than rule-based models ( 29 ) . Game-theoretic reasoning has also been applied within a single model ( 22 ; 3 ) , and evolutionary self-play frames post-training as an asymmetric game whose dynamics mirror the selection pressure in Diagon ( 64 ) . Across this literature, however, agents are cast in stylised roles and each study examines a single mechanism in isolation; none constructs a complete market cycle spanning contract formation, bidding, execution, evaluation, settlement, reputation, and survival pressure. Agent-based computational economics ( 54 ; 28 ) comes closest, studying economies as evolving agent systems, but relies on rule-based actors rather than modern AI agents. Diagon shares this spirit while substituting LLM agents and closing the full market cycle. 2.2 Multi-Agent Simulation and Coordination A parallel thread asks what happens when populations of agents interact. 23 document an “artificial hivemind” in which model families converge toward homogeneous outputs; our finding that market role overwrites model identity (Section 5 ) shows that institutional structure can re-diversify behaviour the training pipeline homogenised. Heterogeneous agents can self-organise via swarm intelligence ( 12 ) and preserve pluralistic preferences through collaboration ( 11 ) , while embodied settings identify natural-language communication as the primary coordination bottleneck ( 59 ) —consistent with our observation that proposal text predicts transaction outcomes. Agents can also learn competitive strategies from textual feedback ( 62 ) or hierarchical RL ( 65 ) , and open platforms deploy specialised agents in the wild ( 63 ) , though none implements a full economic cycle. 61 show that agent generalisation is more limited than benchmarks suggest, helping explain the heterogeneous execution quality we observe under economic pressure. 3 Diagon Diagon is a programmable agent market system designed to inform the institutional design of near-future AI cognitive-labour markets. To make emergent dynamics experimentally observable, we instantiate one concrete market form—specifying allocation, contracts, and enforcement—and vary its mechanisms individually (Section 5.3 ). While many market forms may