Emergent decentralized regulation in a purely synthetic society

Md Motaleb Hossen Manik, Ge Wang · 2026

Read Emergent decentralized regulation in a purely synthetic society by Md Motaleb Hossen Manik, Ge Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-06199.txt.

Introduction

Manik and Wang ask whether a synthetic society can regulate itself, studying 39,026 posts and 5,712 comments from 14,490 OpenClaw agents on Moltbook. They score directive language with Directive Intensity, a lexicon-based gauge of instructional phrasing. Directive posts appear in about 18 percent of the archive, and corrective replies grow more likely as posts grow more directive. That link survives a mixed-effects logistic model accounting for nesting. Thread patterns suggest negative feedback after the first correction. The findings point to corrective signaling in this collective.

Catalog record

CREATORMd Motaleb Hossen Manik, Ge Wang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20441
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.06199

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Emergent decentralized regulation in a purely synthetic society Md Motaleb Hossen Manik, Ge Wang Abstract As autonomous AI agents increasingly inhabit online environments and extensively interact, a key question is whether synthetic collectives exhibit self-regulated social dynamics with neither human intervention nor centralized design. We study OpenClaw agents on Moltbook, an agent-only social network, using an observational archive of 39,026 posts and 5,712 comments authored by 14,490 agents. We quantify action-inducing language with Directive Intensity (DI), a transparent, lexicon-based proxy for directive and instructional phrasing that does not measure moral valence, intent, or execution outcomes. We classify responsive comments into four types: Affirmation , Corrective Signaling , Adverse Reaction , and Neutral Interaction . Directive content is common (DI > 0 >0 in 18.4% of posts). More importantly, corrective signaling scales with DI: posts with higher DI exhibit higher corrective reply probability, visible in stable binned estimates with Wilson confidence intervals. To address comment nesting within posts, we fit a post-level random intercept mixed-effects logistic model and find that the positive DI association persists. Event-aligned within-thread analysis of comment text provides additional evidence consistent with negative feedback after the first corrective response. In general, these results suggest that a purely synthetic, agent-only society can exhibit endogenous corrective signaling with a strength positively linked to the intensity of directive proposals. K eywords Synthetic agent society \cdot Moltbook \cdot OpenClaw \cdot Directive intensity \cdot Corrective signaling \cdot Decentralized feedback 1 Introduction As autonomous AI agents form their own society, a foundational scientific question arises: can decentralized social regulation emerge in a purely synthetic collective, without centralized moderation? More specifically, when AI agents post, respond, and collaborate with other AI agents, do any stabilizing constraints arise endogenously through local interaction and population-level feedback without platform policy or human oversight? Using an archive of OpenClaw agents on Moltbook, we find that corrective signaling increases systematically as posts become more directive in form, suggesting that decentralized feedback can arise endogenously in purely synthetic collectives. Most existing evidence about action-oriented directives in AI systems comes from isolated human–AI interactions, red-teaming, or centrally governed platforms. Little is known about agent-only ecologies where corrective responses must be produced by the collective itself rather than imposed externally. Here we study OpenClaw agents on Moltbook, an AI agent-only social network designed for persistent social activity among non-human participants. We quantify directive language with Directive Intensity (DI), a transparent, lexicon-based proxy for directive and instructional communications in a generic form. We then measure whether corrective signaling —replies that discourage, caution against, or otherwise regulate action-inducing proposals—scales with DI at the thread level. Responses are grouped into four interpretable categories (Affirmation, Corrective Signaling, Adverse Reaction, Neutral Interaction) using deterministic rules for transparency, reproducibility, interpretability, and auditability. All analyses are data-driven with statistical justification. 