Quantum Hilbert Space Fragmentation and Entangled Frozen States
Zihan Zhou, Tian-Hua Yang, Bo-Ting Chen · 2026
Read Quantum Hilbert Space Fragmentation and Entangled Frozen States by Zihan Zhou, Tian-Hua Yang, Bo-Ting Chen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-05218.txt.
Introduction
Zhou, Yang, and Chen find rank deficiency of the Hamiltonian in a fragmented model drives quantum Hilbert space fragmentation. Rank deficiency creates local null directions generating entangled frozen states, embedded in mobile Krylov sectors that do not evolve. With a non-empty entangled frozen subspace, the mobile sector splits into a quantum Krylov subspace and an entangled frozen subspace. The mechanism is shown in four models of increasing symmetry. They introduce weak and strong quantum fragmentation: weak-case block counts stay O(1) with GOE statistics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zihan Zhou, Tian-Hua Yang, Bo-Ting Chen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 128498 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.05218
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum Hilbert Space Fragmentation and Entangled Frozen States Zihan Zhou, Tian-Hua Yang, Bo-Ting Chen Abstract We find that rank deficiency of the local Hamiltonian in a classically fragmented model is the key mechanism leading to quantum Hilbert space fragmentation. The rank deficiency produces local null directions that can generate entangled frozen states (EFS): entangled states embedded in mobile classical Krylov sectors that do not evolve under Hamiltonian dynamics. When the entangled frozen subspace is non-empty, the mobile classical sector splits into a mobile quantum Krylov subspace and an entangled frozen subspace, and the model exhibits quantum fragmentation. We establish this mechanism in four models of increasing symmetry structure: an asymmetric qubit projector with no symmetry, the ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} -symmetric GHZ projector, a ℤ 3 \mathbb{Z}_{3} -symmetric cyclic qutrit projector, and the Temperley-Lieb model. For the asymmetric and GHZ projector models, we obtain closed-form expressions for irreducible Krylov dimensions, degeneracies, and sector multiplicities. The all-mobile-sector EFS in these two models exhibits a sub-volume-law bipartite entanglement entropy scaling as S ∼ L S\sim\sqrt{L} . Further, we introduce the notion of weak and strong quantum fragmentation, the quantum counterpart of the weak-strong distinction in classical fragmentation. After removing the EFS, the mobile quantum Krylov subspace decomposes into irreducible blocks. In the weak case, the number of irreducible blocks remains 𝒪 ( 1 ) \mathcal{O}(1) , each is individually ergodic with Gaussian Orthogonal Ensemble (GOE) level statistics, and the unresolved spectrum follows an m m GOE distribution. In the strong case, the number of irreducible blocks grows with system size, and the gap-ratio distribution approaches Poisson as L → ∞ L\to\infty . Introduction. — Hilbert space fragmentation (HSF) 55 ; 27 ; 36 ; 40 ; 37 ; 50 ; 25 ; 10 ; 11 ; 12 ; 49 ; 65 ; 34 ; 4 ; 28 ; 20 ; 10 ; 16 ; 63 ; 62 ; 15 ; 14 is a mechanism for ergodicity breaking in which the Hilbert space decomposes into exponentially many dynamically disconnected Krylov subspaces, beyond what conventional symmetries dictate. Unlike many-body localization 48 ; 43 ; 61 ; 44 ; 2 , which relies on disorder, and quantum many-body scars 56 ; 5 ; 60 ; 59 ; 41 ; 35 ; 51 , which arise from fine-tuned eigenstates, HSF is generated by local algebraic constraints and persists at all energy scales. HSF comes in two varieties: classical and quantum fragmentation 37 ; 50 ; 12 ; 30 ; 31 ; 54 . In classical fragmentation, Krylov sectors are spanned by product states. A systematic understanding of this case has been achieved through semigroup word problems 4 , where the glassy dynamics of local rewriting rules generates a combinatorial structure of frozen states and mobile sectors. Classical fragmentation is classified as strong if the largest irreducible Krylov subspace \mathcal{K}_{{\rm max},L} has measure zero compared relative to the full Hilbert space in the thermodynamic limit, i.e. {\dim}\mathcal{K}_{{\rm max},L}/{\dim}\,\mathcal{H}\to 0 as L\to\infty and weak if {\dim}\mathcal{K}_{{\rm max},L}/{\dim}\,\mathcal{H}\sim\mathcal{O}(1) . Quantum fragmentation goes further: it decomposes the classical Krylov sectors themselves into sub-sectors spanned by entangled states. This phenomenon is far less understood. The only well-studied example is the Temperley-Lieb (TL) model 37 ; 38 ; 39 , where the TL algebra {\rm TL}_{L-1}(\delta) 58 ; 26 and its