b → c b\to c semileptonic sum rule: SU(3) F symmetry violation
Syuhei Iguro · 2026
Read b → c b\to c semileptonic sum rule: SU(3) F symmetry violation by Syuhei Iguro (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-05186.txt.
Introduction
Iguro extends the b to c sum rule to include Bs to Ds and Xib to Xic decays, giving more cross-checks. The rule checks b to c tau events for gaps. Both heavy quark rule and SU(3) flavor rule are broken in reality, so the break size must be measured. Chiral theory suggests a small break, and number work finds it smaller than lab error. He therefore constructs more new-physics-free sum rules for checks.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Syuhei Iguro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27082 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.05186
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
b → c b\to c semileptonic sum rule: SU(3) F symmetry violation Syuhei Iguro Abstract To clarify possible deviations in b → c τ ν ¯ b\to c\tau\overline{\nu} processes, the b → c b\to c semileptonic sum rule provides a valuable tool. This relation, derived based on heavy quark symmetry (HQS), offers a powerful consistency check among experimental results. In this work, we extend the previously proposed sum rule for { B → D ( ∗ ) l ν ¯ , Λ b → Λ c l ν ¯ } \{B\to D^{(*)}l\overline{\nu},\,\Lambda_{b}\to\Lambda_{c}l\overline{\nu}\} to include { B s → D s ( ∗ ) l ν ¯ , Ξ b → Ξ c l ν ¯ } \{B_{s}\to D_{s}^{(*)}l\overline{\nu},\,\Xi_{b}\to\Xi_{c}l\overline{\nu}\} , thereby enabling more useful cross-checks. Although the relation is supported by HQS and SU(3) flavor symmetry, both symmetries are broken in reality, and the size of the violation needs to be quantified to assess the validity of the sum rule. While the violation is expected to be moderate based on chiral perturbation theory, we perform a numerical evaluation and compare it with future experimental sensitivities. We find that the violation remains smaller than the expected experimental uncertainty. Therefore another new physics agnostic and predictive sum rules are constructed to check the consistency. ——————————————————————————————————————————— Keywords: Heavy quark symmetry, SU(3) flavor symmetry, b → c b\to c semileptonic sum rule I Introduction The heavy quark symmetry (HQS) 29 ; 30 ; 36 and SU(3) flavor symmetry (SU(3) F ) 23 ; 37 ; 24 are approximate symmetries of the Standard Model (SM). They offer tools for theoretical calculations in heavy hadron decays to determine fundamental SM parameters and probe the new physics (NP). They are exact in the limit of an infinite heavy quark mass and the degenerate masses of light quarks where heavy quarks and light quarks respectively correspond to Q=b,\,c and q=u,\,d,\,s . The former symmetry especially plays an important role in singly heavy flavored hadron transitions e.g. a beauty hadron ( H_{b} ) decays into a charming hadron ( H_{c} ). The typical size of the HQS violation in the H_{b}\to H_{c} decay system is estimated to be of order \epsilon_{Q}=\Lambda_{\rm QCD}/(2m_{Q})\simeq 10\sim 20\% where \Lambda_{\rm QCD} is a parameter of the QCD scale. The heavy quark effective theory (HQET) allows us to expand the hadronic transition form factors (FFs) in \epsilon_{Q} . This framework successfully describes most of the existing data well 35 . On the other hand, chiral perturbation theory suggests that SU(3) F symmetry works well in H_{b}\to H_{c} transitions 31 . This has been confirmed for B\to D^{(*)}_{(s)} transition FFs at about 5\sim 10\% 34 ; 25 . Such confirmation is not solid for baryon decays since there is no Lattice calculation for \Xi_{b}\to\Xi_{c} transition. Another source of violation arises from the hadron masses. The mass differences among bottomed hadrons and charmed hadrons respectively are about 5\% and 10\% which also affects kinematics e.g. the phase space range. On the other hand, experimental data show no significant deviation from the expectation such as \Gamma(B^{0}\to Dl\overline{\nu})/\Gamma(B_{s}\to D_{s}l\overline{\nu})=1.10\pm 0.10 and \Gamma(B^{0}\to D^{*}l\overline{\nu})/\Gamma(B_{s}\to D_{s}^{*}l\overline{\nu})=1.07\pm 0.10 35 In recent years a 4\sigma level deviation in b\to c\tau\overline{\nu} triggered theorists to propose an HQET based sum rule among a measure of lepton flavor universality violation, R_{H_{c}}={\rm{BR}}(H_{b}\to H_{c}\tau\overline{\nu})/{\rm{BR}}(H_{b}\to H_{c}l\overline{\nu}) where l being e,\,\mu , #1 #1 #1 In the conference, BaBar announced a new R_{D^{(*)}} measurement based on the