A forward analytical model for the optical selection bias on galaxy cluster lensing profiles

M. Costanzi, H.-Y. Wu, J. H. Esteves, S. Grandis, C. To, M. Aguena · 2026

Read A forward analytical model for the optical selection bias on galaxy cluster lensing profiles by M. Costanzi, H.-Y. Wu, J. H. Esteves, S. Grandis, C. To, M. Aguena (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-05833.txt.

Introduction

Costanzi and five colleagues model optical selection bias in galaxy cluster lensing from line-of-sight projections. A scale-dependent bias parametrization plus off-axis halo contributions captures two-halo profile dependence on richness boosts and redshift. Validated on a DES Y3-like catalog, the model recovers projected profile bias against mass-matched random samples.

Catalog record

CREATORM. Costanzi, H.-Y. Wu, J. H. Esteves, S. Grandis, C. To, M. Aguena
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52273
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.05833

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A forward analytical model for the optical selection bias on galaxy cluster lensing profiles M. Costanzi, H.-Y. Wu, J. H. Esteves, S. Grandis, C. To, M. Aguena Abstract Cluster catalogs selected by optical properties are subject to selection biases, primarily arising from unresolved systems along the line of sight. These biases affect key observables for cluster cosmology, such as the lensing signal and clustering statistics. In this work, we present a fully predictive forward analytical model to quantify the impact of optical-selection bias due to projection effects on cluster density profiles. This is achieved by introducing a scale-dependent parametrization of the optical cluster bias, whose small- and large-scale behaviour is set by the amplitude of projection effects, and by expressing the two-halo component of the density profile in terms of the contributions from off-axis halos along the line of sight. As a case study, we consider a DES Y3-like cluster catalog and validate our model against simulated samples. Our model successfully captures the dependence of the two-halo component on richness boosts induced by projections, as well as its evolution with richness and redshift. It also recovers the overall bias in the projected density profile relative to a randomly selected sample with the same mass distribution. The framework presented here provides a consistent methodology for modeling the impact of line-of-sight structures on the observed richness and density profiles of optically selected clusters, directly linking selection biases to the underlying cosmology and survey specifications. Figure 1: Illustration of projection effects on a target cluster with \lambda^{\rm tr} member galaxies at redshift z^{\rm ob} . Each i -th halo along the line of sight contributes to the cluster’s observed richness with a fraction of its own richness, which depends on the redshift separation and overlapping area: \rho^{\rm prj}_{i}=\lambda_{i}w(z_{i},z^{\rm ob})f_{A,i} (see equations 3 and 4 ). The same systems contribute to the observed projected density profile according to their halo properties and projected angular separation from the target cluster \theta_{i} (see equation 13 ). I Introduction Galaxy clusters are multi-component systems made of stars, galaxies, hot plasma (the intra-cluster medium), and dark matter. This multi-component nature allows us to detect and study these systems at different wavelengths, such as X-ray, millimeter and optical bands. In photometric surveys, galaxy clusters are detected as overdensities of galaxies, and the richness of the system – a weighted sum of the number of putative member galaxies – is often used as a mass proxy for sample selection. Therefore, systems with their main axis aligned along to the line of sight, more concentrated, and with rich structures in projection have a larger chance to be detected and included in the catalog ( Wu et al. 2022 ; Zhang et al. 2023b ; Lee et al. 2025 , e.g.) . In particular, projection effects due to the limited resolution achievable along the line of sight have been shown to bias high the cluster density profile of optically-selected clusters by 10-20\% on scales relevant for mass calibration through weak lensing measurements ( Sunayama et al. 2020 ; Wu et al. 2022 ; Salcedo et al. 2024 , e.g.) . If not properly modeled these effects can lead to biases in the cluster mass estimates ( Nyarko Nde et al. 2025 , e.g.) , which, in turn, translate into systematic biases in the cosmological parameters inferred from optical cluster catalogs ( DES Collaboration et al. 2020 ) . Several approaches have been proposed to model or calibrate this selection bias: Salcedo et al. 2024 used a simulation-based approach to emulate stacked cluster lensing profiles and infer observable-mass relation parameters for the DES Y1 cluster sample; Sunayama 2023 quantified the large-scale boost of the cluster lensing profile from SDSS data using cluster-galaxy cross-correlation functions ( Zhou et al. 2024 , see also) . Conversely, in the cosmological analyses of Sunayama et al. 2024 and DES Collaboration et al. 2025 the authors assumed an analytical template for the selection bias and marginalized over its model parameters. In this paper, we propose an analytical derivation to estimate the selection bias of optically selected clusters, without free parameters, which depends upon the assumed halo occupation distribution, cosmological model, cluster finder, and survey specifications. We focus on the bias induced by projection effects, which affect scales relevant for weak lensing mass calibration. In particular, we aim to reproduce the optical selection bias on cluster radial density profiles due to correlated structures as a function of richness and redshift. To this end, we first model the clustering bias of a richness-selected sample, and then derive the corresponding projected density profile. As a case study, we assume an optically selected cluster catalog built with the red sequence Matched-filter Probabilistic Percolation cluster finder algorithm ( Rykoff et al. 2014 , redMaPPer;) using Dark Energy Survey 1 1 1 https://www.darkenergysurvey.org; DES Year 3 data release: https://des.ncsa.illinois.edu/releases/y3a2/Y3key-cluster. (DES) Year 3-like photometric data ( DES Collaboration et al. 2025 ) . Comparing our model predictions to synthetic data, we show the capability of our model to reproduce the scale dependence and amplitude of the bias, as well as its dependence on the strength of projection effects. Despite its simplicity – e.g. we neglect orientation and concentration bias – the model provides a useful tool to estimate the impact of projection effects on cluster density profiles on scales relevant for their mass calibration, which can be tuned to the specifics of the cluster finder and survey data. The paper is organized as follows. In section II , we present the model for the optical cluster bias and the projected density profile. Section III describes the case study and the construction of the mock cluster catalog. The analysis and interpretation of the results, together with comparisons to synthetic data, are provided in section IV . Finally, section V summarizes our findings and conclusions. II Model Our model builds on the observation that the same line-of-sight structures that contribute to the observed richness also affect the projected density profile (see e.g. figure 1 ). Consequently, a larger projection-induced boost in richness, \Delta^{\rm prj} , implies a more crowded environment along the line of sight, which in turn enhances the projected density profile. Therefore, if we can predict the mean number of halos projected along the line of sight of a cluster as a function of \Delta^{\rm prj} and angular separation \theta from its center, we can also predict their contribution to the observed density profile. To this end, we first derive an expression for the optical cluster bias as a function of \Delta^{\rm prj} and projected angular separation (section II.1 ). This relation then allows us to estimate the mean contribution of correlated structures to the projected density profile by summing the contributions of halos projected at different off-axis angles \theta (section II.2 ). The framework developed in this work builds upon the approach introduced by Costanzi et al. 2019 , in which the observed richness, \lambda^{\rm ob} , is treated as a noisy measurement of the intrinsic (true) richness, \lambda^{\rm tr} – i.e. the unobservable true number of member galaxies satisfying the survey selection criteria – which depends on cluster mass. Specifically, we assume \lambda^{\rm ob}=\lambda^{\rm tr}+\Delta^{\rm prj} , where \Delta^{\rm prj} accounts for the

Read the complete text