U_{q}(\mathfrak{sl}_{2}) quantum group commutant provide closed-form expressions for Krylov dimensions and degeneracies. Quantum fragmentation has also been observed in the quantum breakdown model 32 ; 11 ; 22 ; 23 ; 33 ; 21 and the quantum East model 10 ; 63 ; 16 , though without a comparably developed analytical framework. Since the TL model remains the only fully understood example, two fundamental questions are open. First, what is the minimal ingredient for quantum fragmentation? The TL model carries so much algebraic structure (the Jones relation, a quantum group commutant) that it is unclear which part is essential and which is incidental. Second, what role do symmetries play? Symmetries act locally and carry distinct physical consequences from the general (non-local) commutant algebra, yet whether they are a prerequisite for quantum fragmentation, or merely an optional add-on, has not been established. In this Letter, we answer both questions. We find that the key mechanism leading to quantum fragmentation is the rank deficiency of local coupling terms in a classically fragmented model. No symmetry is required. The rank deficiency creates entangled frozen states (EFS): entangled states within mobile classical Krylov sectors that do not evolve under the Hamiltonian dynamics. Each mobile classical sector then splits into an entangled-frozen Krylov subspace \mathcal{K}_{\rm EFS} and a complementary mobile quantum Krylov subspace \mathcal{K}_{q} . Symmetry does not create quantum fragmentation, but when present, it can further decompose the mobile quantum Krylov subspaces if they are closed under the symmetry transformation. We establish this picture in four models of increasing structure. The asymmetric triplet-flip projector provides the minimal example, showing that quantum fragmentation exists even without symmetry. The GHZ and cyclic qutrit projectors then show how \mathbb{Z}_{2} and \mathbb{Z}_{3} symmetries organize the mobile quantum space \mathcal{K}_{q} through symmetry-related degeneracies and charge sectors, without changing the underlying mechanism. In both the asymmetric and GHZ projector models, the all-mobile-sector EFS displays an unusual analytically tractable sub-volume entanglement entropy S\sim\sqrt{L} . Finally, the TL model shows how additional algebraic constraints, encoded in the Jones relation, qualitatively change the structure of \mathcal{K}_{q} by further decomposing it into many irreducible components. These increasing structural constraints lead to a natural distinction between weak and strong quantum fragmentation. After removing the EFS, the weak case retains at least one irreducible block occupying a finite fraction of \mathcal{K}_{q} , whereas in the strong case every irreducible block occupies a vanishing fraction. In the models studied here, the weak-strong distinction is clearly reflected in the gap-ratio statistics. Mechanism. — Consider a one-dimensional chain of L sites with local Hilbert space dimension d , and let S=\{0,1,\ldots,d-1\} be the local alphabet. A local word of length r is an element w=(s_{1},\dots,s_{r})\in S^{r} , and we associate to it the basis state \ket{w}=\ket{s_{1}}\otimes\cdots\otimes\ket{s_{r}} . A semigroup dynamics is specified by a presentation \tilde{G}=\langle S\,|\,R\rangle , where R is a set of relations between words over S . We assume that R only relates words of the same length \ell . This semigroup corresponds to a family of Hamiltonians, with local terms h_{i}=\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}w^{\prime},w\in R_{\alpha}\end{subarray}}g^{w^{\prime},w}\ket{w^{\prime}}\bra{w}_{[i,i+\ell-1]}\,, (1) where R_{\alpha} denotes the \alpha -th equivalence class in R , g^{w,w^{\prime}} are coupling matrix between states in R_{\alpha} . The total Hamiltonian is H=\sum_{i=1}^{L-\ell+1}J_{i}h_{i} with J_{i} a random variable capturing the local strength of the interaction. The classical Krylov sectors are the connected components of the graph whose vertices are computational basis states and whose edges connect states related by a single application of a relation in R . A basis state forming a dimension-1 sector is a product frozen state ; collectively these states span the product-frozen subspace \mathcal{F}_{\rm prod} . Classical fragmentation is strong if the dimension of the largest Krylov subspace compared with the full Hilbert space dimension goes to zero in the thermodynamic limit, i.e. {\rm dim}\mathcal{K}_{{\rm max},L}/{\rm dim}\mathcal{H}\rightarrow 0,L\rightarrow\infty . If {\rm dim}\mathcal{K}_{{\rm max},L}/{\rm dim}\mathcal{H}\rightarrow\mathcal{O}(1),L\rightarrow\infty , the fragmentation is weak. Quantum fragmentation can arise when the coupling