semileptonic tagging method. R_{D^{*}} is measured to be slightly smaller and consistent with the SM prediction within 2\sigma for R_{D^{(*)}} . The result is away from their previous result without a clear explanation during the conference, making the situation unclear. \displaystyle\frac{R_{\Lambda_{b}}}{R_{\Lambda_{b}}^{\rm{SM}}}-\frac{1}{4}\frac{R_{D}}{R_{D}^{\rm{SM}}}-\frac{3}{4}\frac{R_{D^{*}}}{R_{D^{*}}^{\rm{SM}}}\simeq\delta\,, (1) which works as an independent cross check 16 ; 17 . #2 #2 #2 See Refs. 8 ; 9 ; 22 ; 12 for the earlier studies and Refs. 14 ; 18 for the relevant extensions. Also the HQS motivates us to replace R_{\Lambda_{c}} be R_{X_{c}} where X_{c} means the inclusive channel. A non-zero \delta which stems from the potential NP, is confirmed to be negligible compared to the current experimental uncertainty 4 ; 1 . One can substitute the experimental value in the numerator to predict others and check the experimental consistency. In the presence of approximate SU(3) F symmetry, it can be interesting to construct a set of sum rules involving the SU(3) F rotated decays, \{B\to D^{(*)}l\overline{\nu}\leftrightarrow B_{s}\to D_{s}^{(*)}l\overline{\nu}\} and \{\Lambda_{b}\to\Lambda_{c}l\overline{\nu}\leftrightarrow\Xi_{b}\to\Xi_{c}l\overline{\nu}\} . Naively we can expect that the SU(3)-extended sum rules hold approximately as in Eq. ( 1 ), thanks to the approximate SU(3) F symmetry of the form factor and relatively small violation in the mass differences. However, since the sum rules involve three R observables and rely on cancellations among them, it is not trivial to guess how small the violation \delta can be. Furthermore the relevant R observables are nice targets for the future measurements. Table 1 summarizes the current and projected experimental uncertainties of the R observables. The current (future) relative uncertainty is taken from Ref. 1 ( 7 ) for \Lambda_{c} , Ref. 4 ( 39 ) for D and D^{*} , and Ref. 7 for D_{s}^{(*)} future prospect. To our best knowledge there is no prospect available for R_{\Xi_{c}} . For D_{s}^{(*)} , due to the limited statistics, the estimation is made by combining D_{s} and D_{s}^{*} modes. For the future prospect, the number in the parentheses corresponds to the optimistic systematic uncertainty case while the other is pessimistic case for R_{\Lambda_{c}} and R_{D_{s}^{(*)}} . It is seen that there will be precise data available in future. The SU(3) F -extended sum rules would provide a further motivation for future measurements at LHCb 2 and FCC-ee 5 . Mode \Lambda_{c} D D^{*} \Xi_{c} D_{s}^{(*)} Current 31\% 6.7\% 3.9\% - - Prospect 5\,(2)\% 1.3\% 1.0\% - 5\,(2)\% Table 1: Summary table of current and mid-term future experimental relative uncertainty in the R_{H_{c}} observable. It is natural to ask whether there is an advantage in combing various SU(3) rotated modes over simply comparing the SU(3) F rotated modes e.g. R_{D}/R_{D}^{\rm SM} vs. R_{D_{s}}/R_{D_{s}}^{\rm SM} . An explicit construction of the sum rules between \Lambda_{c} and D_{s}^{(*)} modes as well as \Xi_{c} and D_{s}^{(*)} modes allows the simpler comparison among relevant decays and can convey the direct message if a good sum rule is obtained. Numerically checking this is the goal of the work. The outline of this work is given as follows: In Sec. II , we introduce our framework and then we investigate corrections to the sum rule and discuss phenomenological implications in Sec. III . We draw our conclusions in Sec. IV . II Frame work Assuming that NP contributes only to the b\to c\tau\bar{\nu} transitions, the weak effective Hamiltonian is given as, \displaystyle{\cal{H}}_{\rm{eff}}=2\sqrt{2}\,G_{F}V_{cb}\biggl[(1+ \displaystyle C_{V_{L}})O_{V_{L}}+C_{S_{L}}O_{S_{L}} (2) \displaystyle+ \displaystyle C_{S_{R}}O_{S_{R}}+C_{T}O_{T}\biggl]\,. We consider dimension-six effective operators given by, \displaystyle O_{V_{L}}=(\overline{c}\gamma^{\mu}P_{L}b)(\overline{\tau}\gamma_{\mu}P_{L}\nu_{\tau})\,,\,\,\,O_{S_{R}}=(\overline{c}P_{R}b)(\overline{\tau}P_{L}\nu_{\tau})\,, \displaystyle O_{S_{L}}=(\overline{c}P_{L}b)(\overline{\tau}P_{L}\nu_{\tau})\,,\,\,\,O_{T}=(\overline{c}\sigma^{\mu\nu}P_{L}b)(\overline{\tau}\sigma_{\mu\nu}P_{L}\nu_{\tau})\,, (3) where P_{L(R)}=(1\mp\gamma_{5})/2 is a chirality projection operator. The NP contribution is captured in the Wilson coefficients (WCs) of C_{X} with X being V_{L} , S_{L,R} , and T . They are normalized to the SM contribution with a factor of 2\sqrt{2}G_{F}V_{cb} and the SM limit corresponds to C_{X}=0 . We also assume that the neutrinos are left-handed. #3