Your Agent, Their Asset: A Real-World Safety Analysis of OpenClaw
Zijun Wang, Haoqin Tu, Letian Zhang, Hardy Chen, Juncheng Wu, Xiangyan Liu Zhenlong Yuan Tianyu Pang Michael Qizhe Shieh, Fengze Liu Zeyu Zheng Huaxiu Yao Yuyin Zhou Cihang Xie · 2026
Read Your Agent, Their Asset: A Real-World Safety Analysis of OpenClaw by Zijun Wang, Haoqin Tu, Letian Zhang, Hardy Chen, Juncheng Wu, Xiangyan Liu Zhenlong Yuan Tianyu Pang Michael Qizhe Shieh, Fengze Liu Zeyu Zheng Huaxiu Yao Yuyin Zhou Cihang Xie (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-04759.txt.
Introduction
Wang and thirteen colleagues run the first safety test of OpenClaw, an AI agent with full local access. They group an agent's lasting state into capability, identity, and knowledge, and test twelve attack scenes across four backbone models. Poisoning any one of those three parts lifts attack success from 24.6 percent to between 64 and 74 percent, with the toughest model more than tripling its risk. The best defence still fails 63.8 percent of the time under capability attacks, while file protection blocks 97 percent of injections but also stops updates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zijun Wang, Haoqin Tu, Letian Zhang, Hardy Chen, Juncheng Wu, Xiangyan Liu Zhenlong Yuan Tianyu Pang Michael Qizhe Shieh, Fengze Liu Zeyu Zheng Huaxiu Yao Yuyin Zhou Cihang Xie |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53529 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.04759
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Your Agent, Their Asset: A Real-World Safety Analysis of OpenClaw Zijun Wang, Haoqin Tu, Letian Zhang, Hardy Chen, Juncheng Wu, Xiangyan Liu Zhenlong Yuan Tianyu Pang Michael Qizhe Shieh, Fengze Liu Zeyu Zheng Huaxiu Yao Yuyin Zhou Cihang Xie Abstract OpenClaw, the most widely deployed personal AI agent in early 2026, operates with full local system access and integrates with sensitive services such as Gmail, Stripe, and the filesystem. While these broad privileges enable high levels of automation and powerful personalization, they also expose a substantial attack surface that existing sandboxed evaluations fail to capture. To address this gap, we present the first real-world safety evaluation of OpenClaw and introduce the CIK taxonomy , which unifies an agent’s persistent state into three dimensions, i.e. , C apability, I dentity, and K nowledge, for safety analysis. Our evaluations cover 12 attack scenarios on a live OpenClaw instance across four backbone models (Claude Sonnet 4.5, Opus 4.6, Gemini 3.1 Pro, and GPT-5.4). The results show that poisoning any single CIK dimension increases the average attack success rate from 24.6% to 64–74%, with even the most robust model exhibiting more than a threefold increase over its baseline vulnerability. We further assess three CIK-aligned defense strategies alongside a file-protection mechanism; however, the strongest defense still yields a 63.8% success rate under Capability-targeted attacks, while file protection blocks 97% of malicious injections but also prevents legitimate updates. Taken together, these findings show that the vulnerabilities are inherent to the agent architecture, necessitating more systematic safeguards to secure personal AI agents. Our project page is https://ucsc-vlaa.github.io/CIK-Bench . Figure 1: Overview. (Left) OpenClaw’s persistent state spans three dimensions (Capability, Identity, and Knowledge, termed CIK), each exploitable through distinct poisoning mechanisms. (Right) We conduct the first real-world safety evaluation using a two-phase attack protocol across four backbone models, demonstrating that CIK poisoning yields consistently high attack success rates. 1 Introduction Personal AI agents are increasingly deployed to manage daily tasks on behalf of their owners, even sensitive ones such as email, payments, and computer file operations ( 28 ; 26 ) . OpenClaw, as the most widely adopted platform in this category, with over 220,000 deployed instances ( 9 ) , exemplifies this trajectory. It operates with full system access on local machines and interacts with real-world services including Gmail, Stripe, and the local filesystem. Central to OpenClaw’s design philosophy is evolution , whereby the agent continuously learns and adapts through a persistent state that encompasses long-term memory ( 18 ; 17 ) , identity and behavioral configurations, and an extensible library of executable skills ( 25 ) . While this evolving nature of modern agent systems facilitates personalization, it also creates critical attack surfaces: an adversary who can access and manipulate these agent files can alter the agent behavior in lasting and harmful ways. Prior work has examined each dimension of this risk in isolation: Knowledge poisoning through fabricated