Identification and Inference in Nonlinear Dynamic Network Models
Diego Vallarino · 2026
Read Identification and Inference in Nonlinear Dynamic Network Models by Diego Vallarino (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-04961.txt.
Introduction
Vallarino studies identification in nonlinear dynamic systems on unknown interaction networks. The system evolves through an unseen link matrix that spreads shocks via a nonlinear operator. He shows the network cannot be found in general, since finding it needs varied spectral patterns. It can be found when the network creates distinct covariance patterns through uneven boosting of modes. When the spectrum narrows, the network mimics common shocks, and it cannot be found.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Diego Vallarino |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63579 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.04961
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Identification and Inference in Nonlinear Dynamic Network Models Diego Vallarino Abstract We study identification and inference in nonlinear dynamic systems defined on unknown interaction networks. The system evolves through an unobserved dependence matrix governing cross-sectional shock propagation via a nonlinear operator. We show that the network structure is not generically identified, and that identification requires sufficient spectral heterogeneity. In particular, identification arises when the network induces non-exchangeable covariance patterns through heterogeneous amplification of eigenmodes. When the spectrum is concentrated, dependence becomes observationally equivalent to common shocks or scalar heterogeneity, leading to non-identification. We provide necessary and sufficient conditions for identification, characterize observational equivalence classes, and propose a semiparametric estimator with asymptotic theory. We also develop tests for network dependence whose power depends on spectral properties of the interaction matrix. The results apply to a broad class of economic models, including production networks, contagion models, and dynamic interaction systems. Keywords: Identification, Nonlinear Dynamic Systems, Network Dependence, Spectral Analysis, Latent Heterogeneity, Semiparametric Inference 1 Introduction Many economic environments are characterized by interactions across agents connected through networks whose structure is not directly observed. Examples include production networks, financial contagion, spatial interactions, social learning, and dynamic systems with cross-sectional dependence. In these settings, aggregate outcomes emerge from the propagation of shocks through an underlying interaction structure, often represented by a network operator or dependence matrix. When this structure is unobserved, the problem of recovering it from observed data becomes a fundamental question of identification. A large literature studies economic models with network interaction. In production and financial networks, the propagation of shocks depends on the pattern of input–output or exposure linkages across agents ( 2 ; 3 ) . In social and spatial models, outcomes depend on weighted averages of neighboring units, generating cross-sectional dependence that complicates both estimation and identification ( 25 ; 5 ; 19 ; 12 ) . In dynamic environments, complementarities and coordination effects may produce nonlinear responses to small perturbations, including multiple equilibria and tipping points ( 11 ; 26 ; 14 ) . Across these literatures, a common insight emerges: economic outcomes depend not only on individual characteristics, but on the structure of interactions that link agents together. Parallel developments in econometrics emphasize that identification in such environments requires non-exchangeable patterns of dependence. Spatial econometrics shows that heterogeneous exposure across units is necessary to distinguish interaction effects from common shocks ( 5 ; 6 ) . Network econometrics highlights the role of topology in determining the feasibility of inference ( 19 ; 10 ; 12 ; 13 ) . Recent advances extend asymptotic theory to settings with general network dependence structures, allowing for inference under non-metric dependence patterns ( 24 ) . In duration models, identification may arise from nonlinear accumulation of risk when latent heterogeneity is structured rather than exchangeable, although identification remains fragile when baseline hazards and frailty components are flexibly specified ( 4 ; 1 ; 18 ) . These results point to a general principle: identification depends on the structure of cross-sectional dependence, not merely on its presence. Despite these advances, most existing results are derived in linear or parametric settings. In many economic applications, however, propagation mechanisms are inherently nonlinear. Capacity constraints, threshold effects, and feedback loops generate state-dependent amplification, in which the impact of shocks depends on the configuration of the system. Such nonlinear dynamics arise in financial contagion, infrastructure networks, and production systems, where stability is governed by spectral properties of the interaction operator rather than by local behavior alone ( 3 ; 15 ) . More generally, nonlinear evolution on networks may exhibit amplification regimes, heavy-tailed outcomes, and abrupt transitions driven by the interaction between topology and dynamics ( 31 ) . A key difficulty in these environments is that the interaction structure is typically unobserved. Different network operators may generate identical observable dynamics, especially when nonlinearities allow common shocks, baseline trends, or shared heterogeneity to mimic network effects. As a result, identification cannot rely solely on functional form assumptions or time variation, but instead depends on the ability to detect non-exchangeable patterns of dependence in the data. This issue is closely related to classical identification problems in social interactions, where observational equivalence arises when endogenous effects cannot be separated from contextual or correlated effects ( 25 ) . In nonlinear settings, the problem is compounded by the fact that the mapping from the network structure to observed outcomes is itself state-dependent. This paper studies identification and inference in a general class of nonlinear dynamic systems defined on unknown networks. We consider models in which the evolution of a state vector depends on an unobserved interaction matrix through a nonlinear operator. The framework encompasses linear network autoregressions, contagion models, production networks, nonlinear adjustment processes, and dynamic systems with threshold responses. Rather than imposing a specific economic structure, we derive general conditions under which the interaction matrix is identified from observed dynamics. Our first contribution is to provide a general formulation of nonlinear network dynamics with latent interaction structure. The model allows for state-dependent propagation, heterogeneous exposure across units, and nonlinear amplification mechanisms. This formulation unifies several classes of models studied separately in the literature. Our second contribution is to characterize identification in this class of models. We show that the interaction matrix is not generically identified unless the system exhibits sufficient cross-sectional heterogeneity and spectral non-degeneracy. In particular, identification arises from the eigenstructure of the network operator: when eigenvalues are sufficiently dispersed, the induced propagation mechanism generates heterogeneous amplification across units, leading to non-exchangeable covariance patterns that can be detected in the data. When the spectrum is concentrated, the induced dependence becomes observationally equivalent to common shocks or scalar heterogeneity, and identification fails. This result provides a new perspective on identification in network models. Network effects are not identified by their strength, but by their heterogeneity across the cross-section. In this sense, identification is fundamentally a spectral phenomenon: the interaction matrix is identifiable not because it generates dependence, but because it generates heterogeneous dependence across units. This insight connects the econometric problem of identification with the economic literature on network propagation, where amplification and stability are governed by spectral properties of the interaction matrix ( 2 ; 3 ; 15 ) . Our third contribution is to characterize observational equivalence in nonlinear network systems. We show that distinct interaction matrices may generate identical distributions of observable outcomes, and we derive conditions under which the equivalence class collapses to a singleton. The analysis highlights the role of nonlinear accumulation over time in transforming latent interaction structure into observable restrictions. Our fourth contribution is to propose semiparametric estimators for the interaction matrix that remain valid without specifying the full nonlinear operator. The estimator exploits moment restrictions implied by the dynamic system and remains consistent in high-dimensional settings under sparsity conditions. We derive asymptotic theory for the estimator and show that inference is feasible even when the dimension of the network grows with the sample size. Our fifth contribution is to develop tests for the presence of network dependence that exploit spectral restrictions implied by the model. The tests allow discrimination between genuine network interaction, common shocks, and exchangeable dependence, and their power depends directly on the spectral heterogeneity of the interaction