Azimuthal Dust Polarization from Aerodynamically Aligned Grains as Evidence for the Streaming Instability in Protoplanetary Disks numpy ( 20 ) , matplotlib ( 31 )
Zhe-Yu Daniel Lin (林哲宇), Jeonghoon Lim (임정훈), Jacob B. Simon, Zhi-Yun Li, Daniel Carrera, Manuel Fernández-López, Rachel Harrison, Rixin Li (李日新), Leslie W. Looney, Ian W. Stephens, Haifeng Yang · 2026
Read Azimuthal Dust Polarization from Aerodynamically Aligned Grains as Evidence for the Streaming Instability in Protoplanetary Disks numpy ( 20 ) , matplotlib ( 31 ) by Zhe-Yu Daniel Lin (林哲宇), Jeonghoon Lim (임정훈), Jacob B. Simon, Zhi-Yun Li, Daniel Carrera, Manuel Fernández-López, Rachel Harrison, Rixin Li (李日新), Leslie W. Looney, Ian W. Stephens, Haifeng Yang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-05122.txt.
Introduction
Lin and 10 co-authors present dust polarization from aligned grains as evidence for the instability in protoplanetary disks. Dust polarization in protoplanetary disks has revealed large grains aligned along their long axis following the disk's azimuthal direction. A badminton alignment predicts large grains align with their long axes following the direction of gas flow felt by the dust. With 3D streaming instability simulations, they find the field is radial in low dust-to-gas ratio. In high dust-to-gas ratio, it is azimuthal, matching polarization angles.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhe-Yu Daniel Lin (林哲宇), Jeonghoon Lim (임정훈), Jacob B. Simon, Zhi-Yun Li, Daniel Carrera, Manuel Fernández-López, Rachel Harrison, Rixin Li (李日新), Leslie W. Looney, Ian W. Stephens, Haifeng Yang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47424 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.05122
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Azimuthal Dust Polarization from Aerodynamically Aligned Grains as Evidence for the Streaming Instability in Protoplanetary Disks numpy ( 20 ) , matplotlib ( 31 ) Zhe-Yu Daniel Lin (林哲宇), Jeonghoon Lim (임정훈), Jacob B. Simon, Zhi-Yun Li, Daniel Carrera, Manuel Fernández-López, Rachel Harrison, Rixin Li (李日新), Leslie W. Looney, Ian W. Stephens, Haifeng Yang Abstract (Sub)millimeter dust polarization in protoplanetary disks has revealed the presence of large ( ∼ 100 \sim 100 μ \mu m) dust grains that are aligned along their long axis following the azimuthal direction of the disk. The novel Badminton Birdie-like Aerodynamic Alignment predicts large grains to align with their long axes following the direction of gas flow experienced by the dust, denoted as the 𝑨 \boldsymbol{A} -field. With 3D streaming instability (SI) simulations, we find that the 𝑨 \boldsymbol{A} -field is predominantly in the radial direction in regions of low dust-to-gas ratio, but in the azimuthal direction in regions of high dust-to-gas ratio. Through polarized radiation transfer, we find that the resulting polarization angle indeed follows the disk azimuthal direction in the high dust density regions. Therefore, the azimuthal dust polarization pattern, as observed in an increasing number of disks, especially at relatively long millimeter wavelengths, offers evidence of ongoing SI in protoplanetary disks. show][email protected] I Introduction Dust grains play a crucial role in protoplanetary disks, serving as the raw material for planetesimals and planets, and also determining the structure and evolution of disks ( 16 ; 7 , e.g.) . Spatially resolved millimeter-wave polarization has provided critical insights into the properties of dust in these disks ( 36 ; 71 ; 39 ; 19 ; 59 ; 1 ; 64 ; 5 ; 13 ; 74 ; 23 ; 65 ; 68 ; 4 ; 29 ; 76 ; 69 ; 49 ; 53 ; 21 ; 54 ; 12 , e.g.) . Since the first polarization detections at disk scale ( 63 ; 70 ) , it is now abundantly clear that the origin of polarization can be due to scattering ( 35 ; 82 ; 84 , e.g.) , aligned grains ( 1 ; 54 ; 18 , e.g.) , or both effects combined ( 83 ; 85 ; 52 ; 69 , e.g.) . The origin of aligned grains in protoplanetary disks is currently a mystery, but we list a few key empirical constraints on the geometrical properties of grains. First, the fact that grains can scatter millimeter wavelength radiation requires grain sizes to be at least \sim 100 \mu m ( 35 ; 82 ; 50 , e.g.) , which is significantly larger than the typical \sim 0.1 \mu m interstellar medium grains. Second, while grains are generally triaxial, polarization infers grains aligned predominantly by the long axes making them effectively act like prolate grains for polarization. Third, the alignment of the grain’s long axis