memories ( 29 ) and RAG injection ( 32 ) ; Identity subversion through configuration backdoors ( 15 ) , and indirect prompt injection ( 8 ) ; and Capability exploitation through malicious skill payloads ( 11 ) and tool-calling injection ( 30 ) . Yet these efforts share critical limitations: they target a single dimension at a time and evaluate in sandboxed or simulated environments ( 24 ; 13 ; 20 ) , stopping short of assessing all three dimensions in a live, deployed system with real external services. To enable a unified real-world evaluation of how all three dimensions can be exploited and defended in a deployed personal agent, we introduce the CIK taxonomy —the first unified framework organizing the persistent evolving state of personal AI agents into Capability (executable skills), Identity (persona, values, and behavioral configuration), and Knowledge (long-term memory), as shown in Fig 1 . Specifically, we provide concrete file-level mappings of OpenClaw’s persistent state to each CIK dimension, giving the field a unified vocabulary for reasoning about attacks on persistent agent state ( 8 ) and structuring defenses. Building on the CIK taxonomy, we conduct the first real-world safety evaluation of a deployed personal AI agent in a live, real-world environment. Specifically, we instantiate OpenClaw with real Gmail, Stripe, and local filesystem integration, and design 12 impact scenarios spanning six harm categories, covering privacy violations (e.g., financial, physical, and sensitive data) and real-life harms (e.g., financial loss, social consequences, and data destruction). Each scenario is tested under four conditions: a baseline without being poisoned and independent poisoning of each CIK dimension. Finally, we evaluate this setup across four most recent backbone models from three major providers: Claude’s Sonnet 4.5 ( 3 ) , Opus 4.6 ( 2 ) , Google’s Gemini 3.1 Pro ( 7 ) , and OpenAI’s GPT-5.4 ( 16 ) . Experimental results exhibit that in the unperturbed baseline, the attack success rate (ASR) ranges from 10.0% to 36.7%. After poisoning, Knowledge attacks achieve the highest 74.4% average ASR among the three dimensions, while Capability and Identity attacks reach 68.3% and 64.3% , respectively. Even the most resistant model (Opus 4.6) reaches more than triple its 10.0% baseline under poisoning, confirming that the vulnerability is structural rather than model-specific. Qualitative case studies reveal three distinct mechanisms enabled by the CIK decomposition: Fabricated memories make unauthorized financial operations appear routine; injected trust anchors redirect sensitive data to attacker-controlled destinations; and hidden executable payloads destroy the agent’s workspace without its awareness. Moreover, we further evaluate three defense strategies aligned with the CIK taxonomy, each targeting a distinct dimension: knowledge augmentation, identity-based safety principles, and a capability-based security skill. We find that no single defense eliminates poisoning across all dimensions, with Capability-based attacks proving the most resistant. A file-protection approach reduces injection rates by up to 97% but blocks legitimate agent updates at nearly the same rate, revealing a fundamental evolution–safety tradeoff: as long as the persistent files that enable evolution are also the attack surface, separating legitimate updates from injections remains an open problem. Taken together, our findings demonstrate that state-poisoning vulnerabilities are structural, not model-specific, and motivate the need for CIK-aware security architectures. 2 Persistent State in Personal AI Agents To systematically study the safety risks of personal AI agents, we first need a structured understanding of what makes them vulnerable. We introduce OpenClaw as our evaluation target, formalize its persistent state into the CIK taxonomy, and describe the lifecycle that creates the attack surface we exploit. 2.1 OpenClaw Overview OpenClaw is a locally deployed personal AI agent that uses a frontier LLM (e.g., Claude, Gemini) as its backbone and can communicate with its owner via messaging channels (e.g., Telegram, Discord). It runs on the owner’s machine with full system access and integrates with real external services including email, financial platforms, and the local filesystem. Like many other modern AI agent assistants, the central design philosophy of OpenClaw is evolution —the agent continuously learns and adapts through persistent state (agent files that survive across sessions and are updated over time), including long-term memory ( 18 ; 17 ) , identity and behavioral configurations, and an extensible library of executable skills ( 25 ) . These files are loaded into the LLM’s context at every session and evolve over time: the agent