A Comprehensive Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of 22 James Webb Space Telescope Spectral Energy Distributions of Cool Brown Dwarfs Corner ( 21 ) , Matplotlib ( 32 ) , Numpy ( 28 )

Harshil Kothari, Michael C. Cushing, Samuel A. Beiler, Channon Visscher, Mark S. Marley, Ben Burningham, Adam C. Schneider, J. Davy Kirkpatrick · 2026

Read A Comprehensive Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of 22 James Webb Space Telescope Spectral Energy Distributions of Cool Brown Dwarfs Corner ( 21 ) , Matplotlib ( 32 ) , Numpy ( 28 ) by Harshil Kothari, Michael C. Cushing, Samuel A. Beiler, Channon Visscher, Mark S. Marley, Ben Burningham, Adam C. Schneider, J. Davy Kirkpatrick (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-05104.txt.

Introduction

Kothari and seven co-authors present an atmospheric analysis of 22 late-T and Y-type brown dwarfs, observed with JWST NIRSpec PRISM and MIRI LRS. The dataset provides the 0.95 to 12 micrometer spectra of late-T and Y-type brown dwarfs. It enables constraints on ratios of water, methane, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, ammonia, and hydrogen sulfide. They find correlations between water and methane, and carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, consistent with chemistry. They derive metallicity, correlated with water and methane, showing water and methane trace oxygen and carbon.

Catalog record

CREATORHarshil Kothari, Michael C. Cushing, Samuel A. Beiler, Channon Visscher, Mark S. Marley, Ben Burningham, Adam C. Schneider, J. Davy Kirkpatrick
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93169
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.05104