is in the azimuthal direction around the disk. These constraints come simply from the axisymmetry of disks which determines the azimuthal variation of polarization fraction and polarization angle ( 85 ; 56 ) . An addition to the third constraint is that in some cases, there are reported deviations to alignment in the azimuthal direction by 4.5^{\circ} for AS 209 ( 55 ) , 7.3^{\circ} for GG Tau ( 76 ) , and 4^{\circ} for HL Tau (Xu et al. in prep.). Relative to the disk rotation directions, all are trailing spirals. Explaining how and why the large grains are azimuthally aligned and effectively prolate in shape has proven difficult. Historically, grains in the interstellar medium (ISM) are shown to be aligned to the magnetic field ( \boldsymbol{B} -field) via RAdiative Torques (RAT) ( 15 ; 37 ; 2 , e.g.) . In short, as a grain spins, the axis of maximum inertia (i.e., the short axis) becomes aligned to its angular momentum vector ( 62 , e.g.) and both become aligned to the \boldsymbol{B} -field. Over an ensemble, which determines the polarization, the population appear as effectively oblate grains whose short axes are aligned to \boldsymbol{B} -field. Applications of RAT to protoplanetary disk geometry with the expected toroidal \boldsymbol{B} -field structure produces radially oriented polarization ( 11 ; 83 , e.g.) . The observed azimuthally aligned, effectively prolate grains immediately rule out the conventional picture applied to the ISM and calls for new physics to the grain alignment problem of protoplanetary disks. Recently, 51 proposed the Badminton Birdie-like Aerodynamic Alignment mechanism (hereafter, birdie-like alignment) where an offset in the grain center of mass to the general geometric center along the long axis of large, millimeter-sized grains can produce the necessary effectively prolate grains simply due to gas drag from gas motion relative to the grain 1 1 1 Other alignment scenarios are discussed in the discussion section. . Dust polarization traces the alignment direction of the grain following this relative motion, which we refer to as the field of aerodynamic flow — the \boldsymbol{A} -field — defined as the gas velocity relative to the dust velocity. Grains are aligned of order the stopping time, which is usually a fraction of the Keplerian time for millimeter grains ( 7 , e.g.) . The speed of alignment is a major advantage of this mechanism, especially in high-density disk environments where other mechanisms might be damped. Although birdie-like alignment can readily satisfy the polarization requirements on the shape and sizes of grains, the observed alignment direction requires an \boldsymbol{A} -field that is in the azimuthal direction which is unexpected. Assuming dust grains experience aerodynamic drag in a gaseous disk with the typical negative pressure gradient in steady state, the grains with Stokes number \ll 1 (such as the expected 100 \mu m grains) should drift inward relative to the gas ( 75 ) . As a result, the \boldsymbol{A} -field should point in the outward radial direction, which would produce radially oriented polarization under birdie-like alignment ( 51 ) . This is inconsistent with the observations of azimuthal polarization patterns, highlighting the tension between simple equilibrium dust-gas dynamics and the observations. One potential avenue is to incoporate dust feedback where local gas dynamics within a concentrated dust layer can be significantly altered by dust drag ( 57 ) . Furthermore, the time-dependent evolution of the coupled gas and dust dynamics are regularly studied in simulations of Streaming Instability (SI; e.g., 33 ). First studied by 87 in its linear regime, SI has long thought to be a promising avenue for forming planetesimals directly from relatively small grains, involving significant clumping of dust through collective aerodynamic effects ( 33 ; 10 , e.g.) . Since SI necessarily involves aerodynamic interactions between dust and gas, it begs the question: how do the flows align grains through birdie-like alignment? As explained in 67 , inward gas motion is deflected to the azimuthal direction due to the Coriolis force, making it a likely candidate for explaining the observed inferred azimuthal alignment direction. Recent advancements in SI simulations with greatly improved resolution and coverage in 3D make it feasible to address the above question ( 46 ; 48 ; 45 ; 47 ) . In this Letter, we demonstrate that SI naturally modifies the local aerodynamic flow experienced by dust grains, enabling