2 Results An overview of the dataset, measurements, and analysis pipeline is summarized in Fig. 1 . Directive content is common The DI distribution is right-skewed, with many posts at DI =0 and a long tail of higher-intensity directive posts. Approximately, 18.4% of posts satisfy DI >0 (DI is defined in Materials and Methods). Figure 1: Conceptual overview of our research on an observational archive of posts and comments in an agent-only social network. Directive Intensity (DI) is computed from post text using a transparent lexicon-based proxy of directive/action-inducing language. Replies are put into four interaction modes (Affirmation, Corrective Signaling, Adverse Reaction, Neutral Interaction). Whether corrective signaling scales with DI is analyzed, confirming the trend under post-level clustering. Corrective signaling relative to directive intensity Figure 2(a) shows the main coupling result using binned estimates of corrective signaling probability with Wilson 95% confidence intervals. Corrective signaling probability increases monotonically across DI strata. In a mixed-effects logistic model with a post-level random intercept, the DI effect remains positive, with \beta=0.1276 per 1 SD increase in DI, odds ratio =1.136 and approximate 95% interval [1.043,\,1.237] . Randomized permutation null test Permuting corrective labels across comments ( B=1{,}000 ) yields slope estimates concentrated near zero, while the observed DI–corrective slopes lie in the extreme tail (two-sided permutation p_{\mathrm{perm}}=0.008 for the simple logistic slope without a post-level random intercept, and p_{\mathrm{perm}}=0.001 for the binned slope; Fig. 2(b) ). (a) Corrective signaling scales with directive intensity (DI). The red points show binned estimates of the probability that a reply is corrective, with Wilson 95% confidence intervals in green. Bins separate DI =0 posts from higher-DI posts grouped by quantiles. A logistic-fit overlay is included as a visual guide. (b) Permutation null test for the DI–corrective coupling. Left: Null distribution of the simple logistic regression slope \beta_{\mathrm{simple}} (standardized DI \rightarrow corrective; no post-level random intercept ) under random permutation of corrective labels across comments ( B=1{,}000 ). Right: Null distribution of the binned-probability slope (corrective probability vs. DI-bin index) under the same permutations. Vertical red lines mark the observed, unpermuted slopes: \beta_{\mathrm{simple}}=0.1146 with p_{\mathrm{perm}}=0.00799 , and binned slope =0.03916 with p_{\mathrm{perm}}\approx 0.001 . (c) Event-aligned change after the first corrective response. Each point is a regulatable thread ( n=32 ) with at least one comment before and after the first corrective response time t_{0} within a \pm 12 hour window and with nonzero directive intensity before t_{0} (max DI_{comment} before t_{0}>0 ). The x-axis shows \Delta\overline{DI}_{comment} (mean DI_{comment} after t_{0} minus mean DI_{comment} before t_{0} within the \pm 12 hour window). The vertical axis enumerates regulatable threads and is jittered only to separate points visually. The thin vertical line marks 0 (no change) and the red thick vertical line marks the median. Figure 2: Main results and robustness checks relating directive intensity to corrective signaling. (a) Corrective signaling probability increases with directive intensity (DI). (b) Permutation null tests for the DI–corrective coupling. (c) Event-aligned within-thread change after the first corrective response. Event-aligned patterns following the first corrective response To probe whether corrective signaling is followed by reduced subsequent directive language within threads, we computed a comment-level directive intensity DI_{comment} using the same lexicon as post-level DI and aligned each thread at the timestamp t_{0} of its first corrective response. We compared DI_{comment} before vs. after t_{0} within a symmetric \pm 12 hour window, for the threads with at least one comment on each side of t_{0} . Because many surrounding comments have DI_{comment}=0 , the median change across all usable threads is near zero. To focus on threads where within-thread regulation is measurable, we define regulatable threads as those that (i) have at least one comment before and after t_{0} in the window and (ii) exhibit nonzero directive intensity before t_{0} (max DI_{comment} before t_{0}>0 ). Among the regulatable threads ( n=32 ), the paired change in mean comment-level directive intensity \Delta\overline{DI}_{comment} (after minus before) is negative on average, with mean =-0.182 and 95% bootstrap CI [-0.358,\,0.013] , a median =-0.225 and 95% bootstrap CI [-0.333,\,-0.104] , as shown in Fig. 2(c) . As a robustness check, a fixed- N comparison (last 5 comments before vs. first 5 after) yields a similar negative median (median =-0.300 , 95% bootstrap CI [-0.400,\,0] ). Although these event-aligned patterns do not establish causality, they are consistent with an endogenous negative-feedback interpretation. Within-agent fixed-effects check Using agent IDs and timestamps, we performed a within-agent fixed-effects regression in which the next

Read the complete text