Investigating Ethical Data Communication with Purrsuasion : An Educational Game about Negotiated Data Disclosure

Krisha Mehta, Sami Elahi, and Alex Kale · 2026

Read Investigating Ethical Data Communication with Purrsuasion : An Educational Game about Negotiated Data Disclosure by Krisha Mehta, Sami Elahi, and Alex Kale (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-05200.txt.

Introduction

Mehta, Elahi, and Kale give Purrsuasion, a visual game that makes ethical data talk visible. Sharing binds arise where constraints forbid full sharing, and problems involve talks between actors rather than lies. Players act as givers making visuals under sharing constraints and seekers asking and giving contracts. In a college data science class of 27 students, play data supports analysis of talk, problem solving, and trust growth. Trouble seeing ideal visuals leads to settling in making and trouble tracing intent, and scoring uses a rough rubric.

Catalog record

CREATORKrisha Mehta, Sami Elahi, and Alex Kale
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE83855
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.05200

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Investigating Ethical Data Communication with Purrsuasion : An Educational Game about Negotiated Data Disclosure Krisha Mehta, Sami Elahi, and Alex Kale Abstract Data communication entails ethical dilemmas where situational constraints forbid full disclosure of source data. Whereas visualization research and pedagogy often frames ethics as a matter of individuals making deceptive design choices or being misled, disclosure problems involve negotiation between pro-social actors. To provide observability into these situated judgments, we contribute Purrsuasion , an open-source visualization game where participants play the roles of (i) data providers designing visualizations subject to disclosure constraints and (ii) data seekers requesting information and awarding a contract. We deploy Purrsuasion in an undergraduate data science class (N = 27), gathering gameplay data to support a mixed-methods analysis of students’ communication dynamics, problem solving, and trust formation. We find that difficulties envisioning an ideal visualization solution lead to satisficing in visualization authoring and difficulties attributing authorial intent. Given these challenges, we approach scoring student solutions by developing a heuristic rubric that supports sociotechnical judgments of disclosure adherence. \onlineid 1008 \vgtccategory Research \authorfooter Krisha Mehta is with the University of Chicago. E-mail: [email protected] Sami Elahi is with the University of Chicago. E-mail: [email protected] Alex Kale is with the University of Chicago. E-mail: [email protected]. \teaser In Purrsuasion , students (1) navigate a set of data communication scenarios represented by show-hide puzzles, and (2) ideate potential design solutions in an attempt to balance an information need with a disclosure constraint. (3) Instructors use a heuristic rubric to evaluate the visualization’s success in balancing the conflicting, situated requirements of the puzzle. Introduction keywords Visualization, disclosure, ethics, games Visualization research and pedagogy treats ethical data communication as a central concern. Numerous studies investigate the impact on human data interpretation when visualizations incorporate potentially misleading design patterns—e.g., truncating the y-axis [ 9 , 29 ] , violating user expectations based on graphical conventions [ 52 , 22 , 48 ] , or distorting the correspondence between data and visual encoding channels [ 10 , 25 , 32 ] . Work on visualization literacy develops assessments of a chart user’s ability to avoid being misled by such design patterns (e.g., [ 18 , 26 ] ). Visualization pedagogy tends to emphasize identifying and avoiding specific deceptive practices as a learning objective, with coursework often asking students to either find or create examples that commit these violations as an exercise to prompt reflection. In this way, both research and teaching rely on conceptualizations of deceptive visualization that focus on the cognition and design processes of individuals, rather than situating ethical visualization in the communication dynamics of two or more people. We argue that this focus on individual judgment risks fixating on misuse of visualization as a moral hazard, while underexamining legitimate use cases that require designers to avoid full transparency with their audience. In practice, visualization designers encounter morally gray scenarios where tensions arise between their responsibilities to different parties. For example, an environmental analyst may need to communicate pollution peaks while masking proprietary sensor locations. (Fig. Investigating Ethical Data Communication with Purrsuasion : An Educational Game about Negotiated Data Disclosure ). The environmental analyst is not a malicious actor seeking to deceive, but a pro-social one puzzling out a complex design trade-off. Following prior work, we characterize such design scenarios as problems of data disclosure [ 33 ] , which require designers to balance showing information that is useful to their audience and hiding information they are constrained not to reveal. We define design goals for data disclosure problems in terms of the specific data signals (e.g., outliers, clusters, gaps) or aspects of a dataset that are the subject an audience’s information need or a designer’s data sharing constraint. Design scenarios requiring selective data disclosure present critical unmet challenges for the visualization community. Prior work demonstrates that existing visualization tools are not built to optimize for design goals around disclosure [ 50 ] , leaving visualization designers with a “guess and check” workflow as their only recourse to find suitable designs in such scenarios [ 33 ] . Developing the judgment to navigate design trade-offs around responsible data disclosure is a critical learning outcome for data science students, yet to our knowledge it is currently missing from most data visualization curriculum. Finally, the social dynamics that surround these design scenarios—potentially motivating the behavior of a designer or the trust of their audience—lack salience in research and teaching materials. In this study, we investigate these “entangled” [ 4 ] challenges by developing a novel game platform for research and teaching, which enables us to explore problem solving and moral reasoning around selective data disclosure with our students. We present Purrsuasion , a cat-themed browser-based game that asks participants solve data disclosure problems through visualization authoring and negotiation. Players are assigned the roles of (i) a receiver or data seeker who makes a request for information and (ii) a sender or data provider who authors visualizations subject to a disclosure constraint. Each round of gameplay centers on a distinct show-hide puzzle : a design scenario where the receiver is endowed with an information need or data signal they wish to learn about, and the sender is endowed with a disclosure constraint or a data signal they are forbidden to reveal (Fig. Investigating Ethical Data Communication with Purrsuasion : An Educational Game about Negotiated Data Disclosure ). To enable scoring of visualizations as solutions to these puzzles, we define a heuristic rubric to help instructors and researchers assess disclosure adherence. We develop Purrsuasion , show-hide puzzles, and the heuristic rubric to encapsulate disclosure problems and their inherent ethical dilemmas in a controlled setting, so we can provide experiential learning for students while also gaining observability into their problem solving, communication dynamics, and trust formation in such scenarios. Presenting the interface as a game provides structure and social permission for collaboration and reflection [ 7 ] . We contribute an open-source implementation of the Purrsuasion platform as a resource for the community, including onboarding materials and instructor tools for running, scoring, and adapting the game. We also contribute a mixed-methods study based on a deployment of Purrsuasion in a visualization course for data science undergraduates at [institution redacted]. 27/33 students participating in the game consent to donate their interaction log data resulting from gameplay and fill out a survey reflecting on the ethics of data disclosure. In addition to characterizing communication dynamics, we attend in particular to how students conceptualize solutions to disclosure problems. To support this analysis, we draw on Mehta et al.’s taxonomy of disclosure tactics [ 33 ] , which provides a deductive framework for describing how design choices about data transformations determine what information is revealed in a visualization (see Section 3.2 ). Our analysis shows that students face a “gulf of envisioning” in visualization [ 44 ] , a fundamental difficulty conceiving of an optimal design to satisfy design goals around disclosure. We describe how this gulf precipitates design fixation in visualization authoring for senders, difficulties attributing authorial intent for receivers, and pitfalls in negotiated data sharing as a result. Through the development of the rubric, we discover that evaluating student solutions requires sociotechnical judgments of situated communication risks, subverting our

Read the complete text