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Comprehensive Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of 22 James Webb Space Telescope Spectral Energy Distributions of Cool Brown Dwarfs Corner ( 21 ) , Matplotlib ( 32 ) , Numpy ( 28 ) Harshil Kothari, Michael C. Cushing, Samuel A. Beiler, Channon Visscher, Mark S. Marley, Ben Burningham, Adam C. Schneider, J. Davy Kirkpatrick Abstract We present a uniform atmospheric retrieval analysis of 22 late-T and Y-type brown dwarfs within 20 pc, observed with the James Webb Space Telescope NIRSpec PRISM and MIRI LRS. This dataset provides the first continuous ∼ \sim 0.95–12 μ \mu m spectroscopic coverage of late-T and Y-type brown dwarfs, which in turn enables precise constraints on their thermal structures and volume mixing ratios (VMRs) of H 2 O, CH 4 , CO, CO 2 , NH 3 , H 2 S, K, Na, and PH 3 . We find positive correlations between the VMR of H 2 {}_{\textrm{2}} O and CH 4 , and CO and CO 2 , consistent with thermochemical equilibrium chemistry. Using the VMRs, we derive atmospheric metallicity, which is positively correlated with H 2 {}_{\textrm{2}} O and CH 4 , showing H 2 {}_{\textrm{2}} O and CH 4 trace oxygen and carbon content, respectively, allowing us to effectively measure (O/H) bulk {}_{\textrm{bulk}} and (C/H) bulk {}_{\textrm{bulk}} . We also report tentative PH 3 detections in roughly half the sample, suggesting potential vertical mixing or non-equilibrium chemistry. Apart from chemical properties, we retrieve masses and radii spanning ∼ \sim 6–77 ℳ Jup N \mathcal{M}^{\textrm{N}}_{\textrm{Jup}} and ∼ \sim 0.66–1.53 ℛ Jup N \mathcal{R}^{\textrm{N}}_{\textrm{Jup}} , respectively. We compare the derived log 10 ⁡ ( g ) \log_{10}(g) ( ∼ \sim 4–5.5 [cm s -2 ]) and T eff T_{\textrm{eff}} ( ∼ \sim 350–1100 K) with Sonora Bobcat evolutionary models and find an age range of 0.4 to 10 Gyr amongst the sample. Comparing our retrieved thermal profiles with the Elf-Owl forward model thermal profiles, we find a systematic difference between the two, likely arising due to the difference in chemistry treatment. I Introduction Brown dwarfs, particularly the ones at the coldest effective temperatures ( < 600 K), present a fundamental challenge for atmospheric characterization. Their spectral energy distributions (SEDs) peak at \sim 5 \mu m, and yet for years spectroscopic observations were largely constrained to the near-infrared (1–2.5 \mu m) ( 59 ; 39 , e.g.,) due to the difficulty of observing from the ground at \lambda>2.5\mu m and the lack of space-based spectroscopic capabilities before the launch of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). 50 presented spectra of seven brown dwarfs from the Gemini-GNIRS, revealing CO features in the 3–5 \mu m wavelength range. Beyond these data, mid-infrared (2.5–30 \mu m) spectroscopy of very late-T and Y dwarfs remains sparse. Only a small number ( \sim 20) of objects later than T6 have spectral coverage from the Spitzer Space Telescope, primarily using the IRS instrument over \sim 5–15 \mu m, and those observations are limited in wavelength range and signal-to-noise. As a result, detailed spectroscopic constraints across the full near- to mid-infrared spectral energy distribution remain rare for the coldest brown dwarfs. The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has transformed the cold brown dwarf landscape. With a continuous spectral coverage from \sim 1–28 \mu m, JWST captures all of the major carbon-, nitrogen-, and oxygen-bearing molecules (H {}_{\textrm{2}} O, CH 4 , CO, CO 2 , NH 3 ) that make up the atmospheres of the coldest brown dwarfs. The unprecedented wavelength coverage from the JWST enables us to precisely determine the chemical abundances, isotopic ratios, carbon-to-oxygen ratios, metallicity, and thermal structures of these cold atmospheres ( 5 ; 37 ; 40 ) . For the first time, it is possible to draw robust conclusions about the chemical diversity and physical processes governing these cool atmospheres, paving the way for a deeper understanding of their formation and evolution. There are two techniques to model the atmospheres of brown dwarfs. The first, called forward modeling, solves for the thermal structure (i.e. the run of temperature with pressure) of the atmosphere for a give set of fundamental parameters (e.g. metallicity, surface gravity, effective temperature, etc.) assuming things such as thermochemical equilibrium, a chemistry scheme, and one-dimensional radiative-convective equilibrium. The resulting model emergent spectrum can then be compared to observations in order to infer the atmospheric properties of the brown dwarfs. The second technique, known as atmospheric retrieval, was originally developed to study planetary atmospheres in the solar system ( 16 , e.g.,) and aims to infer the thermal structure of the atmosphere along with the abundances of the major absorbers directly from the data. Retrievals have been successfully applied to L- and T-type brown dwarf spectra, yielding new insights into their chemistry, cloud formation, and elemental abundances ( 42 ; 43 ; 10 ) . Previous studies relied primarily on near-infrared spectra obtained with facilities such as the Hubble Space Telescope and ground-based instruments, which probe only a limited fraction of the emergent flux from these \lesssim 500 K atmospheres. At such low temperatures, key molecular absorbers (e.g., NH 3 , CO 2 , and other disequilibrium species) exhibit prominent features at longer wavelengths, leading to strong degeneracies in thermal structure and chemical abundances when constrained by near-infrared data alone ( 69 ; 70 ) . Consequently, retrievals of late-T and Y dwarfs based solely on near-IR spectra have carried substantial uncertainties, limiting robust conclusions about their atmospheric properties. Recent JWST studies of individual Y dwarfs have already uncovered evidence for strong vertical mixing ( 37 ) and disequilibrium chemistry in the coldest atmospheres ( 8 ; 17 ) , and in some cases suggest temperature structures that deviate from forward-model predictions ( 37 ) . While these JWST spectral analyses have provided unprecedented insights, they have largely focused on single objects, leaving open questions about population-level trends across the late-T and Y-dwarf regime. In this paper, we present a comprehensive and uniform atmospheric retrieval analysis of 22 late-T and Y-type brown dwarfs, spanning spectral types from T6 to Y1. Using low-resolution spectra from JWST, we investigate the thermal profiles, chemical abundances, and physical properties of these objects. This dataset represents the largest sample of cold brown dwarfs analyzed with JWST to date, providing a unique opportunity to explore population-level trends and variation in their atmospheric properties, allowing us to understand the diversity of brown dwarf atmospheres. In § II , we describe the observations and data reduction process. In § III , we detail the retrieval framework employed to analyze the spectra, including the model assumptions and parameter space explored. The retrieved results are presented and discussed in § IV , where we highlight key trends and correlations across the sample. Finally, in § V , we discuss our findings with respect to thermochemical equilibrium predictions and forward models, and discuss the implications for understanding the atmospheric physics and chemistry of cold brown dwarfs. II The Spectra We have analyzed spectra of 22 brown dwarfs within 20 pc of the Sun with spectral types ranging from T6 to Y1. The spectra of these brown dwarfs were observed as a part of JWST General Observers (GO) program #2302. For more details about the sample selection please

Read the complete text